The Fainting Goat Island Inn is a charming and beautiful place, known for its warm hospitality and stunning decor. The owners, Marnie and her partner Bill, are very welcoming and friendly, making guests feel at home from the moment they arrive. Marnie is especially noted for her kindness, sharing stories about the inn's history and serving delicious homemade cinnamon rolls in the morning. The inn features gorgeously restored furnishings and a cozy, historic atmosphere, with picturesque surroundings that include a beautiful river, an island view, and friendly animals like goats, pigs, dogs, and Larry the cat. Guests often enjoy the peaceful setting and interesting stories about the inn’s history, which adds to its charm. Many visitors report having some odd or spooky experiences, such as noises, bumps in the night, or chilling moments, but nothing too frightening—just enough to make the stay fun and intriguing. Some guests have had spine-tingling encounters, like hearing mysterious sounds or feeling an eerie presence, which adds to the haunted reputation of the inn. Others simply appreciate the quiet, cozy rooms and the welcoming atmosphere. Overall, the inn provides a memorable experience, blending comfort, beauty, and a touch of the paranormal. Visitors leave with stories to tell, eager to return for another stay. It’s a perfect spot for those seeking a peaceful retreat with a little spooky fun and warm hospitality.
My second visit. I love this place! Gorgeously appointed rooms in a historic theme with goats of course! Marnie is a wonderful hostess. This visit was uneventful; the spirits couldn't be bothered with me.
January 2025
Such a beautiful place with very welcoming and knowledgeable hosts of the property. Absolutely loved it and me and my wife will definitely come here again. Such an amazing history behind the inn and we loved hearing the stories about the place. Didn't see any paranormal activity during our stay hopefully on our next visit
January 2025
Can't say enough about our amazing time here. The hosts are wonderful and the house is beautiful. We had some very interesting activity our first night there and definitely plan a return trip.
