Post Offices near Bay Shore, NY

28 locations found near Bay Shore
View Map

“My family and I moved to Bay Shore 4 years ago, we've met a lot of friendly people but the BEST of all was our postman "Craig" he's professional and courteous, always has a charming smile, and most of all handles our package and mail with care. We've had other post people in between and they some times they'll put our mail in someone else mailbox, and I've found other people's mail in our mailbox... But with Craig I got my mail. He occasionally stops and play with my dogs, Craig has a huge heart great personality. You can tell he enjoys his job, Bay Shore Post Office is blessed the have a worker like Craig. Thank you Craig you're the best!”

2.4 Poor5 Reviews

“Out of all the employees at this facility one of them was kind and knowledgeable enough to help me. I would like to thank Fran for her kindness and for actually helping me out.”

1.9 Poor23 Reviews

“My got to Post Office.It’s small but there is never a line or long wait. I work in Bay Shore but I make the extra 5 minute drive past the Bay Shore Post Office to head here.Staff is friendly which is not the case typically at any post office/public service establishment.”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“Just had to give a shout out to Victor specifically who went out of his way to be accommodating and quickly re-package some of my packages this morning in order to be more cost efficient and practical- which he didn't have to do! He truly cares about his customers and his kindness made my day. Thank you!”

5 Superb5 Reviews

“This post office has a great staff and one of the nicest and most helpful postmasters that I have met in all my years -- keep up the good work!!! I recommend this place to all my friends and neighbors.”

3.9 Good7 Reviews

“Since the previous postal clerk left (retired) there has been a big change in this post office. The postal clerk there does not have an attitude and is always willing to help”

4.3 Superb3 Reviews

“I love this post office. The people are very nice, friendly and helpful. Even if there is a line, it moves quickly. They never have a problem answering a question. I would recommend it more but I don't want it to get more crowded.”

4 Good4 Reviews

“Great experience in getting the chance to mail a Package to a loved one. Would use them over and over again. However the Automated system does not recognize certain commands to allow me to speak to someone about prices for mailing a package.”

3.3 Good9 Reviews

“The staff are hard working and considerate. They are equipped with great skills, learned through experience.They deserve to be treated with high regard for dealing with difficult tasks.I am a real customer.”

3.7 Good3 Reviews

“USPS of EAST ISLIPBravery Honor Loyalty Sacrifice On the frontlines serving our communities in unwavering commitment and dedication honoring state and federal guidelines operating on top priority for safety. To the call of duty in these critical times for customer fulfillment collaborated with Ups SurePost bringing prestige first class service to residents and businesses. In professionalism, respect and great dignity.Structural Honor Service Excellence”

3.4 Good5 Reviews

“I am not from Islip, but from Queens, NY and was visiting a relative. I lost my receipt but two weeks ago, I was sending a package out to Florida, for my niece's birthday. Postal Clerk Mary attended me, as I walked in. She was engaging, warm and asked all the pertinent questions related to my shipment. She even asked if I needed stamps and I had forgotten, that I DID NEED stamps!I wish every Clerk in the US Post Office was as endearing, proficient and professional as: MARYI'm sorry I lost the receipt but I hope someone on the job or neighbor sees this post and that it brightens MARY'S day, as she did mine.”

3.2 Average5 Reviews

“Great people at this location! Very quick, professional, accurate & friendly. I've been coming to this location for 20+ years and have never had an issue.”

2.9 Average12 Reviews

“I would not believe a review that starts with "This is the worst post office in Suffolk County" unless you believe said person visited the well over 100 post offices in Suffolk County. Hardly ever a line, staff is always courteous and friendly. Would not blame them for following federal regulations or a delay that happened on the road probably in another state.”

3 Average4 Reviews

“Just wanted to acknowledge the courteous servi e I always receive when ever I use the Wheatley Heights Post Office. Postal worker Sam is very helpful and always greets you with a smile. Please recognize him for his extraordinary service . He deserves kudos for making a trip to the Post Office a pleasurable experience..”

2.3 Poor4 Reviews

“I am beyond grateful for the outstanding service I received today. I was trying to send a package and I was struggling with getting the package ready and trying to care for my two little ones. It was becoming impossible. Just when I was about to give up and try a different day the women who were working saw me struggling and helped me right away. There were two women who came around the counter and brought out toys for my little ones , I believe their names were Careen and Jeanette. Jeanette helped entertain my little ones while another women named Hani got my package already to ship. There are no words to describe how incredibly thankful I am for the love that was shown today. They worked together as a team to lend a helping out to me. I will forever be grateful.”

2.5 Average11 Reviews

“I can't say enough about Susana at this location who went way above and beyond helping me with a critical situation. An error was made in addressing a package when someone moved and some very important documents were lost. Susana took control of the situation in an expedient, patient, caring and professional manner. It was amazing that in a facility which handles so much mail every day she was able to locate the package and promptly get it to its correct destination. Susana was humble and acted as if she did it every day and just shrugged it off. Meanwhile, on the other end of the phone all I could think of was Superwoman. I hope that this is put in her employee file and at her next review is remembered. I also hope she is considered at the next review for employee of the month. She certainly has my vote. Thank you again Susana. You will always be the Superwoman of Smithtown to me.”

2.1 Poor7 Reviews

“They helped me even when it was technically closing time. The lady behind the counter was great and quick. I will say they lock the door behind you if it's the actual time they close but as long as you make inside they will help you before they close.”

2.2 Poor13 Reviews

“The staff today was able to rectify my missing package. They’re superb in their work, very kind, and highly patient. Thanks for everything and understanding. I was a little stressed and they helped me out.”

2.2 Poor13 Reviews

“I don't think the problem is with the Post Office workers. I think the problem is with the customers who flock to this location overwhelming the staff. Especially those who go there for things other than mailing a package/letters or getting money orders. There are plenty of other avenues to buy stamps, get passports than waste the time of these fine people. We need this location for important tasks instead. Those who want passports can go to public libraries, other government offices as well. Do some critical thinking for once and improvise.”

2.1 Poor14 Reviews

“Personally, I love this post office. The two women who work at the front are always so helpful, even after I ask them the same questions about postage over and over again lol.”

1.9 Poor13 Reviews

“Jeff from the Bohemia post office is a TOP TIER employee. I had an issue arise with my package and not only did Jeff go above and beyond to look into my issue, he also went out of his way to completely resolve my issue and fix a mistake he had NOTHING to do with creating in the first place. Employees like Jeff make everyone's lives so much easier. Please give this man a raise!! We love Jeff and the Bohemia post office!”

1.9 Poor14 Reviews

“After a Christmas gift was delayed almost 2 months because of international shipping, Lucinda called me personally and then helped me forward the gift onto the recipient. She was very helpful and kind each time I spoke to her on the phone. It was especially helpful that I no longer live in NY and needed to take care of this from a few time zones away.”

1 Poor6 Reviews

“My package was accidentally delivered to the wrong house. I called, spoke quickly to a very nice gentleman, Anthony I believe, he looked it up, saw the problem and said he’d tell the delivery person and I’d have my package soon. About an hour later my mail carrier was handing me my package! Mistakes happen, they worked quickly to resolve it and that was awesome! Good job and thank you!!-Sue”

1.4 Poor10 Reviews

“The women postal clerks at window were nice and were helpful to me with answering my questions. The Supervisor Chris helped me one day to get my mail to my door when I was feeling sick and in pain. Thank you.”

1 Poor7 Reviews

“I have been using this post office for years both professionally and personally with a personal PO Box as well. I have seen people treat them in the utmost disrespectful ways and they keep calm and collected then turn a smile out for me and are pleasant and helpful. Put out kindness to people and it will be returned. All of these negative reviews are horrible. Years I’ve gone in here and never had a bad experience with the staff. Some of the entitled patrons however, is a different story. They are lovely and efficient. I’ve never been in a post office that works through the process so quickly! Be kind to people!”

1.4 Poor20 Reviews

“I just had a wonderful experience via telephone from Indiana to Brentwood, NY post office. Postal worker, Nick, there should be more like you in the world’s workforce. Not only did you go beyond for a postal customer but were knowledgeable, courteous and kind. And thank you to the kind carrier that also went above and beyond. Kudos to you both! You deserve a raise!!! Thanks again!”

1.5 Poor44 Reviews

Related Categories