Pet Supplies Plus Central Islip is a highly regarded neighborhood pet store that offers a wide variety of products for dogs, cats, and other pets. Customers appreciate the extensive selection of natural and made in the USA products, as well as competitive prices. The store features a convenient self-serve dog wash that is well-equipped with shampoos, towels, and a powerful dryer, making bath time easier for pet owners. The wash area has recently been renovated, enhancing the overall experience. Reviewers highlight the friendly and helpful staff, noting their polite and welcoming demeanor. The store is well-stocked and organized, making it easy to find everything needed for pets, from food to toys and accessories. While some customers mention that prices can be slightly higher, they are willing to pay more for quality and unique pet food options. The rewards program is also appreciated by regular shoppers. Overall, Pet Supplies Plus Central Islip is recommended for pet owners looking for quality products and excellent customer service in a local shopping environment.
Always friendly and helpful. Great selection of items at reasonable prices.
August 2026
Very nice people, washed my dog and it was a mess!! Self serve dog wash 1000% way to go
July 2026
I am thankful for the knowledge and helpfulness of all the team members whenever I visit the store. And my Boston Terrier Abigail appreciates everything I bring home for her.
