Shoe Stores in Ithaca, NY

“Shawn has done an amazing job as a local small business owner. Anytime I have needed a certain pair of shoes for myself or a family member they have been able to get what I want. 10/10”

““I had a great experience at Benjamin Peters. The staff was professional, knowledgeable, and attentive throughout the entire process. Sam took the time to understand exactly what I was looking for and provided excellent guidance on fit, style, and alterations. The quality of the clothing and craftsmanship exceeded my expectations, and the final result fit perfectly. I highly recommend Benjamin Peters to anyone looking for quality menswear and outstanding customer service.””

“Shop is very sleek with wide selection of apparel, shoes, and gear. Andrew and Zack are both very helpful. I’ve been coming here for over a decade and have never left disappointed.”

“The friendliest and most compassionate associates are found here and I resolved my time-sensitive wardrobe issue with time to spare thanks to such kind attentiveness on my visit. I’m usually a catastrophically-shy default-online shopper but they made my day and I will have to visit again.”

“Excellent staff!! I was looking for a particular brand of sneakers in a small size, but they didn't have them in stock. Staff went out of their way to help me! They recommended that I try on sneakers that were a half size larger, and they surprisingly fit me well. Staff recommended I try them out at home on a clean surface, and if I felt they didn't fit right, I could bring them back, and they could order the smaller ones. Very happy with my purchase!”

“i absolutely love this plato’s closet location! every time i come in, the customer service is seriously next level. the staff is always so friendly, helpful, and genuinely excited to assist you in finding what you’re looking for. they go above and beyond to make sure you have the best shopping experience possible—whether it’s helping me track down a specific size, suggesting pieces that match my style, or just greeting me with a smile when i walk through the door.

their selection is amazing too! everything is super trendy and on point with current styles, so it feels like shopping at a high end boutique but without breaking the bank. the store is always well organized and clean, which makes browsing so easy and fun. i love that they carry so many name brands and unique pieces (i’ve even found concert merch!)

i absolutely love how they post on their instagram story everyday too, it definitely gives the feeling of being informed on what is in the store everyday! i have also been in a few times at a later time in the day, and they’re always able to accommodate me.

honestly, this store has become my go-to spot for affordable fashion because they really care about their customers and the experience they provide. 10/10 recommend this plato’s closet to anyone who wants great deals, and the best customer service around!”