Michael Anthony Jewelers in West Caldwell is a highly regarded jewelry store known for its wide selection of quality jewelry and exceptional customer service. Customers appreciate the variety of items available, including engagement rings, diamond wedding bands, fine diamond and gemstone jewelry, gold bands, wedding rings, bracelets, earrings, pendants, and necklaces. They also offer men's rings, bands, and jewelry in rose gold, white gold, yellow gold, and sterling silver, along with enameled saint Christopher medals. The staff is friendly, helpful, and welcoming, making customers feel like family. Whether purchasing new jewelry or having pieces repaired or adjusted—such as watch bracelets—the team is honest, fair, and accommodating. Many customers have trusted them for over 20 years, praising their professionalism, creativity, and ability to source or create specific pieces. The store is considered better or just as good as higher-end options in larger cities, offering quality, choices, and personalized service without pressure. Overall, Michael Anthony Jewelers is the top choice for jewelry needs in the area.
The best place. Lisa, Ramona, Elena were so helpful and guided me on the right pieces.
October 2025
Amazing people working there. I just love every one of them- fast service, honest people and price good compared to others. They attend to me right away and if they’re busy with a lot of customers- they acknowledge me and tells me they’ll be right with me.
September 2025
Lisa was wonderful to work with, would highly recommend for all your jewelry needs
