Jewelry Stores in Oyster Bay, NY

“I was referred to Jared by a friend in my search for a custom engagemet ring, and reaching out was probably the best decision I made in my search. Jared was extremely approachable and responsive, and was really helpful throughout the process in adressing questions, asking questions, and providing examples / videos to help us get exactly what we're looking for. Payment and shipping was a breeze. I will definately reach back out to Jared for my future jewelery needs, and would recommend him to anyone in their search. We could not be happier and more satisfied!”

“Great jewelry store ! Sold gold & silver here . Was in-and-out within 30 mins with cash in my hand. Got more than expected for my pieces. They were very honest with market trends & price

Also brought a couple watches that needed bracelet resizing . Diane & Gerard had completed the job within 30 mins. Compared to my old jeweler who needed almost a week to remove a few links…

This is how you run a business !! Great family owned store with fair prices. We’ll be return customers and recommending friends/family here as well.

Thanks for everything,
-Bryan B. (precious metal seller / customer)”

“I have known Paola for years now and have many of her pieces. I was initially drawn to her jewelry because of how unique and stunning they all are. Even when she makes two of the name pieces they are both different from one another. I noticed Paola made a beautiful bracelet with a pearl. The chain was exquisite with its chunky rectangles that countered the dainty pear. I asked if she could make such bracelet into a necklace and she immediately got to work. That is the type of dedicated small business owner she is. She is always using her art to make her clients happy. I can't wait to wear this necklace for years to come.”

“I stumbled across this store and I’m so happy I did. If you’re looking for a fantastic clock store, look no further! This shop is an absolute gem. Not only does it offer an incredible selection of clocks, but the jewelry sold here is also stunning—each piece is unique and beautifully crafted. The owner is exceptionally sweet, knowledgeable, and welcoming, making every visit a pleasant experience. His passion for his work truly shines through, and he takes the time to answer questions and help customers find exactly what they’re looking for. I highly encourage everyone to stop by this amazing store—you won’t be disappointed!”

“Beautiful shop in Oyster Bay - you can find presents for everyone here (especially yourself!) Be sure to say hello to Eileen - she's lovely and can steer you to many beautiful treasured”

“My family and I have used Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay for at least ten years. Recently, with the price of silver having increased tremendously, I decided to sell all my sterling silver pieces which included dinnerware, jewelry, and a large coin collection. Ira and Chelsea gave us their full attention and we found them knowledgeable, thorough, and careful in their attempt to accurately assess the value of everything we brought to them and to give us a fair price. We were thrilled with the service we received and the integrity that they showed while patiently answering any/all of our questions. We have returned there three times with our own possessions and have returned with other family members and friends who wished to sell their own silver. We cannot recommend Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay highly enough. We left each time feeling assured that we had been treated well.”