-
February 2024 by Felisa C.
Amish Market is great. Just sometimes find items that are too near or over expire dates.
-
January 2024 by Jonathan Robertson
Lovely lovely grocery market with ENDLESS variety of very high quality, clean food. I met the owner yesterday and we chatted for a long time about his love for his customers and the industry. A+ this place is the best grocery market in Manhattan!
-
January 2024 by Manolo G
The best grocery store in a mile or 2 mile radius. Broad selection across all products, good prices and location.
-
December 2023 by Paulina W.
I came here to pick up some food from the buffet and it was a pleasant experience. The staff was very friendly and there was a good variety of food. The food was also tasty. There were also a lot of items for sale here - if you need any groceries in Hell's Kitchen this is the place to go!
-
December 2023 by Paula J Pollard
I work in a building a few doors away from this market for about 9 years now, so I come here often. I like the prices of their produce. So I've witness the turn over of cashiers. This group they have now are just down right mean. They don't even say hello or thank you. They all just appear to be disgruntled employees. I used to like coming here but not so much anymore they are just mean, and so is the bald guy, I don't know if he's the floor manager or what, he stands there looking at folks like they are going to steel something black or white don't matter. the vibe there is just weird now. The tall handsome pizza guy is nice though. If it wasn't for the convenience of just going there and back to the office quickly, I'd probably stop going there. Mean just mean...
-
December 2023 by Bas L.
Solid neighborhood market but the prices have been creeping up so high. I was about to checkout on a Whole Foods delivery and then I thought I would do better to go here. So I had the WF prices and total in my head. Some of them items were literally double the price from WF. All of them were more expensive. I consider WF a fairly expensive market and to see how much more the Amish market was, disappointed me. Those are some steep margins the owners are enjoying.
-
December 2023 by Ornwara Tritrakarn
An organic grocery store with buffet line for lunch (13.99 USD/Lb). The items are, of course, on a high price. But they provide a good selection of items. So, if you are in need of a quick grocery stop for a few items in this area, this could be a good spot. I wouldn't use this place as my main grocery shopping spot though. As for the buffet line, the ingredients are fresh and mostly well-seasoned. I highly recommend their baked salmon and avocado salad but wouldn't recommend the sausages with mushroom, as the sausages are plain salty with no other redeemable taste. (Expected it to be more herbal based on its look.) The one pictured in this review is 14.62 USD/box - tax included.
-
December 2023 by Michael Costanzo
A true diamond amongst the bright lights. About 10 min from Rockefeller center. Everything in here is so good and they have it all from groceries to fresh cut steaks. We went with an ensemble of desserts to take home after dinner. They were all phenomenal but the Cannoli put me on the floor.
-
November 2023 by Nyan P.
Stopping in for a late lunch, I have been here for groceries which is a great variety, and fresh produce. I thought to myself today, why not skip a $30 poke bowl and check out the food bar. This location is a mix of a grocery store with an area downstairs for lunch-in. As I mentioned if you live in NYC and around grand central great for your grocery needs, lines are long at the bakery counters but butcher and registers move pretty quickly. That being said I came by for what I thought was a decent cheap meal. I grabbed myself a container to fill up with some hot/cold mix food bar which is 13.99 a lb., I believe. I was trying my best to do the healthy thing and skip the burgers and pizza next door to my job and thought a leisurely walk while not paying for delivery would make for a nice late lunch. A couple of the stew and chicken dishes were not visually appealing, some pieces seemed left too long on the warmer. I picked up the best looking Salmon piece I could find from the hot food and proceeded to grabbing a mix of some balsamic chicken, avocado/tomato salad, grilled vegetables and mushrooms. Yes I know i know point of a food bar or buffets in general, is go for the lightest and most expensive items but I thought it would be fine. I thought I was light on the veggies but the avocados must have done me in because 4 oz Salmon and sides came to $28. Salmon was well cooked, not overdone, moist but not dry in any parts. The vegetables were decent as well grilled right with a little bit of char on some lucky pieces. Balsamic chicken salad was not as tasty with many of the pieces being a bit dry probably due to sitting out too long, to me it shows that its not maintained to above proper standards. There must have been some issues with theft or something because there was a staff around the food tables and one at the door, cautious and understandable but for me not warm welcoming feeling to eat there and grabbed to go. Love mushrooms but all the veggies probably could have been seasoned but otherwise no complaints but nothing exciting. As I mentioned prior, a decent place for your groceries and have had pre-marinated skewers from the butcher before and never had any complaints, produce pretty fresh as well. Variety of gluten free and dairy free items around. Food bar on the other hand, probably not worth it for the price, better options in terms of food the vicinity that may be same or better quality. Would have loved to give another star but few noticeable things and leaving out any nostalgic experiences left this to be a fair rating.
-
November 2023 by Jiayi L.
Cute market that is actually bigger than it seems! There are two sides and they have a lot of items it and it feels like you can get anything you need. Quality seems good and they have a large variety of specialty items as well for different dietary restrictions that for some people are more difficult to find. I have not tried their ready made food, however, I do see people eating it so I assume it is not bad. Prices are a little on the high end, however it is NYC and quality matters so its not too bad. They have been here for a long time and I think that says something as well as it's hard to survive here unless you are good!
-
October 2023 by Pamela Grafilo
It has everything one can practically need. Food is delicious at reasonable prices.
-
October 2023 by monicaa
Best specialty grocery store in the area! Always has a large variety of snacks. They serve fresh hot lunch buffet that is equally affordable and delicious. Always come here to satisfy my sweets craving.
-
October 2023 by Marwan Majeed
Great place for good organic groceries and excellent food buffet for breakfast and lunch. A bit pricy though.
-
October 2023 by Olga Berestetskaya
Never knew city had an Amish Market, so it was a nice surprise. It seemed to have everything and good selection of interesting cheese.
-
August 2023 by Jim Paterson
I really appreciated this Deli. In a baking hot New York summer, the salad bar is just brilliant, providing a refreshing, filling, healthy and tasty lunch. Their salads offer a welcome respite to New York's excruciatingly high prices. They also have a pizza oven and self-service buffet arrangement too, amidst wall to wall adornments of fresh fruit and veg, cured meats and seafood, lots of cheeses, breads, delicacies, deserts, chocolates and more. In fact, the shop is crammed full of delicacies, with every available space used to ensure their offering of an extensive variety of stock. Amish market is a brand name, and this is actually a chain store deli.
