Fantastic Toyage Inc. is a collectible toy store with something for everyone. It carries a vast inventory including action figures, statues, prop replicas, dolls, model kits, comics, Disney items, toy soldiers, plates, and much more from lines like Star Wars, Marvel, Batman, and vintage brands. The selection is fantastic, with plenty of value and rare stuff, making it one of the best collections on Long Island. It is a real store and museum with a museum-grade, museum-style collection rich in pop culture history from vintage to modern. The owner is very kind and helpful. It is a wonderful place to discover and an amazing experience just to walk through, where visitors can be there for hours in toy and collectible glory. The only noted issue is parking, as there is no mentioned lot behind or near the store. It is a very nice place to visit and find many nice collectibles, especially for those seeking a white whale or a vintage rarity.
Fantastic Toyage is truly revenge of the collectibles!!! Located on Merrick rd in Massapequa, every toy enthusiast should visit this nostalgic store!!! The inventory at this place is awsome, Alex is super cool & friendly!!! I highly recommend!!!!
November 2025
Love this place. Well organized. Went in to pick up birthday presents. Clean store, awesome selection, awesome customer service! Definitely will be recommending this place to family and friends! And definitely will be back for more!
