“Within the last few months, I purchased a gold rope necklace and, most recently, a matching gold rope bracelet from Lisa. She was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and kind throughout both experiences. She made the entire process easy and enjoyable. The store has such a beautiful selection of jewelry, and I couldn’t be happier with my purchases. I highly recommend Lisa and the store! I can’t wait to come back for more!”
“Larry and his staff are always friendly, honest and incredibly helpful. My aunt recently wanted to sell some gold jewelry and after visiting several other jewelry stores that offered her much lower prices, I told her to bring to Great American Jewelers , Larry gave her a fair price and treated her with honesty and respect instead of taking advantage. It absolutely made her day!
It's so refreshing to find a business you can truly trust. I have been a customer for years and highly recommend for jewelry and LOVE their Brighton collection !”
“Beautiful, high quality jewelry. Service is impeccable—Manny is knowledgeable, friendly, and super honest. Reset my engagement stone into a stunning halo setting and created a matching eternity band. Both pieces are exquisite. Can’t recommend Maddy Fine Jewelry enough. I won’t go anywhere else.”
“Lori Quirk at Gem Pawn brokers was such a sweetheart, a people persons & helped me get a loan for my gold chain, she went above & beyond to get me extra cash after coming home from broke from vacation. I would absolutely reccomend anyone that needs a loan to come here & no where else ! Thank you Lori !”
“Kay’s is the best great quality beautiful jewelry and Katherine was amazing she helped me find everything I needed and packed up the necklaces perfectly friendly service highly recommended store and staff”
“Mike did it again! I decided to upgrade my ring and, of course, went straight back to Mike at Elegant Jewelers. He is incredibly trustworthy, works quickly, and truly listens to what you want. Once again, he delivered the most perfect ring — exactly what I envisioned. I couldn’t be happier with the experience or the result. Highly recommend!”
“Gennaro Jewelers is the only place to go if you are looking for anything from engagement rings to earrings to necklaces and anything in between. This weekend Angela assisted my husband and I in finding exactly what we were looking for!!!
UPDATE- I was back at Gennaro last weekend and Donna was very helpful. She understood exactly what I was looking for, how much I wanted to spent, and could not have done a better job assisting me to find the perfect ring.”
“My friend bought a beautiful custom made necklace. The quality was fantastic. Everyone who worked here was so helpful and kind. Please come here for any of your jewelery needs! It's a lifetime piece my friend just purchased!”
“I have had the best experiences at Good old Gold. They helped me choose the correct setting g for my diamond earrings and the earrings look fabulous. I have also purchased a bracelet with diamonds and a beautiful necklace. The staff is amazing and so helpful with different ideas. They are courteous and I feel honest prices. Hope to be back soon!”
“I needed a fix for a chain for my wife. Seeing as it was my first time in a private jewelry store I didn’t know what to except. I was greeted warmly by Mike and right away he showed his expertise by easily untangling the wild chain. He told me what I was working with and showed my a subtable chain replacement that was better that what I had and matched the custom lockett I came in with. I’m happy with my purchase that didn’t break my wallet. Thank you for being the only jewelry store in the area that was open after 6. I will be back for future purchases and asking for Mike. 🙏🏾”
“Went in for quick battery replacements on watches. Very friendly, lovely store. (Was my 1st time in here) Atmosphere is also nice. Replacement went smoothly. Will return at some point. Thank You”
“I had such a great experience selling my gold here. Dalia, the owner, was incredibly caring, honest, and most importantly FAIR. She took the time to explain everything, made me feel comfortable throughout the process, and offered a price that truly felt fair compared to other places. You can tell she genuinely cares about her customers and runs her business with integrity. I highly recommend coming here if you’re looking for someone trustworthy and professional.”
“I recently purchased a stunning morganite and diamond engagement ring from Frassanito Jewelers, and once again, they exceeded every expectation. I’ve been buying jewelry from them for over 45 years, and I can honestly say I’ve always been ecstatic with both their exquisite designs and their exceptional level of service.
Having grown up with the Frassanito family, my trust in them runs deep—I truly regard them as I would my own family. That trust shines through in every piece they create. Their passion, craftsmanship, and dedication to their work are evident in the beauty and quality of their jewelry.
This latest ring is absolutely breathtaking, and the experience of selecting it was just as meaningful as the piece itself. Frassanito Jewelers isn’t just a jewelry store—it’s a place where artistry, integrity, and lifelong relationships come together beautifully. ~ Andrea Mastrocinque-Martone”
“Finding an honest jeweler is rare these days, which is why my experience with Eddie was so refreshing. I initially visited to obtain an appraisal report for my insurance coverage. Before proceeding, Eddie took the time to honestly explain the true retail value of my diamond. Rather than encouraging me to pay for an appraisal I might not need, he was transparent and upfront about the situation.
Because of his integrity and professionalism, I decided to move forward with the appraisal anyway. Not only was the service exceptional, but their appraisal fee was approximately 70–75% lower than what I was quoted in New York City and the surrounding counties. In fact, Eddie even charged me less than the standard appraisal fee.
The drive was absolutely worth it. It's rare to find a business that genuinely prioritizes honesty, customer satisfaction, and the best interests of its clients over making a quick sale.
Thank you, Eddie, for your outstanding service. I look forward to seeing you again soon to discuss the watch we talked about.”
10AM - 5:30PM
30 Cold Spring Rd, Syosset
Jewelry Stores
“I cannot recommend Anthony Jewelers enough! My wife brought her engagement ring here to be reset and repaired, and the entire experience was flawless from start to finish.
Martin took care of us, and he was absolutely fantastic. He was incredibly attentive and really took the time to listen to exactly what my wife wanted. He walked her through options with great, thoughtful suggestions that elevated the final design while keeping the integrity and sentiment of the original ring.”
“Great deals and beautiful inventory. My family only comes here for all our jewelry! Everyone is friendly helpfully and extremely knowledgeable- highly recommend!”
“Extremely friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. Amazing selection and pricing. I have been back several times since I first walked in because of the great experience. It's so nice to be appreciated as a customer.”
“I’ve had consistent positive experiences with Devin Jewelers over the years, from jewelry purchases to resetting my wedding band and repairs. Danny is a true perfectionist and always makes sure every detail is absolutely perfect. Andrew is incredibly kind and helpful, and the sales associates are always warm, knowledgeable, and attentive. Their craftsmanship, customer service, and attention to detail are truly exceptional. Highly recommend!”
“Nuha rocks. Honestly I didnt think I would get the ring made before the time frame i was given. They listen to every little detail, they make sure you feel good about whatever purchase your about to make. Thank you so much. You guys definitely essed my nerves lol. I will definitely send more people your way.”
“I cannot recommend the retail experience at this establishment enough due to the high level of knowledge, dedication and professionalism. The world of jewelry can seem intimidating to many people so having a guide to help navigate your purchase in a thoughtful manner that offers peace of mind and greater comfortability is priceless.”
“They were very helpful. Brought in a bracelet for its yearly inspection and they also cleaned my wedding rings. Everything sparkles now! They were very professional.”
“The best place in town for all types of jewelry and watches! Professional and reliable! Very reasonably priced and knows his work!
Always a pleasure working with them.”
10:30AM - 5PM
332 New York Ave, Huntington
Jewelry Stores
“Outstanding purchase experience. This is not my first time buying from Time Source, so I finally decided to share my thoughts about the consistent service and quality of the staff. I was always greeted warmly upon entering the store. My first visit was just to browse. There was no pressure from the sales staff. It was a comfortable experience. I had brought in a watch for service (battery replacement and cleaning). It was done in a timely fashion. The results were perfect. I purchased my first watch 2 years ago. It came in a timely manner and was in mint condition. Very pleased with the experience. Fast forward to now, when I bought a new luxury timepiece. It would normally be a difficult model to obtain, but Time Source was able to get it within 2 weeks. I was kept informed about the progress and finally picked it up. The watch and incidentals arrived in mint condition. The staff was very helpful during the pickup. I would definitely return for my future needs and highly recommend this place to anyone interested in anything related to watches.”
9:30AM - 8:30PM
25 Melville Park Rd Suite 180, Melville
Jewelry Stores
“Matthew is a very well educated and highly certified professional with a passion for gemology. He has a professional lab in his office with up to 30 instruments at his disposal. I came in with a couple of fairly rare stones and he did a very thorough analysis. He researched them, spending probably more time than it was worth for him to come up with a reliable current retail value. His rate was very reasonable to boot. He was very personable even though it was late in the day which made it a fun visit as well. He will definitely be my ‘go to guy’ for any future appraisals.”
“I’ve been coming to Levit Jewelers for years for gifts, repairs, and appraisals and they have always been wonderful. Recently, I brought in several pieces of my mother’s jewelry that she left to me. Many of them were broken, with cracked stones and dulled settings, and I wasn’t sure how much could be restored.
When I picked them up, I was truly moved. Every piece had been beautifully repaired and brought back to life and absolutely stunning. The care and craftsmanship that went into restoring something so meaningful to me was incredible. The cost was also affordable. I’m beyond grateful and will continue to be a loyal customer for years to come.”
“I had a positive experience at this pawn shop. The staff was friendly, professional, and took the time to explain the value of my items without making me feel rushed. The store was clean and well organized, and the buying and selling process was straightforward. They offered a fair price, and I appreciated their honesty and transparency throughout the transaction. Whether you're looking to pawn, sell, or browse for deals, this is a shop that's worth checking out. I would definitely return and recommend it to others.”
10AM - 6:30PM
1306 Hicksville Rd, Massapequa
Jewelry Stores
“My husband and I have both have had great experiences at Rontal. He bought me a beautiful sapphire and diamond bracelet this past Christmas. I bought my daughter a beautiful circle diamond necklace for her graduation.
This week I went in to have my diamond replaced in my engagement ring. It had fallen out😭, I was able to find it 😊, and Ben replaced it, shined everything up, 🤩 !!
I can’t wait to go back with some of my/my mother’s pieces to have them make me something special. I follow them on instagram and LOVE all the transformations! My sister had a piece made and it is stunning! 😍 —Anastasia S.”
“Lifelong jeweler since I can remember and it never disappoints! Manny always takes the time to help us pick out the perfect piece and offers great prices afterwards. Would highly recommend.”
“NO WORDS! Mark just made the most fantastic wedding band for my ten year anniversary. He was able to take diamonds from my grandmas rings and recreate the most magical wedding band that I get to wear forever!! I will definitely be returning with more jewelry and more visions for him to design.”
“Huge thank you to Candy's for making my son's experience a memorable one and in the best way possible. My six year old came to me just before Mother's Day and expressed his desire to get mom a gift. Wanting him to take ownership over the experience rather than me just buying whatever i suggested we go shopping together and he asked could we make it a jewelry store. The great reviews lead us to Candy's on a quiet rainy afternoon. The only ones in the store he was made to feel like a king, asking all sorts of questions as kids his age do and wanting to more or less see everything. Candy was beyond patient and helpful, letting him see the pieces in the price range I'd mentioned and put them side by side so he could make his choice. In the end he picked out the necklace he like best and was thrilled that we walked out with it giftwrapped, bagged and ready to go for mommy. She of course loved it because it came from him and he now has a memory he'll always treasure. Highly recommended, we will definitely be back.”