Plato's Closet in Commack offers a clean and pristine store with many great deals and very cheap prices, such as fifteen dollar pants and ten to twelve dollar shirts. Shoppers can find a high amount of high-value items, including brand new sneakers. The staff is consistently described as amazing, happy, friendly, very welcoming, polite, courteous, and extremely helpful. Customers report a great experience with a super easy step-by-step process for selling items, aided by helpful text message updates. However, those selling clothing are advised they may not make what they want, as payouts can be low, such as a few dollars per item, and the store is selective in what they accept from a bag. Overall, it is a highly recommended place where people definitely plan to go back, both to shop and to sell.
Always the best finds!!! They have the best brands like skims, white fox, edikted, Zara, Lululemon etc !! I always leave with something and everyone’s really nice . I thrift alllll the time and it’s def my fav spot on Long Island
April 2026
Cute stuff but staff are not friendly. I came around 8:30pm (half an hour before the store close) to get stuff for vacation and girl working would not let me try on clothes. If your store is open why are fitting rooms closed?
January 2026
Recently stopped by and was able to find some great outfits during our New York trip. Store was clean and the staff was friendly. Will definitely stop by again when in town!
