24HR Fuel Available Crosby’s is your local family-owned convenience store and gas station, proudly serving communities across NY & PA. Offering oven-fresh pizza slices, quality fuel, and more— Crosby’s has everything you need! Stop in store now or order online!
They are now charging for a small amount of hot sauce to put on your purchased pizza slices. Another corporate way to nickle and dime there loyal customers.
December 2025
Stopped to grab a couple of slices of pizza. Fast, friendly service!
November 2025
The staff is wonderful and everything there is always fresh.
