Toy Stores near Massapequa, NY

25 locations found near Massapequa

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 5288 Merrick Rd, Massapequa NY 11758

    4.3 Superb 122 reviews

    “Fantastic Toyage is truly revenge of the collectibles!!! Located on Merrick rd in Massapequa, every toy enthusiast should visit this nostalgic store!!! The inventory at this place is awsome, Alex is super cool & friendly!!! I highly recommend!!!!”

  2. 6150 Sunrise Highway, Massapequa NY 11758

    3.5 Good 75 reviews

    “Had a great experience at this store with Gamestops team member Krsyten. She was extremely helpful and patient while still being attentive to other customers who were shopping. Very knowledgeable with the current stores inventory and made great recommendations for me to pick up on the Nintendo Switch! Looking forward to returning to this store for my future purchases. Great staff and atmosphere.”

  3. In the Great South Bay Shopping Center, 1021 Montauk Highway, West Babylon NY 11704

    4.8 Superb 79 reviews

    “Found this place on Google for my little guy! Worth a trip from East Quogue. Unique Lego sets. Great built sets. Generous grab and go selection. Staff friendly and fair! Will definitely be back!”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 138 Gardiners Ave, Levittown NY 11756

    4.8 Superb 74 reviews

    “Kidz Toys is the best toy store around. The selection is fantastic, with something for kids of all ages and interests. The staff is extremely friendly and helpful Go get your needohs from this store!! 10/10 .”

  6. 203 Airport Plaza Blvd, Farmingdale NY 11735

    4.8 Superb 44 reviews

    “First time in today! They had the cutest things. I was upset I was in a rush to get to the airport. I wanted to look around, I wanted one of everything!The whole store is very inviting, clean organized! I was shocked to see that in a card and gift store. the woman at checkout who helped me sign up for the rewards program was super sweet can't wait to go back!”

  7. Sunrise Promenade, 5224 Sunrise Highway, Massapequa Park NY 11762

    4.5 Superb 175 reviews

    “This is a great bookstore! I have been frequenting it for years. It's my go-to when I am in need of something, or just want something new for my interests. Very helpful and professional staff. Love the old school quiet atmosphere. Two thumbs up.”

  8. 3639 Merrick Rd, Seaford NY 11783

    4.7 Superb 112 reviews

    “WHAT A NICE TOY STORE , I MET OWNER WHAT A NICE COOL MAN ,THEY HAVE ALL KINDS OF TOYS FOR KIDS OR TEENS MY SON BOUGHT NEEDHOS GUM DROPS COUPLE, MY FRIEND BOUGHT THESE DOLLS VERY NICE QUALITY , THE STAFF GIRLS ARE VERY KIND ,POLITE WE WILL BE BACK WHEN WE COME TO LONG ISLAND AGAIN FROM CITY. THERES SOMETHING 🎩 MAGICAL ABOUT MOM AND POP TOY STORES ITS MAGICAL ,ALSO IT REMINDS ME OF THE 1980S GREATEST DECADE OLD SCHOOL. YOURS TRULY EDDIE CUZZ,,, AND SAL SON.”

  9. 21 Brookvale Ave, West Babylon NY 11704

    4.7 Superb 82 reviews

    “Staff were very nice and helpful. Very good service. This store had a good selection and a lot to choose from. I highly recommend this store if you are a collectors .”

  10. 37 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst NY 11757

    4.6 Superb 52 reviews

    “Great store for horror movie fans and gift givers. Always something new in the store to check out. you can tell the small business owner puts a lot of work into the store”

  11. 107 Stewart Ave, Hicksville NY 11801

    4.9 Superb 66 reviews

    “Phoenix Comic Shop is an awesome spot for any comic book collector. The owner was super nice, welcoming, and really helpful throughout my visit. You can tell he actually cares about the hobby and takes time to make sure you find what you’re looking for instead of just trying to make a sale.The prices are also very good Whether you’re hunting for new issues, back issues, or just browsing, there’s a solid selection and very good variety Overall, I’d definitely recommend Phoenix Comic Shop to any comic fan. It’s the kind of place that makes you want to come back again. I loved it !”

  12. 630 Old Country Rd Spc 1057, Garden City NY 11530

    4.3 Superb 109 reviews

    “Had the pleasure of meeting Bobby today, he is incredible! He is smart, knowledgeable, and glad he was able to give me more information on the new Batman Lego I purchased for my 10 year old nephew! Thank you again for such an amazing experience at Legos in Garden City :)”

  13. 160 Walt Whitman Rd, Huntington Station NY 11746

    4.5 Superb 57 reviews

    “I actually love this Build a bear so much, probably one of the best locations. I haven't been to any Build a bear in YEARS and the staff were so extremely nice to me. Some scents and textures bother me, and they were very patient with helping me get my plushie exactly how I wanted. I should've paid better attention to the names of the staff, I think the one who did the stuffing was Natalie (I'm so sorry if I spelled that wrong) I'll definitely be coming back! I didn't feel like I was unwelcomed or judged. You can tell the staff enjoys what they're doing and puts effort into providing good customer service.”

  14. 1162 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh NY 11793

    4.6 Superb 41 reviews

    “Every time I visit this card and gift shop,they couldnt be nicer.They are happy to help you.You will not feel rushed,and their cards are beautiful.The owner and the staff keep the store so clean and will step away from the counter to help you. Inventory is not just cards, they have sports memorabilia, special gifts, And a lot of winning lottery tickets”

  15. 2170 Merrick Ave, Merrick NY 11566

    4.2 Good 7 reviews

    “Simply Super stationery-papers, wrappings, cards, candies, cigarettes, very small items, very small gifts, notions, very small beverages; &, very small snacks selection, a few toys, many stuffed animals, lottery tickets; &, a small choice of useful household items kind of place.In general; &, especially, in the sense, of both of the Mom; &, Pop, co-owner's vibes; moods; approach; sensibilities; attitudes; feelings; &, policies; they're quite welcoming; accepting; tolerant; giving; accepting; &, embracing folks.At their quarters that they have, now; at this point; they are downsized to rather much smaller proportions; to state the barest minimum in descriptions; &, their, current customer demands are scarce; &, very narrow in sales scope; they, are therefore: few; &, far between; &, their stock of inventory is slight; restricted; &, gigantically limited; but, their hearts are: surely, filled w/: overflowing respect; &, assorted abundance. However, they have been local shopkeepers for quite a very long time.Their business codes of conduct in: commerce; transactions; &, personal demeanor; certainly guide; &, reflect all of that; as, both: George; who is: tolerant; patient; amiable; amenable; hapless; slow-going; accessible; available; present; understanding; &, accomodating; etc.; amongst his many other good characteristics; &, his, long-term: hugely devoted; undyingly loyal; highly caring; &, extremely loving; very concerned; &, greatly warm; elegant; classically tasteful; high-class; quietly, very shy; naivete-infused; and, rather conservative, spouse: Mini; who is an ->huge; frequent; &, regular help to him; in many ways; in the, constant; ongoing operation, of their business; &, their store; have both found ways, that they are enabled, w/: God's assistive support, to let those great qualities, that they mutually possess, shine through; &, be expressed; consistently, in their business practices; &, professional conduct; &, within the insides of their, private home; &, small family lives.They are without a, doubt: some of the, gentlest; most humble; nicest; kindest; low-toned; under-keyed; easiest-going; most laid-back; most polite; &, most soft-spoken; understated; sweetest; warmest; friendliest; most accomodating; and, most sophisticated combined vendors and proprietors; as well as: local community families; and, are amongst the: most, normal; simplest; plain-est; guile-less; most, routine; most, ordinary; yet: so caring; most, >decent; most, chill; &, most amiable; liberal; tolerant; open-minded; &, accomodating, of: small hamlet; tiny shop proprietors; and, to be found in this local small community; &, its' general, immediate, surrounding area.They also happen to be: very largely involved; engaged; committed; present; &, interested types of enthusiastic; emphatic "Family People"; incusive of: family of origin; &, their greater community, at large. Their best operating practices, include: being very good group members, as regards, any roles they inhabit; whether that involves, being: store owners; &, vendors, for very many multiple long years; parents/grandparents/family members; or: small-business operators/regional citizens/and, community anchors; as well as: just good people; as one is, both: clearly; &, probably, ever likely to be: able to; or, in actuality; come to: know; meet; or: find.If one encounters nearly any problem at all; here, it most likely will be addressed w/: some sufficiently adequate solution of resolve; or: reasonable accomodation; albeit, even this elevated vendor; and, shop, are not: perfect; like >all things in the human-made world.A. - [Up-Dated: Sun.-12/24/23.].”

  16. 345 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview NY 11803

    4 Good 68 reviews

    “This neighborhood toy store is such a gem! The selection is always fun, unique, and perfect for kids of all ages. What really sets it apart, though, are the employees—they are incredibly kind, patient, and always willing to help you find exactly what you need. You can tell they genuinely care about making every visit special. It’s the kind of place that feels warm and welcoming the moment you walk in. Highly recommend for gifts, birthdays, or just a little treat!”

  17. 1958 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow NY 11554

    4 Good 14 reviews

    “First time shopping at this location and my experience was great, the store was clean the shelves were stocked and Lexi at checkout was extremely sweet and helpful.”

  18. 918 Main St Suite 17, Farmingdale NY 11735

    3.7 Good 5 reviews

    “Harry and his beautiful family's please keep up the wonderful work you are doing in the community you guys always let everyone that come through the door feel welcome with a smile and most of all you know most of your customers by name keep on serving the community.”

  19. 2847 Jerusalem Ave, Wantagh NY 11793

    3.9 Good 93 reviews

    “I heard great things about the store so I decided to visit I immediately fell in love with the staff, the community and little by little I started going there more often I forgot my one piece binder at the store(I know I know how dare I forget my binder) Reached out To them and they told me not to worry, they had it and it’s behind the counter. I recommend this place to anybody That’s looking for one piece and any other TCG related games They have earned a lifetime customer”

  20. 630 Old Country Rd Spc 1049, Garden City NY 11530

    3.9 Good 176 reviews

    “Today my husband, my daughter & I went in hoping to make a gender reveal bear for our baby on the way. Marcel approached us immediately with great energy and once we told him our idea he was extremely energized to help us and ensure our experience was exciting. Marcel did the above and beyond for our experience and we can’t thank him enough! Thank you for being a part of our story and for the amazing attention to detail.”

  21. 239 Main St, Farmingdale NY 11735

    3.2 Average 11 reviews

    “Love this place! It’s the perfect Main St boutique - great spot for girly gifts, unique baby items, wedding/engagement, clothing, jewelry, home & dinner party decor. They also have personalized Long Island signs. Staff are friendly and down to earth.”

  22. 254 Sunrise Hwy, Freeport NY 11520

    3.8 Good 105 reviews

    “I give this a 5 star rating because they had dumplings, and they had a lot of new stuff that most blows do not have, and they had the cheese block and they had this stuff.I wanted , but some of the people were , we're rude but I don't go off how nice the people are I go off how good their stuff is. In what they have”

  23. 3041 Hempstead Turnpike Mezzanine Level, Levittown NY 11756

    3.6 Good 103 reviews

    “They have a great selection of singles and sealed product. Their pricing on singles is extremely fair. Definitely worth checking out if you are looking for specific cards”

  24. 380 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville NY 11802

    3.2 Average 41 reviews

    “Heard about this store from the LI Teachers group on FB. Greatest little find. Store has teacher supplies throughout but most of it is concentrated in the back. The woman at the register is extremely helpful. If you can’t find something, just ask her, she will let you know if they have any more in the back or if the are ordering more supplies. They also laminate anything you buy for free. Plus teachers get a 15% discount. Great store and customer service.”

  25. 1431 Old Country Road Next to Starbucks (Country Point Shops, Plainview NY 11803

    3 Average 145 reviews

    “This Candy Store has so much to choose from. There are gummy candies, sour candies, chocolate covered pretzels, truffles, novelty items and so much more. Will definitely be back!”

  26. 2705 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown NY 11756

    3.1 Average 233 reviews

    “Stopped in on a trip down here and they have an incredible selection of cards and the best prices I have seen at a card shop. I will stop back anytime Im in town.”

Advertisement

Toy Stores in nearby cities