Island Thrift is a well-stocked thrift store that offers a wide range of items across various departments. While some customers find the prices to be on the higher side, the store often holds special sale days where most items under $24.99 are priced at $2.99. The staff is generally described as helpful, with one customer praising a staff member named Robert for his excellent customer service. Many customers appreciate the store's large size and the variety of merchandise available, with one reviewer describing it as the "BEST THRIFT STORE ON LI." However, some customers feel that the store is overpriced compared to other thrift stores. Overall, Island Thrift seems to provide a mixed experience, with both positive and negative reviews from customers.
Moth ball smell gives off funeral vibes. Furniture and bikes are a go!
March 2026
For people saying dont buy electronics because thry dont test them, they have huge outlets all over the place for you to test the electronics. Thats just user error
October 2025
This is a good thrift store. The prices are hit or miss, and you may get a great deal or be amazed at how high something is priced. Their sale days are good, so pay attention to them.
