-
March 2024 by Tee Yoo
Best pizza in New York. Wish they came to
-
March 2024 by Wendell Strong
You can’t beat this place. Got be the best slice I’ve ever
-
February 2024 by Jenny Li
Cashier woman is rude and pizza was
-
February 2024 by George Ellsworth Turnbull
OK, OK, OK.Somebody has to speak up about Don Pepi's OTHER offerings. White there trying to decipher the pizza choices 8 or 9 years ago, I overheard some one order a ham and cheese ... no, make that 'brie,' sandwich on pump with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. I stepped back to watch the production. Production it was, like a ballet. About 2 minutes later it appeared on the counter...MONSTAH! Heck with pizza, I'll have one of those! Paired with a cold beer it's the perfect train companion for the trip back up to Bastoon. We have made it our go-to ever since...not one regret. Going North or South...we always make time to hit Pepi's...SO New York. SO glad. Someday we'll break down and try the pizza.
-
February 2024 by Elle
Yay! I finally tried the New York pizza, and it was delicious. They served it fresh, crusty, and the price was just fair. It's obviously busy since it's right in the station, but it's worth the wait
-
February 2024 by ells w.
OK, OK, OK. Somebody has to speak up about Don Pepi's OTHER offerings. While there trying to decipher the pizza choices 8 or 9 years ago, I overheard some one order a ham and cheese ... no, make that 'brie,' sandwich on pump with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. I stepped back to watch the production. Production it was, like a ballet. About 2 minutes later it appeared on the counter...MONSTAH! Heck with pizza, I'll have one of those! Paired with a cold beer it's the perfect train companion for the trip back up to Bastoon. We have made it our go-to ever since...not one regret. Going North or South...we always make time to hit Pepi's...SO New York. SO glad. Someday we'll break down and try the pizza.
-
February 2024 by Eric Edmonds
Great old school NY Pizza slice. Reminds me an old school pizzeria slice
-
January 2024 by Tina Beiland
Best place to grab a freshly made sandwich before catching your train! I’ve had this place a number of times now and it never disappoints I recommend trying this place out if you are traveling to New York or leaving New
-
December 2023 by markricharddavies
We are done with this place. The brown haired cashier woman yelling “next” short changed me, and when I asked her for the correct change she proceeded to give it to me all in pennies in spite.Our company orders pizza from them as we are near by.. we will be canceling ordering pizza from them.Rip off , stay away.
-
December 2023 by Taylor Wisler
Great NY Pizza place, they move you through quickly with fresh pizza.
-
December 2023 by Kinard Edwards
This girl was rude and disrespectful I had long stressful day my head was everywhere it was busy day at work I ate the pizza I Went to go leave and they reminded me I needed to pay which is no problem when I to pay a apologize for mistake before I could talk this woman was laughing and talking disrespectful also was the manager it’s giving racist the way the sat here and was laughing and being disrespectful and making comments in Spanish and didn’t even know I was Spanish
-
December 2023 by James Bond
Great best ?
-
December 2023 by Jenny L.
Pizza was cold and the woman working the cashier was rude and kept rolling her eyes when she took my order.
-
December 2023 by Alexis M.
Their pizza is so good. It's located right in Penn Station. Whenever I hit the city, I am sure to stop here on my way home even if I'm not hungry. I'll eat it the next day and throw it in the air fryer. No place to sit but the pizza is phenomenal.
-
November 2023 by Eugene Goldman
Decent. Crispy crust but sauce and cheese has little flavor. Quick service.