Tire Dealers near DeWitt, NY

30 locations found near DeWitt

“Efficient, affordable, customer oriented. I've never had to wait around in the waiting room for someone to notice me even if they are very busy in the bays.”

4.3 Superb138 Reviews

“They were super friendly and accommodating even though we didn’t have an appointment to fix a flat tire. They did not try to upsell, even though they said we needed 2 new tires!”

4.9 Superb259 Reviews

“Wonderful customer service. Great experience and wonderful employees. Thank you so much for taking care of me and my car. I appreciate everything they so for me, and I love that they explain everything so I can understand”

4.8 Superb342 Reviews

“The team at Mavis is top-notch! I have had a great experience every time I bring my car there. The staff are always very professional, timely, honest, communicative, pay attention to detail and focus on getting your car serviced without any upsell. Highly recommend- they are really the only people I trust with my car. They care about their customers, and it shows.  I never write reviews, but feel the need to tell everyone how awesome they are!”

4.8 Superb351 Reviews

“I had a great experience at this Mavis location. We were able to get an appointment the very next day, which was a huge help. The person at the counter was friendly from the moment we walked in. While we waited, we could hear him dealing with computer issues that were affecting inspections, and he handled every call with real empathy. He took the time to apologize to people and explain the situation clearly, which says a lot about how he treats customers.

The shop was not the fastest that day, and it seemed like they might have been a little short staffed for the season. Even so, everyone we interacted with was kind, helpful, and committed to doing the job right. They took responsibility for the problems caused by the machine going down and made sure people knew what was going on.

In a world where everyone expects instant results, it was refreshing to see a place that prioritizes quality work and genuine customer service. If that is what you value, this is a great place to go.”

4.8 Superb299 Reviews

“This place is absolutely great!! I was in today for 4 new tires, and it was a great experience. The staff there is the best, friendly and funny!! I will be back in the future!!”

4.8 Superb225 Reviews

“I never really leave reviews but this one deserves it. I hit a deer and caused a tremendous amount of damage to my car. Insurance was being a pain and didn't want to cover OEM parts but canettas argued my case and got me the parts I needed. Their repair work was top notch and my car was basically brand new when I got it back! Love these people!!!!”

5 Superb96 Reviews

““Best place to visit for tire-related issues and replacements. I went to Mavis Tire after getting a nail in one of my tires. The mechanic came out, removed it in less than 10 minutes, and didn’t charge me a penny. Excellent service!””

4.7 Superb310 Reviews

“Overall, excellent service. My service provider, Dante, went out of his way to be super helpful. My vehicle was brought into the service area as soon as I arrived and I had my seasonal tires changed out in record time. Service was greatly appreciated!”

4.7 Superb195 Reviews

“I bought my 2013 xt4 from a very pleasant gentleman Ashley at Crest August of 2025. I couldn’t have asked for a better sales person. I just brought it in for a new push button starter. Of course crest happens to be down a machanic which kept my car there longer than usual but having a warranty helped me keep my visit at a lower price. Although, just having bulbs put in the handles and lowest point in back bottom of car were way too exspensive to have done I was disappointed but my car is running and after not having to use my car for two in a half weeks I had an appointment coming up in which they kept up until that date. I’d rather deal with the men directly fixing my car and not the female secretary in that area. Overall it was ok for that visit.”

4.6 Superb203 Reviews

“Two of my tires have been losing air. I brought my vehicle in and Dunn tire checked all four tires, un mounting and checking surface of rim and remounting. One of the tires did have a small nail in it which they repaired. They worked on my car for about an hour and a quarter. There was no charge for this service. They are unbelievably great company. I highly recommend them.”

4.6 Superb223 Reviews

“What an incredible find! If you look up customer service in the dictionary, you will see FIRST AUTOMOTIVE! These guys have gone above and beyond for sure. Quality work, flexible, quick turnaround and absolute superior customer service. M. Webster/T.Dugo”

4.8 Superb98 Reviews

“Fantastic company, excellent customer service. I will be recommending them to everyone I know. They completed the scheduled task in the time frame I was given and did a fantastic job with the paint work.”

4.7 Superb111 Reviews

“Recently had to get my sons lil BMW NYS inspection done . They were able to fit me in the following day. Contacted Carrier Circle Care because they are highly reviewed in a popular FB group. Bringing my wifes car in there soon to.”

4.8 Superb60 Reviews

“My appointment wasn't technically for 18 days but they told me I could drop it off and they would try to fit me in before then. They called me the first day and said they had it all done. If you want great customer service from a local family owned business, go to Scotty's.”

4.9 Superb55 Reviews

“Tobi got me in ASAP looked over my car and gave me great pricing on parts and labor . Very quick very professional and even looked deeper into my car . Thanks you go see the fellas over at 7435 Oswego rd in Liverpool”

4.6 Superb133 Reviews

“THIS PLACE IS INCREDIBLE! The communication and customer service was unmatched. I was able to text them on the weekend and get my vehicle in the shop that Monday. They were transparent about the specific needs of service on my Truck. A+ experience - DO NOT HESITATE TO BRING YOUR VEHICLE HERE!!!”

4.7 Superb89 Reviews

“I was traveling and desperately needed new tires for my F350 superduty long bed. Most place cant even jack my truck up. Joe got me in first thing in the morning and out by 100 in the afternoon. Thanks Joe.”

4.7 Superb77 Reviews

“Walt’s Automotive Service truly saved the day for me, and I couldn’t be more grateful for the level of professionalism, honesty, and skill this shop showed from start to finish. It’s not easy finding a mechanic you can trust, especially when you’re dealing with unexpected car trouble, but Walt and his team proved immediately that they take their work — and their customers — seriously.

I came in with an electrical issue that had completely thrown off my vehicle. Other places had given me guesses, rough ideas, or long wait times, but Walt diagnosed the problem quickly, explained everything clearly, and didn’t try to upsell or scare me into unnecessary repairs. He found the exact issue, fixed it efficiently, and had me back on the road faster than I ever expected. The honesty alone deserves five stars, but the quality of the repair made it even better.

The shop itself is clean, organized, and run by people who actually care about what they’re doing. You can tell Walt takes pride in his work and treats every customer like a real person, not a paycheck. The communication was excellent, the pricing was fair, and the peace of mind was priceless.

If you need reliable automotive service from someone who truly knows what they’re doing, look no further. Walt’s Automotive Service is the place you want in your corner when your car decides to give you trouble. They definitely earned this five-star review.”

4.6 Superb136 Reviews

“Happened to be next door at Byrne Dairy topping air off in tires when a valve stem broke in half. Took vehicle to this Goodyear and despite being fully booked and every tech busy, they stopped and got working on replacing the valve stem and TPMS sensor immediately.

20 minutes later, I was pulling back out and on my way. It is so hard to find a shop these days that’ll breakaway for a small job like that. These guys helped me avoid sitting in their lobby for 3-4 hours until they could make it to my vehicle.

Thanks folks, you have my highest recommendation and I’d definitely come back if the situation warranted. May need new tires next year, I’ll keep you on the short list.”

4.7 Superb90 Reviews

“Great bunch of guys! They really helped me out when I needed them plus spoke to my son (who paid over phone).
They didn't hesitate to come to my Aide, that was so comforting to know thete are still people (mechanics, no less) with integrity in the world!
Thanks guys
GOD bless ?”

5 Superb35 Reviews

“Honestly first time using and originally used because I needed an inspection and they are open on weekend. I had to bring my toddler but we dropped off and walked over a short distance to McDonald’s and then within 15-20 min it was done and ready for pick up but wasn’t rushed. Staff was all very friendly. No issues.”

4.5 Superb167 Reviews

“J & J Automotive did an absolutely outstanding job tricking out my truck, including installing side-step lighting that came out perfect. Their work is top-notch, the prices are fair, and the quality is excellent from start to finish.

This is a family-run, family-owned business, and you can really tell—they take pride in what they do and treat customers right.

I highly recommend J & J Automotive to anyone looking for reliable, professional, high-quality work. You won’t be disappointed.”

4.6 Superb58 Reviews

“Upstate Imports has serviced three different BMW's of mine over the last few years. They have been very reliable and trustworthy. They have fixed problems that other shops couldn't. They only use high quality parts. Tony is very knowledgeable and communicates very well. I will continue to use them and highly recommend them.”

4.5 Superb111 Reviews

“Great experience at Big4 Tire!
I called last Friday—right after Thanksgiving—looking for snow tires for both my wife’s vehicle and mine. The service advisor provided outstanding customer service and offered several options at different price points, clearly explaining the differences and benefits of each.

The installation this week was prompt, efficient, and exactly as promised. Communication throughout the entire process was excellent. It’s refreshing to deal with a well-run, locally owned and operated business.

We’ll definitely be returning in the future!”

4.5 Superb106 Reviews

“I took my vehicle in for a nail in my tire. The gentlemen who work at this location were friendly, professional, and efficient! They even fixed my tire for free! I will definitely be back for other services I need on my tires in the future. I highly recommend them!”

4.4 Superb202 Reviews

“I was quite surprised to find a tire shop that actually treated me with kindness. I'm not saying that all tire shops are rude, but often times I feel like I'm bothering the person at the front desk - if you know what I mean.”

4.4 Superb156 Reviews

“I've been going to this shop for over 15 years . Danny, Mike and Red are the best people in the business . A great local shop that will get your issues solved immediately . Great deals on tires and exceptional maintenance on all your vehicles needs . Tell them Jerry sent you”

4.6 Superb53 Reviews

“Great guys took great care of me even though they appeared to be mostly commercial, they stopped what they were doing and got me back on the road,, can't say enough good things for Customer service and work ethicThank you!”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“My tire purchase and replacement went extremely well. The job was done in a time fashion and they notified me as soon as the job was complete. They also replaced my rear taillight and did a super job.
Plony’s is always a pleasant experience. We are so fortunate to have a local shop like Plony’s in our neighborhood.”

4.5 Superb43 Reviews