-
March 2024 by J C
No host or hostess was available when we visited and the bartender didnt even bother to help us after seeing us just standing.
-
March 2024 by Ian Kornberg
It was a busy night I asked the wait and the hostess doesn’t even tell me how long just says we’re busy. She does not take my name down. I’m forced to participate in this trash beer, and they don’t even have Budweiser. I was sitting waiting for the waitress to take my order for OVER AN HOUR. Unacceptable. This place sucks save your
-
March 2024 by Jason S.
Great selection of small plate offerings. Delicious steak sandwich. Friendly and attentive staff. Not too loud, so easy to have a conversation
-
March 2024 by Allison G.
Went for drinks with friends and the cocktails were dangerously smooth! The bartender was very friendly and let us take some tables so we could spread out from the bar. The moody ambiance with low music created a great vibe to catch up with everyone.
-
March 2024 by Seth B.
Good food (and good veggie/vegan options but had some weird blob in my tea. I think they needed to clean the tea machine. They replaced it though with a fresh one.
-
March 2024 by Maya N.
The top heavy Australian hotesses with glasses was extremely rude the moment my friend and I walked in. I asked "are you guys open?" and she looked around and sarcastically replied "uhh yea..". It was during the time the restaurant's turnover for 5pm so we just wanted to be sure. She kept stressing there's reservations coming in later in the evening but it was only around 4:30pm so didn't understand what that had to do with us. The place was practically empty so not sure why she needed to go tit for tat. My friend's boyfriend came in as we were paying the bill & sat at the table near us waiting for us to finish. The same obnoxious Aussie hotesses BADGERED HIM TWICE about how he needed to get up because a party was coming. She knew we weren't staying! We were simply waiting for our cards back and it was freezing outside. Just patronizing for no reason, we all left feeling uncomfortable. I had to ask for my drink twice but that's understanding since they were short staffed. The food is just okay, nothing I'd rush back for.
-
March 2024 by Alison C.
Haymaker Bar and Kitchen had been on my list to visit for quite some time and was the perfect spot to meet a colleague for happy hour one afternoon. I was able to grab the last 2 bar stools at 3:30 pm on a Thursday. It was not exactly crowded, but the bar seats were all otherwise occupied by men, leaving us as the 2 lone women in the place! Anyway, we grabbed some menus, and I was very impressed by their cocktail, wine, and beer lists, which were vast and diverse. I decided to go for the Spicy Pineapple Margarita, which was a very potent blend of Pueblo Viejo Tequila, fresh pineapple, Fresno pepper, and lime. It was served in a rocks glass with a singular, large ice cube, and, boy, was it strong! Haymaker was perfect for our needs, but I would definitely go back there for a casual meal, group drinks, or pretty much most occasions.
-
March 2024 by Beth Ranney
No burgers, but the other food and drink offerings were fine. Great servers, comfy.
-
March 2024 by Jacquelyn A
Servers we nice but once it got busy it took some time to get their attention. The hummus and chicken wings were great. The ribs were tender and seasoned but not exceptional. The chicken tacos were bland. Maybe that was a bad day for the tacos. Overall, I'd visit again and try different foods on the menu.
-
March 2024 by Diana C.
Came here after an improv show with about 20-25 people, NO reservation, and they quickly and gladly seated us. The service was quick and friendly and I enjoyed my Haymaker burger! Any place in NYC where you can roll in 20+ deep is automatically 5 stars in my book!
-
March 2024 by Lisa Gillard
I have been here twice. It's a nice intimate bar when you can enjoy a
-
February 2024 by Richard Gilfert
A friend and I stopped by last Friday evening. We were looking for a bite. WOW! The fries were fantastic! We were sharing an order, we placed another order. The Prosciutto Flatbread was delicious. We had cold beers, but the drink menu looks superb. The best part of the evening was the service. They seated us quickly, and our server made the evening! Courteous, friendly, knowledgeable and fun!! A terrific spot in Mid Town!! Check it out!!!
-
February 2024 by Vaughan Machado
My buddies and I stopped here before a show at MSG and were totally blown away. Fantastic beer selection, great music, and killer food. The burgers were incredible, and the wings (we had the maple mustard) were insane. I forgot our bartenders name, but he was awesome as well - we're definitely coming back soon.
-
February 2024 by Andre Floyd
Nice quiet place to go after a show at MSG. Kitchen closed at that time, though.
-
February 2024 by Phillip T.
Incredible flat bread pizzas. Must try. Also they have really great cocktails. And wonderful ambiance
