Plato's Closet in Commack offers a clean and pristine store with many great deals and very cheap prices, such as fifteen dollar pants and ten to twelve dollar shirts. Shoppers can find a high amount of high-value items, including brand new sneakers. The staff is consistently described as amazing, happy, friendly, very welcoming, polite, courteous, and extremely helpful. Customers report a great experience with a super easy step-by-step process for selling items, aided by helpful text message updates. However, those selling clothing are advised they may not make what they want, as payouts can be low, such as a few dollars per item, and the store is selective in what they accept from a bag. Overall, it is a highly recommended place where people definitely plan to go back, both to shop and to sell.
I just love this place! I found everything I needed at a low cost. There’s such a great variety of things to choose from, and the people are really nice too. Definitely a great place to shop!
September 2026
Has a good selection of bothe men and women clothing and shoes. Will definitely be going back
September 2026
I’ve gotten myself, my bf and family some nice clothes or bags from this spot. I enjoy coming in and seeing what new things they have that I can save on. Especially in a time where everything else is overly expensive.
Pretty organized and they also have fitting rooms. Which is a HUGE plus for me.
