Thrift Stores in Ithaca, NY

“An amazing place, there should be places like this everywhere! I just love it, I have saved hundreds of dollars buying at mama goose and always the best quality!”

“Out of the two locations the downtown seems to be the best of the two I always seem to find something of interest and the prices are fair.
Staff is pleasant and the store has a lot to offer.
Out of all the secondhand stores in Ithaca this and Thrifty are my go to stops!”

“Prices on certain things are questionable for a thrift store, however overall, it's a decent thrift store. I was able to thrift a coffee table and an endstand to refurbish for our home renovation. I definitely walked out with a large purchase of books and picture frames too. I'll definitely visit again as I've now been twice.”

“Ah, comrades, let me speak plainly of a small, unassuming place on Elmira Road—this Goodwill of Ithaca. One might be tempted to pass it by, imagining it nothing more than a depot of cast-offs and the refuse of our endlessly consuming society. But step inside and you will find something else entirely: a quiet rebellion against waste, against the tyranny of novelty, against the capitalist delusion that worth must always be bought new and at great cost.

There is a certain dignity in the garments hanging neatly along the aisles, garments that have already served once, and now await another life. Here, a wool coat whose seams still hold strong; there, a cotton dress with history woven into its threads. These clothes do not clamor for attention as the mass-produced commodities of department stores do—they wait, patient and honest, asking only to be useful again. And in their reuse, we resist: we resist the factories that churn out cheaply made clothing on the backs of exploited labor; we resist the cultural indoctrination that tells us to discard what can be repaired, or to replace simply for fashion’s sake.

But beyond the items themselves, what strikes me most is the spirit. The employees work with calm attentiveness, and there is mutual recognition between shopper and institution—that small, powerful idea that value is something created by community, not dictated by profit alone. University students, families, elders, the frugal, the imaginative, the principled—all walk those aisles together, equal in purpose. In such places we glimpse what society could be: functional, resourceful, humane.

So yes: visit the Goodwill in Ithaca. Not merely to save a dollar, though you surely will—but to participate in a different kind of economy, one rooted in responsibility, imagination, and solidarity. In every reused coat, in every restored chair, in every mended shirt, there is the whisper of a better world.”

“I love second hand places, you never know what you'll find! I have to add however that this particular visit was something I wasn't thrilled with. It was getting close to closing time, which was announced several times within the last 1/2 hr. Then with a line of 8-10 customers, me being 3rd , it was announced that the lights would be turned off in 2 minutes! I actually turned and asked the person behind me if they thought everyone was going to be left in the dark, and if so how were we going to be checked out? They wondered the same thing. I got out before the lights went out, so idk what happened after that!
I also want to say that I've purchased A LOT of things from this place over the years, although sometimes not something I'd like to have because the prices are somewhat ridiculous on alot of stuff! But on the other hand, I have gotten things real inexpensive knowing they were definitely worth more! So it's a choice of how much you want something and how much you want to pay.
Another thing I'd like to mention, I've never liked the way clothes are divided by color rather than size! If you're looking for a specific size in a certain color it can take a very long time to go through to see if you can find the size you're looking for!”