-
March 2024 by Sarah R.
Awesome store with fantastic visual merchandising. Such fun to just browse. Love this place
-
March 2024 by Andrea L.
The people who work here are the rudest people, if a business promotes its business hours as 10-8pm and they don't announce ANYWHERE on their website, social media channels or phone VM that they're closing early...nor answer their phones when customers are calling to confirm the hours before commuting in the rain, then the business has an obligation to provide it services before they are "closed". What did this business do instead? Let more then 10 customers stand outside in the rain, rolled their eyes at us, called us liars because "they didn't get a call" and threatened to call the cops. All fluff bc if they couldn't even stay until 8pm (the time of their business hours) to do their work, what makes me think they would've stayed past 8pm to wait for the cops. It was only an intimidation tactic. All I and 10 other people wanted to do as we stood out on the rain was to support this business and shop on a SATURDAY NIGHT BEFORE IT CLOSED AT 8PM. Instead, we were encountered by outright laziness, and most awful service. I would never try going here again, false advertisers and horrible people that work here who dehumanize customers.
-
February 2024 by suepprsue P.
Great place to poke around and find some great deals on things you didn't know you needed
-
January 2024 by Rachel P.
It's a cute shop with lots of variety of vintage and new kitchen pieces - mostly dishes and silverware with some other items like vases, candlesticks, trinkets. It's moderately priced, and a fun place to pop in for a unique souvenir.
-
January 2024 by Fawn G.
Wow.. over 6 years ago I wrote a review how disappointed I was with Fish's Eddy. The disappointment has grown even worse. I guess the rent on 19th and Broadway has skyrocketed because the prices in this store are outrageous and not worthy of anyone's dollar. First off, their offerings are so boring, so lackluster I just don't know who is buying from here? Those hand figurines, c'mon you've carried these for thirty years! Who is buying this? The same Brooklyn Bridge dishes, towels, bags.. only thing different is the price tag. A small white cup is $5. The Ball jars that used to cost $3 are now $10, a shot glass is $6.95?? The " pigeon" prints for Brooklyn areas??? What is this??! Second, your store has no life, no vibe. You used to be kitschy and offer cool stuff. You call mint tins shaped like guitars worthy of $10? Lastly, you have no service in your store. Your employees seem " busy" doing what? Pricing items at the cash wrap? No greeters no nothing. Crate and Barrel, offers better quality merchandise and they are across the street from you. I hate to predict it, but, they are probably going to run you out of business. They can cater to nearby restaurants better than you if restauranteurs are buying caseloads of "mismatched" plates or the section marked " we know these plates are not pretty"!!!???? Hate to say it but something fishy is happening here and it's not pretty. So sad...
-
January 2024 by Gaia S.
Really cute shop with lots of fun items. very quirky. Lots of good finds for unique houseware.
-
November 2023 by Virginia G.
If you like cute, unusual dinner ware; you will love Fishs Eddy. Huge selection of colorful dishes, glassware & dish towels,at reasonable prices. I almost always find something fun either for a gift or myself.
-
November 2023 by Jill S.
I've been living in this area for decades moved away and now I'm back and I'm shocked at how pricey this place has become. Also, they have the audacity to charge you $.25 for a small paper bag.
-
October 2023 by O H (Olly)
Love this store, great mix of genuine vintage crockery and other kitchen paraphernalia with new items that blend in well.Lovely place to visit.
-
August 2023 by Kim R.
I've been a customer of Fishs Eddy for 20+ years. It's my "pick me up" store - meaning every time I enter, it always makes me smile. I don't think I've ever left empty handed. Whether on the hunt for something specific or stumbling upon something that screams "must have," Fishs Eddy never disappoints! My first cake stand came from this special place, and it is still beloved. I was lucky enough to chat with the owner, Julie yesterday, and so glad we did. She is the real deal, and absolutely lovely! Fishs Eddy is the type of store we so desperately NEED to keep in NYC - a unique, family run store filled from floor to ceiling with gorgeous, well curated, and quirky items perfect for your home or to gift. Any home will benefit from the treasures you will find here, guaranteed!
-
August 2023 by David Bellamy
If you need dishes this is the place with many choices, colors, and styles! And the best part is Fish's Eddy purchases dishes that are sitting in the warehouse and unused from restaurants and sells them to people like us!It's such a fun place with so many types of dishes, cups, and bowls! You'll love it all! They also enjoy the fun artwork around the shop too.The staff are helpful and the shop is very fun to browse and shop!
-
August 2023 by Jeff
Great place to go to for Seconds of Dishes and other table settings. The dishes are all made for commercial use but haven't passed quality control because of various blemishes; color variations, scratches, design irregularities and other flaws. Examine each piece so it meets your standard. The pieces are strong and heavy made to withstand the stresses of high frequency restaurant use. If you are in the Union Square locale definitely drop in for a looksee. Fishs Eddy is a unique and interesting store.
-
July 2023 by jac c.
I grew up just down the block from Fishs Eddy. I can not pass the shop without popping in to see what's new. Over the years I have found stuff to gift absolutely every person I know. My mom hated her middle name, until I found a platter from a restaurant bearing that name, in big glorious script. That platter hung over mom's kitchen door for more than 20 years. Housewarming gifts that are really one of a kind. Yummy girlie antique inspired teapots. Manley coffee mugs and drink ware. Goofy graphic mugs that will make you giggle every morning (Good Morning Asshole mug)!! Of course NYC souvenir items not available anywhere else. Go. Shop. Bring friends. Point tourists there.
-
May 2023 by mindlessbuddha
Not impressed. I guess if you want small-town, heavy, sturdy, basic farmhouse dinner dishes, this is ok. But the selection of styles, patterns, and sizes is limited. Prices are insane! I'm a diehard thrifter, and you can find this stuff everywhere for literally a fraction of this cost. At these prices, you can find some more funky, artsy, unique dinerware that won't make you look so basic and boring.
-
April 2023 by P H
The coolest shop in NYC, period.Owner Julie and awesome artist son Ben are brilliant, kind, funny people who help make NYC so wonderfully unique. (No wonder Amy Sedaris is their friend!)It’s magical just passing by but a revelation walking in.. the atmosphere is unlike anything else in the city, warm and welcoming, fun vibe, cool music, with the historic space itself being half the experience (old school high ceilings and fixtures, with worn, wise old wood floors). The stock is a wide variety of affordable, amusing, vintage and new, witty, well made and practical goods.. (ideal for gift giving)Owners are subtle but not shy about standing up for what’s right too. If you know, you know.Btw, check out their book how Julie and hubby David started the shop decades ago. A true a labor of love, and perfect old school NYC business success story.Be prepared to spend at least 15 mins looking around, there’s *so* much to look at.. take advantage of the bench in back for parking a tired friend/partner!