Toy Stores near Carle Place, NY

30 locations found near Carle Place
View Map

“Excellent selection of old time candy and toys. They had a Willy Wonker tin lunchbox that I had them put all the goodies in for my sons 40th birthday. Wonderful job putting it all together for me”

4.8 Superb123 Reviews

“Wow, what an amazing store! The variety of comic books, action figures, and other nostalgic items are fantastic. It really takes you back to your childhood. Big shout out to Phil who was super friendly, welcoming and helpful!”

4.9 Superb44 Reviews

“Kidztoys is a great local toy store filled with so many goodies for children of all ages and interests. The owner and the workers are so helpful and sweet. If you’re ever looking for a present for a child this is the place to go. It never disappoints and the plus side of it is being able yo shop for small business’. p.s they wrap the gifts for free too !!!”

4.9 Superb31 Reviews

“I love the *olde timeyness* of this shop. It's an absolute blast from the past. I don't think I've ever not purchased a small bag of mixed salt water taffy during a visit.”

4.5 Superb81 Reviews

“Gorgeous toy store. A really great collection of beautiful & unique toys, and the shopkeepers were all very helpful with picking out & wrapping gifts. I found a lot of items I’d never seen before and frankly wouldn’t have found if I were online shopping. Highly recommend!”

5 Superb23 Reviews

“I love this store. I'm a huge Lego fan and I was building a Lego Christmas tree the other day when I realized I was missing a piece. I went back to this store and was able to get the piece along with a Lego Spider-Man keychain. Special Thanks to Dana for helping me out!”

4.5 Superb78 Reviews

“This shop is an easy five star based on their inventory, staff knowledge and overall great atmosphere to shop in. Willis Hobbies has been around MIneola since 1949. Not only have they been a fabric of the community but they always show their commitment to Mineola through their participation in Village events. If you can think of it.... You'll find it here. Plenty of electric cars, models (that go up to 2,000 pieces), lots of model trains and trains-accessories. The beauty of the shop is that the team here are experts. Depending what you're looking for will determine who you speak with. There is value shopping in a store that understands your needs and advices you accordingly. They always set up race cars at the MIneola Street to become more involved and engaged with the residents. In summation... there are good people here. KUDOs top the team at Willis Hobbies.”

4.6 Superb41 Reviews

“If your shopping on a budget but looking for a wider selection, Five below is the place to shop.Shopping for the college drom wont break your bank if your in Five Below.If you need new head phones and dont want to break your bank, check out Five Below.You can even shop for your pet here with a wide selection of dog and cat items.”

4.6 Superb38 Reviews

“I went there to get makeup products and some nails and I was brought with a whole section of stuff I needed! The only thing they should restock in, is lip liner. Other than that, 10/10 experience!”

4.5 Superb50 Reviews

“No weekend is complete without a run to 5 Below. It's always for something that's needed like a phone charger cord and then I wind up seeing so many other things that I feel like I must have. This location is usually pretty well stocked and the staff is friendly. Every once in a while they're short handed up front but they seem to make it work. On this trip I got pillows and a throw for my guest bedroom because they were super cute and affordable. I also bought another bookcase/organizer because I used one of theirs for my pop up shop set up and it works really great. Even though some things are more than $5 most of my items were actually $5. If you have a very small child, I'm warning you they have lots of cute toys and a lot of candy especially near the checkout so either prep them before you go in or don't bring them.”

4.4 Superb68 Reviews

“What a delight to have a toy store in the neighborhood!! I felt nostalgic entering the store and it reminded me of KB toy store. I love that they offer to gift wrap. Will be coming here to buy my son more toys!”

4.6 Superb29 Reviews

“My daughters party favors came out great and were a hit! We love KJ’s corner. Such a great spot for gifts, balloons and party favors. Definitely has a great assortment toys to choose from. Very unique things you can’t find anywhere else. Both staff and owner are amazing!”

5 Superb15 Reviews

“Trainland is a fantastic store with multiple layouts on display; huge selection of all scales. The staff is extremely knowledgeable and take their time to explain the products, along with helping customers troubleshoot. The online store (Trainworld) is my goto place for buying all things trains. They ship quickly, prices are competitive, and they stand behind the products they sell. Trainland continues to excel at providing that in person experience in the age where brick and mortar hobby stores continue to close. Highly recommend visiting and buying something there. They have everything from the Thomas trains for kids to the extremely high-end hobbyist quality products.”

4.5 Superb37 Reviews

“The owner is the heart and soul of this shop. he's extremely knowledgeable and takes great pride in his passions. this feels less like a comic store and more like a passage into someone's comic book collection. he knows a lot about everything in there and he is on POINT with recommendations on what you should read next!”

4.4 Superb51 Reviews

“The owners know all their products and are very experienced with importing merchandise that otherwise might be difficult to attain here in the States. From Transformers to Gundam, from Power Rangers to Ultraman, from One Piece to Jujutsu Kaisen, they’ve quite literally have it all. My brother and I will be frequenting this spot quite a lot in the near future and I hope anybody that is even remotely interested in shopping collectibles or hobby items that you will give this place a chance and fall in love with the atmosphere as did my brother and I!!”

5 Superb14 Reviews

“Loved this place for trinkets and finds at great prices. Especially during holiday decor season! Saddened that this location has closed. Please update GOOGLE as I traveled to permanent closure , web listed as still open.?”

4.4 Superb30 Reviews

“Excellent customer service! I ordered online for a store pick up and when I got there, I was helped or spoken to by three employees. One told me that someone will be with me shortly, one started the laminating machine for me, & the third one just simply told me no worries about something I mentioned. I usually have anxieties around back to school time and having to deal with lines can make me feel worse. This time, completely opposite of what I used to experience. I might go back soon just to use the laminating machine.”

4.3 Superb39 Reviews

“Great couple. had a good rc conversation with the lovely couple. Grabbed a pair of duratax banditos 2.2 on road. Have to say there jus a great couple of ppl. Definitely going back. There love for the hobby is undeniable”

4.7 Superb13 Reviews

“Fabulous local toy store! The owner happened to be there that day and he personally helped me carry toys to my car because I couldn’t carry everything, so kind! Love to support local businesses and would highly recommend”

4.2 Good38 Reviews

“I love this variety card and gift store. They have almost everything including lottery. I never walk out without buying something. There Willow Tree collection is so up to date. I love gazing at them. Of course I buy one here and there. There cards are plentiful and beautiful. Have fun there.”

4.7 Superb10 Reviews

“Birthday gift for my son and he was thrilled!! Price was great and better than Amazon. Shipping was free. They keep Lego sets and lots of choices. He went straight to it after school today too.”

4.7 Superb10 Reviews

“this store is amazing in everway! i stumbled upon this store and i am so happy i did! they have many of the very best toys and great gifts for kids and adults too.. i saw that they had a huge selection if camp stationary, fantasyic pens, and " whoopie cushions" that kids just love.............. the owners try thier best to give you all you need and their kindness did not go unoticed at all. if you need anything they are more than happy to help you and they do gift wrap and ship !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! give this store a try - you wull find its great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”

4.4 Superb17 Reviews

“We've always gone to toy stores on vacation I never thought let me check long island where we live, saw this place and we made a plan to come check it out. I'm happy we only found this place now because I think we'd be broke if we found it years ago lol. Then again we had so many things they sell in this store so eh :) Our son was in his glory and luckily he's easy to please so we didn't spend much. Woman who was working there, was super nice and we will for sure be back.”

4.3 Superb16 Reviews

“Love this place bit it is much too cramped in the holidays. There is so much stuff they fill the isles with that ppl are knocking things over and the baskets cant get through.Otherwise. Looove it!”

4 Good76 Reviews

“Heard about this store from the LI Teachers group on FB. Greatest little find. Store has teacher supplies throughout but most of it is concentrated in the back. The woman at the register is extremely helpful. If you can’t find something, just ask her, she will let you know if they have any more in the back or if the are ordering more supplies. They also laminate anything you buy for free. Plus teachers get a 15% discount. Great store and customer service.”

4.1 Good28 Reviews

“Simply Super stationery-papers, wrappings, cards, candies, cigarettes, very small items, very small gifts, notions, very small beverages; &, very small snacks selection, a few toys, many stuffed animals, lottery tickets; &, a small choice of useful household items kind of place.In general; &, especially, in the sense, of both of the Mom; &, Pop, co-owner's vibes; moods; approach; sensibilities; attitudes; feelings; &, policies; they're quite welcoming; accepting; tolerant; giving; accepting; &, embracing folks.At their quarters that they have, now; at this point; they are downsized to rather much smaller proportions; to state the barest minimum in descriptions; &, their, current customer demands are scarce; &, very narrow in sales scope; they, are therefore: few; &, far between; &, their stock of inventory is slight; restricted; &, gigantically limited; but, their hearts are: surely, filled w/: overflowing respect; &, assorted abundance. However, they have been local shopkeepers for quite a very long time.Their business codes of conduct in: commerce; transactions; &, personal demeanor; certainly guide; &, reflect all of that; as, both: George; who is: tolerant; patient; amiable; amenable; hapless; slow-going; accessible; available; present; understanding; &, accomodating; etc.; amongst his many other good characteristics; &, his, long-term: hugely devoted; undyingly loyal; highly caring; &, extremely loving; very concerned; &, greatly warm; elegant; classically tasteful; high-class; quietly, very shy; naivete-infused; and, rather conservative, spouse: Mini; who is an ->huge; frequent; &, regular help to him; in many ways; in the, constant; ongoing operation, of their business; &, their store; have both found ways, that they are enabled, w/: God's assistive support, to let those great qualities, that they mutually possess, shine through; &, be expressed; consistently, in their business practices; &, professional conduct; &, within the insides of their, private home; &, small family lives.They are without a, doubt: some of the, gentlest; most humble; nicest; kindest; low-toned; under-keyed; easiest-going; most laid-back; most polite; &, most soft-spoken; understated; sweetest; warmest; friendliest; most accomodating; and, most sophisticated combined vendors and proprietors; as well as: local community families; and, are amongst the: most, normal; simplest; plain-est; guile-less; most, routine; most, ordinary; yet: so caring; most, >decent; most, chill; &, most amiable; liberal; tolerant; open-minded; &, accomodating, of: small hamlet; tiny shop proprietors; and, to be found in this local small community; &, its' general, immediate, surrounding area.They also happen to be: very largely involved; engaged; committed; present; &, interested types of enthusiastic; emphatic "Family People"; incusive of: family of origin; &, their greater community, at large. Their best operating practices, include: being very good group members, as regards, any roles they inhabit; whether that involves, being: store owners; &, vendors, for very many multiple long years; parents/grandparents/family members; or: small-business operators/regional citizens/and, community anchors; as well as: just good people; as one is, both: clearly; &, probably, ever likely to be: able to; or, in actuality; come to: know; meet; or: find.If one encounters nearly any problem at all; here, it most likely will be addressed w/: some sufficiently adequate solution of resolve; or: reasonable accomodation; albeit, even this elevated vendor; and, shop, are not: perfect; like >all things in the human-made world.A. - [Up-Dated: Sun.-12/24/23.].”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“Service was great, very helpful. Showed me several different options, they were busy, but they took their time to help me. Got a card there, once less stop. Then wrapping the gift took another stop! I'm not sure about the doll I bought. Maybe a little over priced .”

4.1 Good23 Reviews

“Floral park is tiny, but cute and cozy. Definitely helps narrow down your selection. Store is always organized and clean. Employee Alesia is hands down the best. She is very knowledgeable and helpful! Very much recommend her. Her wrapping is excellent. Mattys is worth the money. We love it there!”

4 Good48 Reviews

“I really like the staff here and they are super helpful when trying to find a birthday gift for someone and will help you find a present that's on sale and will wrap it nicely so it looks really impressive when you give it!”

4.2 Good13 Reviews

You May Also Like