Fitzgerald Jewelry is a friendly and caring Brooklyn store with a top notch selection of beautiful, unique, and interesting pieces. Customers find the staff super sweet, kind, knowledgeable, helpful, and easy to work with. They are courteous, responsive, and communicative, providing a lovely and not snobby experience. The jewelers excel in both custom creation and repair work. They listen to preferences to recommend perfect settings and help design stunning rings. They also handle complex repairs, from fixing broken heirlooms and replacing lost stones to tightening settings, often with helpful advice. They make processes like insurance claims painless and relatively quick. Many note the great price bracket and excellent service, such as quality engraving with lots of font choices. Customers highly recommend the store, calling it their go-to jeweler and planning to return for future shopping.
I appreciated that the staff asked what I preferred before making any suggestions. They did not make assumptions but listened to me and this made me select a necklace that suited my taste very well.
April 2026
I have worked with Michael Fitzgerald off and on over the last 15+ years for different projects and have found him to be consistent, consultative and a pleasure to work with. If you want the opposite of 'cookie-cutter', I encourage you to chat or meet with Michael and his team.
October 2025
Lovely jewelry and wonderful people. We had a great experience here finding a wedding band for me. Hiroyo’s pieces are the best!
