6AM - 10PM
4910 Main St, Bemus Point
Gas Stations
“This place saved our bacon! My husband was feeling really nauseous and we had two hours left to drive home. So we stopped here to see if we could find some Pepto bismol and paper towels because we were genuinely afraid he might need to vomit (gross, I know). The man who helped me offered me a bucket and a lid with plastic bags just in case the worst happened. It was so genuinely nice!
We really appreciated his kindness, and having the bucket made us feel a lot less nervous about getting back on the road. The good news is: we got home just fine and the bucket was not used, thank goodness hahaha!
Thank you again for your help, we REALLY appreciated it!”
“This is probably my favorite gas station in the area. It's not that the gas is especially affordable, but they always have particularly nice employees there. Also, they have a great selection of high-end beers. They may still carry a good tobacco selection as well, but I can't recall.”
“This is my go to after 9pm when everything else is closed. Huge store, walk in cooler, clean, always open, they have a variety of products such as typical gas station things, hats, tobacco pipes, muddy buddy's, snacks. Employees are super nice. It even has a fabulous liquor store attached along with a laundry mat.”
“Crosby’s are 5 star gas stations. The pizza is good. A guy in the store said it beats any pizzeria pizza in town and I replied with “then this town needs a new pizzeria” I mean. It’s good. Not great. When you’re on the go and need some gas for the whip and a fresh zyn AND a slice of pizza all at one stop? Then yeah, go for it, that’s what I mean by good. They get 5 stars at this one because the people that work there are real nice. I wanna give 4 stars because I wanted a coffee once at like 2pm and they were out. That’s lame. So I just grabbed a rio punch monster and a slice of chicken wing pizza. Coffee might not be their strong suit. The canned caffeine and a slice hit the spot. So that gets the 5 stars.”
Open 24 hours
1617 W 3rd St, Jamestown
Gas Stations
“I have gone to places that I did not know and I feel very happy. I recommend that you go out and enjoy so that you can see nature and many very beautiful things.”
7AM - 7PM
18 Main St, Sinclairville
Gas Stations
“I've only got gas in one place outside of my usual and hopefully this is the Valero of which you speak. I believe it is called Crosby Mart so I hope I'm not mistaken.
As I said, I am a creature of habit and usually do repetitive things like getting gas, using an ATM, buying my Mt. Dew at certain stores or ligations because I prefer familiarity. Having said that, I did find myself in need if gas as well as my Mt. Dew at a time when I wasn't anywhere near my usual haunts for these purchases so since I have certainly been in a Crosby Mart a few times over the years (and it was getting late, to) I threw caution to the wind and took care of my business right at the Main Street location in Fredonia. Nothing remarkable happened-I went in the store to get my soda and pay for my gas, the cashier was personable enough and on my way I went. Perhaps this cookie cutter version of a review will be of use to someone out there, I don't know but I just can't elaborate on my visit anymore than this. Sorry. Almost makes me wish I'd taken a near-hit from a lightening bolt or something just to beef this up a little.”
Open 24 hours
17 Water St, Mayville
Gas Stations
6AM - 11PM
4464 NY-60, Gerry
Gas Stations
“Some good subs and a good place to stop on Rt 60. They have a variety of snacks, drinks, and made to order food to choose from. Nowadays the gas every where is pricey! 7/31/21”
“The staff is always so friendly and willing to help their customers out. The manager you have now is well just amazing to say the least. She really has turned that store around. Its always clean and well stocked. I love coming here due to staff and the food.”
“An all in one stop. Convenience, gas, and deli. The subs are good and made with awesome bread. Pizza is very cheesy. Made to order is always fresh and loaded with cheese. If you get a fresh pizza by the slice it's really good if you happen to time it right. Friendly home town staff that has been committed to their job. "BLUE COLLAR" people make the world go 'round.”