-
August 2023 by Nobutstill
Quiet comfortable place. The owner and the staff are friendly. They are very few reasons I will travel into the city these days, this is one reason.
-
July 2023 by 06jburt
‘Pro Sandwich’ is a thing of dreams
-
November 2022 by Adam Wright
This is the sort of spot that romantics look to for an old New York. It is no frills. But if you come here at 4pm on a sunny day you’ll see old Italians sitting at tables on the sidewalk having an espresso complaining about how they don’t recognize the neighborhood. I am sure the food meets expectations but I can only speak to the drinks. Order a Negroni or an Aperol spritz and imagine a world when New York had an soul.
-
September 2022 by Logan Hulsmeyer
Quality espresso, had a marinara pizza made to order (usually have low expectations when requesting a pizza without cheese) which was one of the better I’ve had in the city.They accidentally made two pies instead of two squares and wouldn’t let me pay for both pies even when I insisted, even put espresso on the house.High quality customer service to compliment the pizza/coffee, definitely recommend stopping by for a coffee and quick bite.
-
September 2022 by Robert Nelson
This place is like a hidden old school gem. Authentic Italian food & so much more. Most definitely recommend this place
-
August 2022 by meicha hall
Great Pasta. And friendly waiters! Great portions I 10/10 would come again! Soooo gooood I had the Spicy Shrimp & Clam Linguine Awesomeeeee
-
August 2022 by James Bruni
Great old fashioned Italian American food / once a social club and still has the feeling / always feel at home here
-
August 2022 by Amber G.
Insanely delicious, great atmosphere, stellar staff, and did I mention delicious pasta? Don't skip on this place!! They made the honorable mentions of my recent NYC food review. You can view it here: mise-en-scene.medium.com…
-
July 2022 by Forum Shah
We came here to grab a quick dinner before we went out with friends. This is a small local Italian restaurant where you can get pizza by the slice or pie, paninis and sandwiches, and also excellent pasta.I got the Penne Vodka and it was the right amount of spicy and came out fresh and hot. My husband tried the Spaghetti Agilo Olio as we've been trying to find a good place in the city that serves it correctly. It was definitely perfectly made. The food was very flavorful and we both enjoyed it.The bread was average, nothing that stuck out about it.We didn't get a chance to try the desserts but the dessert menu looked delicious and worth a try.The service was quick and friendly and the restaurant was clean.It's definitely not fancy but a great local spot and I would definitely go back.
-
July 2022 by elissa mcquaid
Worst pizza in the the United States. I've lived everywhere from NY, MA, MI, CA, CO. I can say I've never had pizza this bad. They do not serve round pie slices but Sicilian style. I love Sicilian style. Both of our slices were served cold. Very little sauce. Cheese was a solid slab of coldness (despite earrings on the restaurant). The cold canned mushrooms were atop the cold cheese. I don't think there was a pizza oven in here despite 50% of the menu being pizza. I think they buy premade/cooked pizza dough and add stuff then toss in a toaster oven. Avoid. Go to the by the slice place around the corner with the long line instead.Canoli was yummy.
-
June 2022 by Elissa M.
Worst pizza in the the United States. I've lived everywhere from NY, MA, MI, CA, CO. I can say I've never had pizza this bad. They do not serve round pie slices but Sicilian style. I love Sicilian style. Both of our slices were served cold. Very little sauce. Cheese was a solid slab of coldness (despite eating onsite). The cold canned mushrooms were atop the cold cheese. I don't think there was a pizza oven in here despite 50% of the menu being pizza. I think they buy premade/cooked pizza dough and add stuff then toss in a toaster oven. IDK. Either that or they need to train the guy that serves us to warm pizza better. Go to the by the slice place around the corner with the long line instead. Canoli was yummy. Service was polite.
-
June 2022 by Jeff Dyke
Delightful little place! Was recommended by Tommy's Of New York that we just toured with. I had the slice of prosciutto pizza and it was one of the best slices I've ever eaten! We sat outside in beautiful weather, listening to Frank Sinatra as we watched the city go by.
-
May 2022 by Piril O.
First slice of pizza I did not finish in my entire life of 28 years. Just that bad. Bread with the thinnest spread of bland sauce and cheese...like,another (and better) way of saving on ingredients is to not cook something at all? I feel bad for the natural resources and labor that went into creating this absolute flop
-
May 2022 by Jim Sears
Non-members can dine here, but it has a feel of regulars coming to get together. Square slices with extra toppings available. Also known as Grandma's pizza.
-
March 2022 by Rodney Galella
I wanted to rate this place while there since it would only take three words.OLD SCHOOL LEGITSo, all of you Z, X, Ennials, whatever, you call yourselves, the ones crawling all over that neighborhood now, trying to get into these Fake, Trendy, Wannabe places, take some advice. Check this place out. I'm not sure the owner even wants your business; that's how legit it is.. It's small, quiet, and perfect, so keep your voices down, put your stupid phones away, be polite, and just soak it in because it definitely won't be there forever and when it's gone, something valuable will be lost.
