Colonial Stamp & Coin Co. is a trusted business that buys and sells coins, bullion, collectibles, paper money, gold and silver jewelry, sterling silver flatware, and hollowware. The shop also offers some stamps and trading cards, along with basic collector supplies. Located at 656 Aaron Court in Kingston, NY, the business has recently moved from a long-standing location on Boices Lane and is currently in a soft opening, operating by appointment or when available. Customers appreciate the straightforward, honest, and trustworthy service provided by Neil, who is known for paying top dollar and having reliable silver in stock. Many clients have expressed satisfaction with their transactions, citing transparency, fair prices, and a friendly atmosphere. Neil’s extensive knowledge and fair dealings make him a preferred choice for buying and selling precious metals and collectibles. Overall, Colonial Stamp & Coin Co. is recognized for its reliability, fair pricing, and knowledgeable service in the collectibles and precious metals market.
I took my mom's coins to Neil, and I felt he was very honest and fair. He gave me a good price on the spot for my coin, and gave me honest information about what was going on with the silver market and why I should hold on to the coins until the refineries are back up and running.
January 2026
Was my first time here and had an excellent experience. Was a pleasure doing business here.
January 2026
very professional and honest. Very easy to deal with .
