Gemelli Fine Foods is a popular and highly praised gourmet market and restaurant located in the heart of Babylon, Long Island. Known for its delicious Italian and American specialty foods, Gemelli offers a wide selection of fresh ingredients, including Italian bread, cooked appetizers, sides, pies, antipasti, and a variety of meats from their serious beef, pork, and chicken butcher shop. Customers frequently highlight the quality of their sauces, which make dishes like lasagna, veal, and chicken parmigiana especially tasty. The market is also recognized for its excellent catering service, particularly their heroes and salads, with many customers praising the fresh sliced turkey and friendly customer service. Visitors often describe the store as a cute, bustling place with an overwhelming array of choices, perfect for quick bites, picnics, or planning a feast. The staff is appreciated for their helpfulness, although some mention occasional issues like being sold out of certain items, such as diet soda, which they hope will be addressed. Overall, Gemelli Fine Foods is considered one of the top Italian markets in Suffolk County, offering high-quality food and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more.
OMG!!! The orzo salad here is the best thing on earth. I can eat at least 5 tons of this and still be OK to eat more. It is so delicious!! All the workers there are so polite and kind. If you have any questions they will automatically answer.
April 2025
Great place to get your pasta, your raviolis, or anything else you need to prepare a fine meal, their food is high-quality and the people that own it and work here are top-notch. They care about their customers.
January 2025
Catered food for Christmas and everyone enjoyed people working there are awesome too
