-
August 2023 by Adeline W
I purchased three male gerbils here a few months ago. Very healthy, I haven’t had any health nor territorial issues so far. The establishment was clean and their cage was a perfect size and bedding depth for the species.I have not been able to socialize them beyond simple back touches, but that’s not a fault of the pet store. Sometimes desert rodents just dislike humans. ?
-
August 2023 by dragon goku
Picked up some fish for my pond always enjoy shopping here
-
July 2023 by John Mederski
Very clean. Decent sized fish section. Smaller reptile section. A ton of dry goods and foods. Good selection of fuzzies. And feeders
-
June 2023 by Barbara Clay
Thank you for your friendly service. Staff is extremely knowledgeable about information about the pets and supplies needed to get started on any pet supplies/information.
-
June 2023 by William Brennan
A good selection of fish and supplies. They even had an Aoxolotl for my granddaughter.
-
May 2023 by Edward Krauzowicz
Wow what a great place I just wandered around looking at all the different pets available fish tanks and everything you could need for your critters.
-
April 2023 by Roxanne Avery
Store was stocked and clean.The Downside was that staff followed me and hubby around like we were thieves. Caught the cashier leaning sideways over the counter to see us in the aisle.
-
March 2023 by Dawn Dennahower
Love this place great customer service l. Family owned and very knowledgeable
-
March 2023 by Ruby Porter
I’m from a smaller town in PA and the fish are much more expensive in my towns stores! So happy! Great store! The man was very kind, patient, and fast!
-
March 2023 by Brian Richards
Nice selection of tropical fish. Very helpful employee's. I was very happy to find this place and will be back.
-
February 2023 by Mike R
New owners after Niagara Aquarium closed are doing a great job of making the place even better. Of primary concern for me was the fish selection and healthiness of the tanks. They are pristine. Wasted time stopping by the major chains in recent weeks for new fish to stock a new tank. Wouldn't buy anything from them. Algae, sluggish fish, poor selection, not kept up. Just go here and avoid all that, get yourself healthy fish and have a nice selection to choose from. Staff was friendly and fast. Prices are either a little lower than the big stores or similar. I'll just buy from them from now on.
-
January 2023 by Joseph Carey
I’ve been waiting to post a review until I had everything I needed to properly give this establishment the justice it deserves.My son was gifted a beardie from his grandmother who, with my advice, chose Buffalo Pet Supply to purchase the lizard. Max came free of parasites, happy and healthy. Throughout the next 4 months, through blizzards and just making it there on a Sunday when crickets were low, Dave and staff were there to help a new lizard dad/grandad? properly set up the lighting and husbandry needed to house such an amazing animal. If Buffalo Pet Supply didn’t have what I was looking for, they tried to find it. If I found a better price online, Dave worked with me. Couldn’t ask for a more knowledgeable and courteous local pet store. Thanks everyone!
-
January 2023 by Marie Conta
We recently had Buffalo Pet Supply come to our home to clean and restore our fish tank. We had let the tank go and it got way beyond us being able to clean it and set it back up. We almost tossed it and decided to call round to see if this was “actually a thing anyone did” When I first spoke to Dave I knew he was the right person. He was very friendly and super knowledgeable on what needed to be done to bring our tank back to life. His scheduling was quick too. Dave spent about 2 hours working on cleaning the entire thing and I have to say it looks incredible. Just yesterday I was thinking about Dave would show up and tell us there was no way he was going to touch it, but man did he surprise the heck out of us. The tank looks BRAND NEW! We are so excited to come visit the store to fill our tank up! I wouldn’t go anywhere else after the amazing experience we had! Thank you so much for being so helpful and being so good at what you do!*the photo was taken only a few hours after he finished cleaning it and it’s already super clear- I wish I had taken before shots! My kids came home and ask if we got a new tank - thanks again!!
-
January 2023 by Vincent Polino
More knowledgeable than big box stores and locally-run. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff.
-
December 2022 by James Myers
Nice neighborhood pet store. Good selection of supplies for good prices. Helpful staff and plenty of parking.