Shoe Stores in Ithaca, NY

“My boyfriend walks all day on concrete and his feet have been hurting a lot. I did a lot of research and compiled a list of recommended shoes for him to try. Then I did some research into shoe stores within an hour's drive. Fontana's had the most variety so that was our first stop. Jayden was so helpful - he started pulling a couple of shoes to get an idea of what features were most appealing. From there, he brought out a lot more based on preference. He was so knowledgeable about brands, applications of features, and very very patient with us. He focused on us for an hour until we decided on 2 pairs and I'm happy to report that those shoes were a great choice :)”

“Great vibe. The employees are great to be around and are extremely helpful and will make sure to get you exactly what you need. They take the time to answer any questions you might have. They will also help suggest options and explain why certain materials are good for x events or seasons.

They also provide tailoring which is amazing. Overall a great place, great vibe, and great people.”

“Shout our to Zach! Had a kiddo's scooter wheel get jammed at the skate park- the only place in town for quick bearing. And he even plugged them in for me. Skate park day saved!
Excellent customer service, excellent member of the our community.”

“The salesperson at this place was honest and informative about winter boots and shoes. The prices were reasonable too, overall it's a great store for shopping winter shoes.”

“i absolutely love this plato’s closet location! every time i come in, the customer service is seriously next level. the staff is always so friendly, helpful, and genuinely excited to assist you in finding what you’re looking for. they go above and beyond to make sure you have the best shopping experience possible—whether it’s helping me track down a specific size, suggesting pieces that match my style, or just greeting me with a smile when i walk through the door.

their selection is amazing too! everything is super trendy and on point with current styles, so it feels like shopping at a high end boutique but without breaking the bank. the store is always well organized and clean, which makes browsing so easy and fun. i love that they carry so many name brands and unique pieces (i’ve even found concert merch!)

i absolutely love how they post on their instagram story everyday too, it definitely gives the feeling of being informed on what is in the store everyday! i have also been in a few times at a later time in the day, and they’re always able to accommodate me.

honestly, this store has become my go-to spot for affordable fashion because they really care about their customers and the experience they provide. 10/10 recommend this plato’s closet to anyone who wants great deals, and the best customer service around!”