Thrift Stores near Farmingdale, NY

21 locations found near Farmingdale

“Really clean and well organized store, lots of cool home decor and accessories. Also a super nice staff. Actually answer DM‘s when you reach out to them and are prompt in responding. This is such a big deal for thrifters because we know when it’s the thrill of the hunt and only one item exists, you want quick answers before you make the journey to find your item is no longer in stores. I’ve been lucky two times to get items posted from Instagram stories (the dog statue now in my living room and this sick fringe handbag) that would have slipped past me if they weren’t quick on answering. Will definitely be coming here more often, so happy to have them local to where I live.”

3.8 Good64 Reviews

“Just tried out the shop recently wounderful selection ? definitely something for everyone.
Staff seemed very friendly. I wish all items were priced. I truly would have considered purchasing more without having to find someone and figure out the price of each iten I was interested in. I understand it can be very time consuming to price out each item when there is a lot. I did overhear other customers saying I wonder how much this cost ?”

4.5 Superb56 Reviews

“Pretty good store I’ve recently gotten into collecting physical media & they had a bunch of cd options so I picked up a few, prices were pretty reasonable I got quite a few for just $10 would’ve been 10 a piece anywhere else so I can’t really complain. Def wanna come back to check out DVDs since I collect those too!”

4.5 Superb81 Reviews

“Absolutely lovely shop filled with wonderful people serving the Lord Jesus. The store has great items and stays current and seasonal.
The work they do there is a blessing for the community and helps support the equally great ministries of their local church.
You would be blessed in going to support Hope Thrift Shop!”

4.8 Superb24 Reviews

“I have been a patron of this shop for over 50 years, have found the best!!! Prices are unbelievable. New items daily. Ya never know what you will come upon. Treasures!”

4.7 Superb47 Reviews

“Came here for the first time with my friend. We absolutely LOVED being there. Betty Ann was super friendly! Lots of awesome things to look at, with no pressure to purchase anything. We will be back!!!”

4.6 Superb41 Reviews

“This place is run by angles on earth, they take care of as many people as humanly possible they clothes and feed anyone in need and this world is a better place for having the Long Island trading post friends and family is spreading the world with take care of your neibor s and anyone that is in need attitude. God bless us all xoxo”

4.5 Superb70 Reviews

“I volunteer at this shop and each week I find the most AMAZING clothing at great prices. Quality clothing. Stop by, you won't be disappointed. There's also housewares, toys, cutlery, dishes and children's clothing too.”

4.1 Good53 Reviews

“Awesome team inside. Can see and hear just how they appreciate each other and the people whom come in. This place has good prices, inventory changed frequently which is fantastic. HOWEVER it’s the people that volunteer / work here that is the best. Truly good caring hardworking and attentive people. God Bless you all”

4.6 Superb7 Reviews

“Great thrifting experience! The ladies who work there are lovely and so helpful. The place is so organized and full of treasures! Terrific set-up with different rooms dedicated to various items. Prices are great, too.”

3.9 Good16 Reviews

“Take a peek! I've found Pyrex and pampered chef practically new, along side of classic finds that bring back memories of my childhood. There's always something different in there.Profits benefit local animal rescues”

3.9 Good12 Reviews

“The staff working there are very friendly, caring and approachable. The items are neatly organized and the items are sold at a very reasonable price. Love the shop”

3.7 Good11 Reviews

“Very nice, small thrift store. Excellent prices, very good merchandise and a friendly, easy to communicate with, staff. Really enjoyed shopping there. My wife purchased about 14 items; every thing was 50% off.”

3.3 Good7 Reviews

“What a wonderful little store..the staff is so kind and sweet.
The merchandise is amazing..sometimes you will find that long lost pin your grandmother wore. Or maybe that blazer your mom had back in the day.
But dont be shocked if you find a rack of brand new clothes..
Their hours are 11-3 and they only take cash
Happy shopping
Update:: they now take credit cards and apple pay.. the ladies are still absolutely wonderful. The store gives you a back in time vibe..its absolutely perfect..”

3.3 Good32 Reviews

“I love this savers, Marlon, Nora and Cheryl are the best!!!! They are always very helpful and always so nice. They greet everyone with a smile, and if you have a hard time at the register they are more than happy to help you. They are top tier! Marlon, Nora and Cheryl are always approachable not like some of the other employees. Patrick is the best store manager of any of the savers I have gone too. Cheryl is an absolute doll, and has so much patience even when she is super busy . When she is working her area is very organized.”

3.4 Good141 Reviews

“This is a well stocked store with two floors of merchandise. The staff is friendly. Most of the items are in excellent condition and the store is kept fairly orderly.”

3 Average66 Reviews

“Place is really great! Saw some of the other reviews, not sure how people were displeased. I thought the staff was helpful and kind. Selection was large and fantastic! I came with my girlfriend, and we both found something here!”

2.1 Poor40 Reviews

“This is a good thrift store. The prices are hit or miss, and you may get a great deal or be amazed at how high something is priced. Their sale days are good, so pay attention to them.”

3 Average121 Reviews

“This place is SOOO good I literally found such good clothes and shoes and a bracelet! I even found a 15 dollar coach bag! But I didn’t get it cus it had a yellowish stain”

3 Average219 Reviews

“Hey probably it was my lucky day the owner I think extremely nice …. the guys that helped me with furniture Nice …..
Extremely nice , the place it’s clean

Yes there was dining sets for over $2000 but hey you pick up what’s good for your pocket!”

2.6 Average77 Reviews

“Great place, nice little food court, some arcade games, little flea market, card bazaar.

If you check often you can get some really good deals on the clothes. Some better finds than a lot of the other thrift stores.”

2.7 Average171 Reviews