9:30AM - 8:30PM
25 Melville Park Road Ste 180, Melville
Jewelry Stores
“Finding an honest jeweler is rare these days, which is why my experience with Eddie was so refreshing. I initially visited to obtain an appraisal report for my insurance coverage. Before proceeding, Eddie took the time to honestly explain the true retail value of my diamond. Rather than encouraging me to pay for an appraisal I might not need, he was transparent and upfront about the situation.
Because of his integrity and professionalism, I decided to move forward with the appraisal anyway. Not only was the service exceptional, but their appraisal fee was approximately 70–75% lower than what I was quoted in New York City and the surrounding counties. In fact, Eddie even charged me less than the standard appraisal fee.
The drive was absolutely worth it. It's rare to find a business that genuinely prioritizes honesty, customer satisfaction, and the best interests of its clients over making a quick sale.
Thank you, Eddie, for your outstanding service. I look forward to seeing you again soon to discuss the watch we talked about.”
“Ibraheemm was so nice to me! My first time in a pawn shop and he explained the worth of each item to me, answered my dumb questions, and gave me a hellava good price for my jewelery. Can't reccomend enough”
9:30AM - 4:30PM
109 Coverly Pl, Melville
Jewelry Stores
“Elsa made our rings over 7 years ago and we have never had any issues with stones falling our, nor discoloration or anything. The experience with Elsa was awesome, she is first class and very attentive!!!!”
“My sister and I had gold jewelry to sell. I researched how to go about it, how much the items were worth and the best places to sell it. After my research and reading of reviews I chose Whitman. David sat with us explained the process and was completely transparent during the process. He patiently answered all of our questions. I knew what my jewelry was worth and what I should expect to be paid. David was professional and honest, he paid us more than I had optimistically expected! Bravo to this small business it’s obvious why the store always has lots of customers. We surely will be back to purchase future jewelry items.”
“Matt appraised my daughter's engagement ring and verified it authenticity. He spent quality time checking all aspects of the diamond and the setting. His knowledge expertise were resilient through the whole process. It was a fabulous and educational experience!”