York Cellars is a neighborhood gem and a smart, friendly wine store in Brooklyn. It carries an unmatched selection of uncommon wines and is a big advocate for small producers and woman-owned wineries. The team provides fantastic and incredibly accurate suggestions, making every visit informative. Their "$17 and Under" table offers fun, high quality, and affordable options. Customers describe the service as a magic trick and highly recommend the shop, calling it the best in the neighborhood and a top competitor among natural wine shops in the city.
The staff here gives awesome recommendations! Very happy to purchase from this store
July 2025
Great business! I hosted an event and needed to buy 30 bottles of wine. They recommended several wines and I chose 3, all of which were delicious. They also talked me down from my original order size which was a generous overestimate of how much wine I'd need. So helpful!
September 2024
Loved the 4 bottles we got. It tasted as good as the bottle brands looked... 😋
