Jewelry Stores near Island Park, NY

30 locations found near Island Park
View Map

“Did an amazing job on me and my wife’s rings highly recommend. thoroughly cleaned and sized. has a beautiful selection of all kinds of great jewelry for a great price.”

4.6 Superb73 Reviews

“I love this place! Ask for Ron or Ed! Besides being Ed's youngest brother, Ron is also a gemologist and very knowledgeable in many areas especially art. Been working with them as a satisfied customer since their father founded the operation…. I'm a very happy and satisfied customer! A+++++”

3.9 Good19 Reviews

“The owner was very helpful and kind. He had great knowledge of the item I brought to him. I was grateful to come across this business and will definitely come back in the future if needed.”

5 Superb362 Reviews

“J & H jewelry store is the best store around ever. The owner and the staff are welcoming and helpful without being pushy or rushing you. The inventory is amazing. I cant say enough about this store! The repair person treats your jewelry as special as you feel it is and is an expert at what she does. I highly recommend this store”

5 Superb263 Reviews

“My boyfriend and I went in today to look at engagement rings for the time. The moment we walked in the vibe was very welcoming. Donna sat with us and showed me many options and let me try on everything that I wanted. Donna answered all of our questions and made the whole experience extremely comfortable. 100% recommend this store the service was impeccable.”

4.9 Superb178 Reviews

“I have been going to Forever Diamonds for a couple of years. Never a bad experience! From buying jewelry to replacing batteries to steam cleaning they are great. They are friendly and most important, they don't pressure you into anything. They want you to enjoy what you purchased. So nice to have small businesses you can go to and be happy”

4.9 Superb148 Reviews

“Simply amazing. Bennett and his team (Natalie, Danny, & Naheed to name a few) truly went above and beyond to deliver a white-glove experience that is second to none.My custom engagement ring and wedding bands came out exactly how I had envisioned them and the quality and attention to detail is impeccable. The team did a great job of educating me on my options and I left feeling awesome about my purchase. To further sweeten things, I also went home with my dream watch!I highly recommend stopping by Kravit for your jewelry and watch needs. You will not be disappointed and their brand new showroom is pure luxury. I hope to be a client for years to come.”

4.9 Superb137 Reviews

“EXCEPTIONAL, SUPPERB, HUMBLE, KIND, GENEROUS, OUTSTANDING, VERY RESPECTFUL & UNDERSTANDING, BLESS THEIR HEART ❤️ ? ?, I RECOMMEND ANY & EVERYBODY TO UTILIZE THEIR SERVICES, IM GOING TO SEND THEM SOME ROSES AND BAKE THEM A CAKE?”

4.9 Superb120 Reviews

“I hardly recommended this jewelry, this guy did some heart design jewelry for my mother in lawI came to get fix few things great prices .Thanks Sir to keep good work”

4.9 Superb119 Reviews

“What a nice surprise..sent my husband to get batteries for a few of my many watches.. no charge. Will return for watch and other jewelry repairs and purchases. Thank you”

5 Superb68 Reviews

“Lori was very helpful and friendly. Sometimes situations in life may bring you into places like pawnshops and what you hope for is a no judgment zone and a friendly environment and that’s what I gotThanks”

5 Superb68 Reviews

“Brought my daughter for ear piercing. The ladies were kind, very professional, and really took the time to ensure the piercing was in the right spot. They have a pretty selection of jewelry. It was a very good experience overall.”

4.9 Superb97 Reviews

“My boyfriend just proposed with the most stunning ring from Gennaro Jewelers- we are so happy with the final setting and he was so thrilled to feel like family working with Angela and the rest of the team. The most special day of our lives- thank you for your knowledge, keen listening, and attention to detail, true experts and would HIGHLY recommend!”

4.8 Superb169 Reviews

“Had a great experience at HL Gross. Krysi is friendly , courteous and patient as she took the time to answer all of my questions and followed up with me when i reached out via email. She went above and beyond in helping me with my purchase as she delivered as promised.i highly recommend this store and will be doing more purchases.an update 10/19/23, Krysi came through once again for a special occasion . Thank you”

4.8 Superb142 Reviews

“I found this establishment through Google search and read the reviews so I decided to check them out. The owner is an incredibly nice gentleman that repaired a very old piece of jewelry given to me by my late mother. Less than 48 hours and it was like new. Kind, knowledgeable and quick service. I highly recommend!”

4.9 Superb80 Reviews

“I had a wonderful experience at Mathew James Jewelers! Excellent customer service! Mathew was very honest and helpful! They have gained a new customer! Thank you so much!”

4.8 Superb124 Reviews

“Rachel is a very good saleswoman. Made sure I was comfortable with the price I was paying and gave me a free cleaning and fix of my bracelet that I brought in on the house.”

4.8 Superb116 Reviews

“I needed some links removed from my watch bracelet. I usually do my watch maintenance myself but I was unable to get the pins out with this particular watch. I brought it to a jeweler by my house and they were unable to do it after trying for a half hour and offered to charge $50 to send it out to have it done. Thankfully I declined and brought it to Denise at Unicorn Jewelers who had it done in 5 minutes. Highly recommend!”

4.9 Superb69 Reviews

“My experience From Italy With Love has been truly exceptional. From the attention to detail of the design to the high quality service from Jeff and his staff, they have made this process as easy and as joyful as possible. I love my necklaces. Thank you so much !!”

4.8 Superb82 Reviews

“My new go to Jewelry Store. Spent the morning driving around looking for a jeweler who could fix my treasured chain. Stopped at the "bigger" jewelry stores on long beach road before finding this gem. None of the bigger stores were able to accommodate my needs. Their sales associate Linda was terrific! She and Andy have earned my trust. Bringing my Citizen watch to get fixed next. Fast service.... fair price.... Thanks for everything!!!!”

4.8 Superb69 Reviews

“I had a great experience at Bolila Jewelry. I needed a watch battery and the expert was able to take care of this with great professionalism.The store was very busy, and she asked me if I wanted to drop off the watch and pick it up later, caring very much about not inconveniencing me, but I preferred to wait! And the job was done very well. Definitely worth waiting for!!”

4.9 Superb47 Reviews

“Josef was able to help fix my watch that was given to me by my wife for our wedding. He was working on a Sunday, was transparent about price, helpful, and quick. Thank you !”

5 Superb35 Reviews

“They are awesome!! Very friendly and knowledgeable. They were calm and patient with my 5 month old daughter when getting her ears pierced. Would definitely recommend!!”

4.8 Superb63 Reviews

“Awesome customer service. No job seems too big or too small, they treat you the same whether you are spending a lot of money or a little bit of money. Every single person working there is professional, knowledgeable and just nice. That's not a word that use much anymore... But they are all extremely nice. It's a pleasure to go into the store.”

4.8 Superb62 Reviews

“This place is simple & quick! I’m getting rid of some last minute things before moving away & the exchange was easy & the customer service was superb. I’ll definitely be returning with other items.”

4.7 Superb101 Reviews

“Such a wonderful experience while I was here searching for wedding bands. Very personable, patient, reasonably priced and informative. I'll definitely be coming back here in the future!”

4.9 Superb41 Reviews

“Just had a wonderful experience selling and doing business with Jeffrey. Was very quick and informational and received money upfront. Would 100% buy and resell here again!”

4.8 Superb56 Reviews

“Lijia is the best seller I have ever had, the store has variety of good items besides Lijia, the rest of the workers are very nice and have good knowledge of their products.”

4.7 Superb90 Reviews

“Sandy is the absolute best! I came here to get earrings for my bridesmaids and the customer service is unmatchable. She truly cares for her customers and provides the best experience. This has been one of my favorite experiences during wedding planning. Every bride should come here!”

5 Superb30 Reviews

“EXCEPTIONAL. Angela went above and beyond for me and I am very grateful for the exemplary customer service. Highly recommend the Madison's Niche Garden City location. I myself will be a repeat customer in the future!Back Story Summary: They helped me with getting a stuffed cat for my aunt, who loves cats, and was just put on hospice care. Was booked for a flight in the morning to go see my aunt in Indiana and Angela went above and beyond to work with my schedule to inure I got the stuffed animal for my aunt. Thank you sincerely!”

4.9 Superb33 Reviews