Self Storage near Middle Island, NY

27 locations found near Middle Island

“I came to this facility unsure of what exactly I needed, Genevieve at the office listened to all of my needs and got me into the perfect size. It's really refreshing to have someone that truly listens and knows what they're doing.”

4.9 Superb141 Reviews

“They answered all my questions concerns and showed me around the facility. It was very clean and the staff was very professional. I'm going to recommend this facility to all my friends and family. I have been using storage for some time and this was by far the best facility”

4.9 Superb207 Reviews

“I purchased a unit to rent and a few days later, my moving plans changed. I called and spoke with Dennis who graciously refunded my payment. Thank you so much for your kindness Dennis. I will be sure to use Extra Space Storage in the future.”

4.9 Superb236 Reviews

“Daniel was fantatic. Took the time to make me aware of what exactly i was getting into and guided me through the process with ease. Highly recfomend dealing with him. Good man.”

4.9 Superb221 Reviews

“I can’t say enough good things about Extra Space Storage— patchogue location, but especially about Mike and Frank.

I was completely panicked and needed help, and they didn’t just do their jobs—they went above and beyond. They took extra steps to make sure I was okay and truly taken care of, and that level of dedication is rare these days.

Extra Space Storage has always been clean, convenient, and safe, but what really sets this location apart is the people. Mike and Frank exemplify professionalism, compassion, and a genuine commitment to excellence.

When you’re stressed and overwhelmed, having staff like this makes all the difference. They turned a really difficult moment into one where I felt supported and respected. Thank you both—you made a lasting impression.”

4.9 Superb150 Reviews

“RIS at the public stores in coram is the number one customer service in ever coming across i really have to give a five and if there where more i would not hesitate to give it to him”

4.9 Superb178 Reviews

“As a newly single mom, with her hands full….i was having trouble with the key to my storage unit, Jasmine in the office…was SO INCREDIBLY HELPFUL…it’s been rough for me because we had just moved into the townhouse community next door. I just can’t thank her enough…I don’t know what I would have done!”

4.9 Superb128 Reviews

“I stored my belongings at Extra Space Storage for 16 months and everything went smoothly. The facility was consistently clean, secure, and easy to access. Overall, a solid and reliable storage option. I will use them in the future if needed.”

4.8 Superb154 Reviews

“Had a great experience renting a new storage space. Joseph the store manager is very pleasant and made the end of a horrible day with movers better. Thank you for being so kind Joseph. I recommend this facility!”

4.8 Superb129 Reviews

“Angela was the best part of my experience here..... She's an amazing person, very helpful and accommodating.... I hope management can see her worth....

Thank you Angela and I wish you all the best!”

4.8 Superb183 Reviews

“Great service. My restoration company used this company to delivery a large pod to my property. The staff was professional. The delivery and pickup guy was great. Prompt delivery and pickup. They will be 1st choice if I need a pod in the future.”

4.9 Superb71 Reviews

“Very clean storage facility and staff go out of there way to make you feel welcome and show you your new storage space...very good management..5 stars out of 5 stars!!”

4.9 Superb72 Reviews

“Mario in the Office was great. He was very efficient at getting things done. He actually called me to follow up and make sure everything was going well and it doesn’t matter that I am only renting a very small unit he will still come by to check that I’m satisfied with my experience with istorage”

4.7 Superb156 Reviews

“Front desk representatives so helpful and kind Tia went the extra mile to make sure I had the best rate for the storage room size I needed. Upon upgrading she made sure the upgrade storage room was right next door. I moved further away from these units but just because how they made it such an easy process I wanted to stay at these units.Thank you Prime Storage Bohemia Team”

4.7 Superb101 Reviews

“I was experiencing tremendous difficulty reaching someone at my Public Storage location in Commack. No one was there to assist. Terrance at another location was so helpful it’s unbelievable. He took my payment and truly took care of me!!! Thank you Terrance!! I really appreciate it.”

4.7 Superb93 Reviews

“On my journey to find a storage unit, I came across public storage in Mount Sinai the property manager Alex did a great job at giving me a tour of the property. Very knowledgeable with what the property has to offer. I would recommend this location to anyone who is looking for a storage unit.”

4.7 Superb145 Reviews

“Angela M. Is by far the best person to do business with – she is hands-down the best storage facility representative I’ve ever worked with.
From the moment I walked in, Angela made the entire process incredibly easy and stress-free. She listened carefully to exactly what I needed (parking), asked smart questions I hadn’t even thought of, and then walked me through every available option without trying to upsell me on things I didn’t need.
Her knowledge of the facility is impressive -
What really stands out though is her genuine kindness and patience. She treated me like her only customer of the day even though I could see she was busy. When I had a small question about access hours, she responded within minutes even though it was after normal business hours.
In an industry where most people feel like just another contract, Angela makes you feel valued and taken care of. She’s professional, warm, incredibly knowledgeable, and honestly just a pleasure to deal with.
If you’re looking for storage in this area, do yourself a favor and ask for Angela M. – you will not be disappointed. She’s the gold standard.
Thank you, Angela, for making a stressful move so much easier! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐”

4.7 Superb80 Reviews

“Brian has been nothing short of amazing as the property manager. He’s always attentive to our needs and goes above and beyond to ensure everything is taken care of. His professionalism and dedication make storing here a breeze.”

4.7 Superb124 Reviews

“I came to this place to check out some prices for the storage rooms and Angela M. Help me soo much, where she go over the sales with me, she went way out of her way looking at some different spaces she was soo wonderful she helped me with so many questions I had for her and she was soo clear for me to understand and we looked around the place is so clean. I will be back again i want only her to help me im going to tell my friends and family Thank You Angela M for your help”

4.7 Superb140 Reviews

“After having a VERY difficult time completing the sign up on line, I saw Rich at the Church St. location and he easily saw me through the whole process. He was professional, helpful and absolute pleasure to work with. Storage unit looks clean,well maintained, and again, quite honestly,Rich made thewhole process much better than I'd experienced on line. GREATJOB!”

4.7 Superb110 Reviews

“We just used Avatar for a move across state lines, the guys were super polite and hardworking. Rob was the driver and there were two other younger gentlemen. I would recommend.”

4.8 Superb105 Reviews

“The gentlemen (Eric) who helped me was great both picking up and dropping off. Always had a smile on his face. He even offered an arm to help me out of the truck. I'm a 64 yr old disabled woman and the truck is very high up.”

4.7 Superb85 Reviews

“Claude was very helpful, and answered all questions that I had… and walked me through the process, explaining everything in detail I would definitely recommend to friends and family
Thank you, Claude!
Rosa”

4.5 Superb104 Reviews

“What a refreshing experience at the Medford Prime Storage facility. Clean and no drama. No people hanging around, just a quiet storage facility. The Manager was friendly and helpful. Felt homey when I walked into the office. I recommend keeping any of your excess stuff there.”

4.5 Superb74 Reviews

“This is a storage facility company that cares about what you are storing and how much space you need. The manager, 'Dan', helps you get the size of the unit you need and at their, lowwer than anybody's, best price. Access is 24/7. You can feel comforitable that your unit is constantantly under close sucurity. The grounds are always kept clean and neat. If you need to store it, Dan is the Man @ ** PORT JEFFERSON STORAGE **”

4.6 Superb10 Reviews

“Decent place, temperature of storage area is a little warm for my liking. Returned a truck here as well was fairly painless. Good location easy to access.

Scanning your storage facility card out is weird. Scans in no problem but then when you scan out it welcomes you again. Idk we just left.”

4.5 Superb26 Reviews

“Quick and efficient service for a new hitch. Danny, who installed the hitch, went above and beyond. There was an issue with a part being sent (which had nothing to do with this location) and he made sure it got figured out. Then he took the time to explain the hitch, the cover and accessories I might want later. Very glad I chose to get this done here.”

4.4 Superb45 Reviews