Toy Stores near Newburgh, NY

8 locations found near Newburgh

“I love the store itself! It loses one star for the absolutely DISGUSTING bathrooms. I was there today (3/11/26) and one toilet was absolutely STUFFED with only God knows what, and there was excrement on the seat in the second stall. The third stall had what looked like dried blood on the floor and scraps of dirty looking toilet paper all on the floor. I was there yesterday and everything that was on the floor then was still on the floor today. Dried blood and all. Which means nobody cleaned the bathroom in the last 2 days. Absolutely DISGUSTING!”

4.3 Superb196 Reviews

“I live a little over an hour away so I have not visited in person yet but I have ordered online a few times. Everything comes packaged so cute! I love looking here for unique gifts! Thank you so much. I can’t wait to come in person one day!”

4.9 Superb93 Reviews

“One of the best store for kids and adults with vintage, smart and fun items for kids and adult. We can stay for hours in this place.... It s pretty it s colorful, and it s carrying fun cards for special events.”

4.7 Superb64 Reviews

“It’s been a while, but the Epic Spider ? is still here. The most ThreeZero stuff I’ve ever seen in a store. Acid Rain, Hiya, Joy Toy & even some Hot Toys Clones- not the usual stuff.”

4.8 Superb23 Reviews

“We were visiting from New York, and today I had the pleasure of stopping by this charming little gift shop. We were greeted by the sweetest gentleman, and right away, we were drawn to the beautifully crafted soaps. He kindly told us all about the different types they carry.
The shop also features unique wooden LEGO-style sets made in Eastern Europe , as well as many locally made products from the USA. There’s a wonderful selection of toys for children! Unusual, creative, and clearly made with love.
It’s obvious that the people working here truly care about what they do. This gentleman took his time to show us everything and share stories about the items. We left with such a positive impression and will 100% be coming back. It’s always a joy to see businesses like this thrive!”

4.6 Superb33 Reviews

“From Alexa welcoming us in at the door, to Arlo helping us with stuffing our new Capybara, the experience was amazing! They made a very comfortable, welcoming environment for us and their customer service was exceptional! Looking forward to going back there soon.”

4.5 Superb62 Reviews

“I love the store and would give it 5 stars but it's not always the greatest they do have some flaws and some not so nice staff but hey that's retail, if you wanna have an amazing experience go on Sunday or request Adriana she's amazing. She'll make you feel welcome from the moment you walk in and she goes above and beyond. She has personally walked around to help me find specific items and she's just such a happy bubbly girl. I also watched her go above and beyond to make exceptions for a customer selling she just seems to want to make us all have the best experience possible. I wish everyone had her positive energy.”

3.1 Average102 Reviews

Related Categories