-
April 2024 by Jennifer Sherwood
Easter dinner with my boys. We did not have reservations.The staff was super nice, and the Manager Glenda made us feel welcomed and sat us at the open bar. She spent time to talk to us despite the busy buffet people who had reservations. Bar staff was great, as well. The prime rib was amazing. Thank you, Colgate Inn.
-
March 2024 by steve s
Incredible professional service by Shannon, Glenda and the Colgate Inn Team. Always friendly and helpful looking to lake your stay remarkable. A giant thank you to Dennis, Therissa, Ruth and all the front desk team. This is a beautiful property with excellent staff & World class service.
-
March 2024 by Barry Greenstein
We stayed at the Colgate Inn for a recent visit to see our daughter . The rooms were clean and modern , the Hotel food was excellent and the Bar Hospitality superb lead by Bartender Shannon who couldn't be nicer or do more for everyone .We had a dinner event downstairs in the Lobby Room and it was done to perfection lead by Event Planner extraordinaire Emily Barnes and all the staff was great !Highly recommend. !Rooms: The rooms were spacious and cleanFood & drinks: We stayed at the Colgate Inn for a recent visit to see our daughter . The rooms were clean and modern , the Hotel food was excellent and the Bar Hospitality superb lead by Bartender Shannon who couldn't be nicer or do more for everyone .We had a dinner event downstairs in the Lobby Room and it was done to perfection lead by Event Planner extraordinaire Emily Barnes and all the staff was great !Highly recommend. !
-
February 2024 by Kristin
We loved staying here! The accommodations were very nice and offered everything we needed. The hotel service was friendly and the whole place is just really beautiful. The restaurant downstairs offered a great breakfast too. It also is within walking distance of coffee shops, a movie theater, and an ice cream/chocolate store.
-
February 2024 by Julie Wick
Updated menu, tasty drinks, beautiful fireplace.Safety: Well patrolled college town.Walkability: Walk to everything from grocery to spa.Food & drinks: Updated menu, tasty drinks, happy hour specials.
-
January 2024 by Mike Celano
Great
-
January 2024 by Alyssa Diemer
My family and I stayed there and had a wonderful time! The hotel is very cozy and was decorated so festive for Christmas. The food at the Inn was delicious, especially the beet salad! The service was amazing, very responsive and helpful! It’s walkable to everything in town. We will be coming back for sure! Thank you for a wonderful stay. The puzzle table in the lobby is a nice addition, something fun to while waiting in lobby.
-
January 2024 by Collette Marie Pretre
Kendra and Dennis went above and beyond to help make a special night extraordinary! Everyone at the Inn welcomes you with a friendly smile and is very accommodating when it comes to any special request. The beds are comfortable, bedrooms are clean and decorated beautifully, especially the bathroom with amazing tiled walk in shower.The tavern serves excellent food and beverages highlighting local farms and breweries. I had the Beet salad and Salmon~ delicious. My favorite spot is in front of the fireplace on a snowy night. Definitely a favorite in Hamilton.
-
January 2024 by Wendy Henry
We had a very pleasant experience with our waitress Shannon. Shannon was very professional and fun, as well as engaging...We had the best experience with lunch at the Inn's Tavern at The Colgate Inn. The French Onion Soup was delicious, and the wings were tasty to finish it off with a cookie in a cast-iron skillet (recommended by Shannon). We will definitely come again. Happy New Year!
-
January 2024 by Johnny Gustafson
Kali was our server and we appreciated her candor and attitude. The food was also excellent. Between the food and her service we will definitely be back.
-
December 2023 by Gary Beehler III
Absolutely beautiful property. All around a great vibe. The staff were all very friendly and kind. Amazing atmosphere to dine drink and stay. One of a kind experience you have to check it out for yourself really.
-
December 2023 by Samantha H
Absolutely beautiful inside and out. Restaurant is delicious. Couldn't ask for a better stay!Rooms: Small but perfect for 1-2 people, especially if you aren't planning to spend much time there.
-
December 2023 by Lucie Reynolds
lovely lovely place to stay with amazing people and food!
-
December 2023 by Brendan McLaughlin
We just went to the restaurant. Had a great burger, and wings. Shannon, our server and was totally delightful . The atmosphere was cozy and funWalkability: Right in downtown Hamilton
-
December 2023 by Bruce Tompkins
Due to an early morning surgery at Community Hospital, we decided to get a room locally the night before. We had heard about the Colgate Inn before, but had never stayed overnight. Fortunately for us there was a recent cancelation and we were able to get a room as the Inn was totally full. We could not have been more impressed. The front counter team was super friendly and accommodating, the room was just perfect, and the meal at the restaurant was to die for. (No pun intended because of my surgery). We highly recommend this beautiful establishment and excellent staff.
