Shoe Stores in New Hartford, NY

9 locations found near New Hartford
View Map

“I, unfortunately, have a swollen left foot due to lymphedema & was suggested to try here. The clerk was very helpful, even though they didn't have anything that would fit. An A+ for service.”

5 Superb85 Reviews

“Great selection of shoes. I was on the hunt for Uggs slippers and was searching every store imaginable, only to be told they were out of season. They had multiple styles/colors and left with a smile on my face.”

4.5 Superb25 Reviews

“Went here to buy my son sneakers for school. It was our first time. They didn't have a lot to choose from but he found Jordans that he liked. A little pricey but they seem to be good quality and Jordans are expensive no matter where you go.”

4.3 Superb6 Reviews

“Visited here yesterday, travelled from Rome as my very tall husband has very large feet and it's so difficult to find shoes that fit him. He's been needing just some very plain black work shoes that fit him and are comfortable, and we are happy to say we finally found some!This place had quite the variety of shoes, many in fact that were black with no decorative bits and suitable for work. My husband is generally a size 13.5, but the largest size we saw in all the boxes were 13. Initially we were worried, but after he tried on a few we found a pair of flexible Sketchers slip-on shoes that fit very well. Even though it was half a size smaller than his usual shoe size, the flexibility of the shoe was comfortable enough for him along with the memory foam sole.”

4 Good17 Reviews

“I walked into foot locker at sangertown square the young gentleman came directly asked me how could they help and I really appreciate that cuz some of the stores you see out in New Hartford they get a little intimidated I want to see a big black man walk through the store so I did appreciate the service they gave me”

4 Good30 Reviews

“Sometimes you walk into this store you see the most beautiful store of all time.Sometimes you walk into this store and you see what looks like a frag grenade being let off inside a shoe store.Sometimes customers will fight each other, sometimes workers of the store will fist fight each other.Sometimes there's amazing beautiful woman that you have no idea how they ended up in upstate NY. However at the end of the day it's just the good ol shoe department in New Hartford.”

3.9 Good18 Reviews

“Clean well stocked store great prices. Store manager Dom helped me tremendously. Advice on correct shoes for amputee with prosthetic legs. I will DEFINITELY be repeat customer. I highly recommend this store”

3.7 Good23 Reviews

“I love this place. I drop in at least 2-3 times a month to check out the clothes, shoes, and accessories. You can find real treasures here. I recently sold a few items of clothing that don't fit me anymore. As they were going through my stuff and deciding what to keep and what not to keep, I looked around and spotted a pair of brand new doc marten boots. With the $20 they gave me for the few items I sold to them that I never would have worn again, I bought the boots for $30. Let me just repeat that- I purchased a pair of brand spanking new Dr. Marten boots for $30 at this wonderful place. I felt really lucky as earlier that day, I was at DSW and was prepared to buy the same boots for over $160. I'm glad I didn't. To be honest, I should frequent Plato's on a more regular basis to find great deals like this more often, but I go when I have the time. I don't always have the time or patience to look through all the items, but when I do, I almost always find something great to buy for super cheap that ends up being my favorite piece of clothing that i wear often. I mean, shopping at Plato's is less expensive than purchasing from online second-hand sites like Poshmark, mercari, and others like it. I am so grateful that I live near this treasure trove of a store!”

2.6 Average20 Reviews

You May Also Like