Buffalo Exchange is a popular thrift store known for its unique and trendy selection of vintage clothing at reasonable prices. Customers often find great deals on designer items, with one reviewer noting a $20 jacket purchase. The store is clean and well-organized, making it easy to browse for styles that appeal to various tastes. While the prices are slightly higher than some other thrift stores, shoppers appreciate the quality of the items available, including sturdy footwear and fashionable pieces for all ages. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and selective about the items they accept for resale, which helps maintain a high standard of quality. However, some customers have noted that the selection of sizes can be disorganized, with fewer options for curvier figures. While the store offers good trade-in value for clothes, some reviewers advise against selling branded items, as they may not yield the best returns. Overall, Buffalo Exchange is a fantastic place for second-hand shopping, with a reputation for finding cool, trendy items.
Staff was kind. Was willing to purchase a few items. Did not care that they informed me that they would only give me 3% of what they would charge for the clothing but I guess that's how businesses work. Didn't have a great selection to pick from to purchase new items.
June 2026
For being second hand store I believe their prices are really high I also took in two big bags of clothing that are still brand new or in very nice condition and they only bought four pieces of clothing which I thought was ridiculous .
June 2026
Always a great experience selling and shopping here. I find the most unique and adorable clothing here (for both myself and my husband) and every week there is something different...which keeps me coming back! 🥰
