We've been enjoying Butter Cooky for decades! Simply delicious!! I am pretty impartial to the Napoleon cake and cannoli
March 2024
Best Bakery on Long Island. Cynthia makes the best cappuccinos. The owner Benny is there every day, making sure customers are being taken care of. Quick service with delicious cakes, pastries, and cookies.
February 2024
Got a cake recently, the writing was horrible. I was embarrassed when I opened in the birthday girl presence. The the cake was delicious though. I’d buy the same cake again, but they need work on writing neatly- no chicken scratch esp for a bday.
From these humble beginnings, we have continued to grow and expand in our never-ending pursuit for excellence, and have gained a loyal following. Chef Borgognone's devotion, diligence, authentic recipes, and elegant presentations have allowed Buttercooky Bakery to earn its current high standards nationally and become one of Long Island's landmarks, as it is known as today. If you ever have any questions or feedback for us, don't hesitate to let us know!
