Jewelry Stores in New Paltz, NY

7 locations found near New Paltz

“I had an amazing experience with Hudson Valley Goldsmith . Working with John was extremely comfortable and a smooth process. I have bought a few pieces and sold my gold and silver jewelry with John. I felt confident I was receiving the best price and care. John explained the whole process for selling and I was with him while he checked each piece of jewelry. I live out of town and consider my 6 hour drive worthwhile and will continue to do business with him. You can't go wrong working with Hudson Valley.”

4.8 Superb168 Reviews

“A wonderful shop, full with a variety of unique, magical products and gifts. Owner Karen is very genuine, and will eagerly help you find the right item you need. Highly recommend!”

5 Superb26 Reviews

“The perfect place to find the best, most unique and fitting gift. I've loved this store forever. Don't look any further. If you need a gift- for anyone- anyone- it is in this store. And to top it off they beautifully wrap for you. It's always special at Handmade. Treat yourself to something too. Jewelry, pottery, glassware, wooden items, clothing... So many great possibilities.”

4.6 Superb57 Reviews

“Best small town gift shop! Isabella and her family are so welcoming and they definitely know how to find unique treasures that appeal to anyone. I make sure to go here for all major holidays and birthday gifts!”

4.5 Superb47 Reviews

“Such a cool place to stop in at! They have some really neat stuff to check out, ranging from apparel, jewelry, and more.

The owner and staff are super nice people too! Definitely recommend stopping in and checking Heady Teddy's out!”

4.3 Superb33 Reviews

“So glad I stopped by. Everyone in the store is beyond friendly and welcoming. I got the coolest fordite necklace and when I asked to shorten it they helped me on the spot and Dean even made me the cutest earrings with the leftover beads. You can see the attention to detail and care everything is made with.

Sage and Tania were very personable, recommending me some great films in town too. Absolutely a stop worth making in New Paltz, I can’t wait to grow my collection with them.”

4.2 Good39 Reviews

“I thought this place was perfection. The displays were enchanting and I loved everything! Great selection of sunglasses and jewelry. I had to limit myself but I would definately go back. Staff was very friendly.”

3.3 Good22 Reviews