Extra Space Storage in Middle Island, NY, offers a wide selection of storage options, including drive-up units, climate-controlled units, and parking spaces. The facility features electronic gate access, exceptional security, ADA compliance, and multiple entrance and exit gates, ensuring convenience and safety for all customers. Visitors can expect professionalism and cleanliness throughout the property. The staff, particularly the manager, is known for their exceptional customer service. Many reviews highlight Genevieve for her attentive and patient approach, making first-time renters feel comfortable and supported. She takes the time to understand each customer's needs and provides honest recommendations on the best storage solutions. Clients appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the helpfulness of the staff, which makes the process easy and stress-free. The facility is well-maintained, organized, and creates a sense of community among its customers. Extra Space Storage is highly recommended for anyone looking for reliable and quality storage solutions.
Rented via website and the process was easy to complete online but signed the agreement in the office to meet the store manager, Dennis, very helpful and clean facility.
June 2026
This facility was clean and had very nice staff. Never had any issues when I needed to drop off or pick up my things.
June 2026
I can't be happier. From walking in with a question about pricing, I signed the deal and walked out in under a half hour...all on my lunch break!
