Ithaca Auto Service is highly recommended for its honest and efficient car care. Customers appreciate the dependable and knowledgeable mechanics who provide great service without upselling or unnecessary charges. Many reviews highlight the quick appointment availability, often accommodating same-day requests. The shop is praised for its fair pricing, making it a go-to place for various services, including brake repairs, oil changes, and maintenance on foreign cars. Long-time customers have consistently experienced good service over the years, noting the friendly and patient staff. A particular highlight includes the willingness to go above and beyond, such as checking issues for free or completing repairs promptly. Ithaca Auto Service has built a strong reputation in the community for being trustworthy and dedicated to quality service, ensuring that customers' vehicles are in excellent hands.
I always feel fair treatment here. They tell the truth, and are honest about pricing.
February 2026
Amazing! Knowledge/fast/effective! It’s critical that there are still some honest folks out there, especially given the fact that 90% + of garages on are on BS.
February 2026
1st time at this shop and am pleased with the service compared to three other garages I have been to before. The waiting room is certainly larger than most. The time waiting for the service needed was fine
