Thrift Stores near Bellport, NY

12 locations found near Bellport
View Map

“This place is very small, but it has the sweetest staff and really great prices! They have shoes for $1 and you can fill a basket full of clothes for a dollar as well! they have dresses on a rack for 5 dollars and up, and they have a really great selection of used books, fabric, glasses and dishware, furniture, and other knick knacks! The only qualm about this shop is that there isn't a lot of everything, but it's great for what it is”

2.9 Average17 Reviews

“I went here for the first time last week. The people who work there are lovely, very friendly and helpful. It is small and a bit cramped but no worries, I don't mind that in a thrift shop (especially one that is for a good cause!). Clothes are very cheap here, much more so than in some of the other thrift stores on Long Island. The selection isn't big (because the space isn't) but there are good deals to be found. Even shoes are cheap. I was looking for housewares, and I scored a full set of very nice vintage dishes for $50! It even included serving platters. They wrapped and boxed them for me, too. I recommend this place if you're willing to dig. Nice staff, good cause, and an interesting mix of items. You might not find something every time, but like with all places if you check in periodically I think you are sure to find things you like at a good price.”

4.4 Superb50 Reviews

“Only complaint is that some of the items are high priced just because of name brand. Doesnt matter whether in good or bad conditions.Ridiculous!Make.sure you make a donation to receive the 20% off coupon!”

4 Good106 Reviews

“Wow!! What a Store . They have everything you need. I got a tailored jacket and brend new pair of all bird shoes for 10$ .Definitely one of the best thrift stores on the island. The Gonzalez family and staff are so kind and helpful too.Especially Mr. Gonzalez's beautiful daughter , her smile and heart are so sincere. Just a wonderful woman from a wonderful wholesome family. These are the stores I always support .”

4.3 Superb19 Reviews

“I dont like the new layout of the store. Makes the 1st floor look so messy and disorganized.Pricing guide and colors of the day or of the week confuses me.Otherwise clean place”

3.6 Good52 Reviews

“Nicest Savers on Long Island. Extremely clean and well organized. Every item is on a hanger. Someone is always around to help. I went to make a return and they went out of their way to be helpful with it. Really went the extra mile. It’s already insane that a thrift store takes returns, so they could have been a lot less generous with me.”

3.5 Good98 Reviews

“The most Amazing, affordable thrift spot on the entire island!! They even deliver and it's not that much extra! Soooooo! Many wonderful things, furniture, plates, clothes, records, vintage items! For such a small place there so much to look at and choose from! The staff is so hospitable and friendly, definitely my new weekend thrift spot!”

3.8 Good13 Reviews

“It is super good, they sell the clothes by the pound, the pound costs $3 dollars, the place is small but there are clothes in very good condition and new, among other things, such as shoes, bags, etc., I highly recommend it.”

3.5 Good4 Reviews

“I love going to the Salvation Army I just wish they were a little more organized there's no way of knowing what sizes are in the clothes until you take it off the hangers no but nothing is in any kind of organization especially in the men's wear”

3 Average36 Reviews

“This is my favorite thrift store for nicknacks. I don't know if I'd recommend clothes shopping here because it does feel kind of expensive for a thrift store, but they have smaller furniture sometimes for pretty cheap (bedside table for $20, small desk for $40 that kind of thing) and again good decor depending on what you're into. I feel like someone can always find something if you're looking for something cool to come home with.”

3 Average150 Reviews

“I've been stopping in here frequently, mainly looking for cast iron. I've found several pieces, some that I'd call vintage, others I'd call modern users. I've yet to figure a system to which color price stickers are 50% off for any given day, just that Wednesday and Sunday have the most "on sale." Prices for the stuff I've been watching for have always been reasonable to cheap. Wish the staff members' English were better. But that could also be phrased as "wish I had paid attention in Spanish class!" (For the record, my Nonno spoke a Sicilian dialect of Italian and almost no English. I will NOT jump on that "English is our language" far right bandwagon!)”

2.6 Average43 Reviews