Carlo's Grocery is a small, local deli and sandwich shop in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, considered a hidden gem and an icon. It is known for its authentic Italian flavor and homemade, fresh food, with nothing pre-made. All items are made to order, which can mean a wait, but the big portions and delicious food are well worth it. Many call it the best deli in South Brooklyn, praising the quality of all the food. The menu features classic Italian heroes and unique creations. Standout items include the chicken parmigiana, hailed as the best in Brooklyn, the chicken parm hero, the roast beef with mutz and gravy, and the chicken blt. Other noted sandwiches are the Giuliana and the chicken salad. The potato wedges are also mentioned as being unlike anything else. The atmosphere is a small corner store that feels warm and inviting, often filled with a delicious aroma. While the storefront can seem empty, the kitchen in the back is always energetic. It gets busy, especially during lunch hours, so calling or placing an order in advance is recommended. Be sure to bring cash.
Carlos Grocery is a hidden gem that serves some of the best sandwiches in NYC. The chicken parm hero is a must-have item. The prices are great, and the staff is fantastic.
June 2026
One of the best chicken Parm heroes I’ve had ever and the fries were amazing as well! I wish they were open weekends
June 2026
The best chicken parm in NYC. Great family own place.
