Hotels near Pine Island, NY

“Exceptional service, so charming!

If I could give this place a hundred stars, I would.

First off, Bob was an absolutely INCREDIBLE and accommodating host. Super kind and knowledgeable about the area. Made the most incredible breakfast (delectable home-made scones, muffins, a ham and cheese pastry, scrambled eggs, poached pears… ? and even home-made brownies)

Location is great! Close enough to local fall attractions like apple picking farms, sugarloaf, and even the Appalachian trail!

We drove past the house a couple of times because it didn’t look like a B&B from the outside. Nevertheless, The house is so charming and well-kept on the inside. Everything was fresh and so much attention to detail in the rooms. We were so grateful and will be back!”

“My first thing about motels is I’m usually concerned about the cleanliness. I must say for this price this is by far the best and well kept motel in the $80 price range. Was perfect for my needs, used this as a stop on my mini motorcycle road trip.

Even managed to sneak my bike into my room and the lady in charge seemed to be chill.”

“There are so many great things to say about the Inn and its owners Bill and Joe... 5 stars is actually insufficient. You'll just have to stay there yourself, and you'll know what I mean... ??”

“Very enjoyable stay at this quaint B&B! Anil is the friendliest, most helpful host you could ask for. Our room was comfortable and we really enjoyed the gas fireplace. The breakfasts were outstanding! Lots to do and see in the area - we plan on returning! Thank you Anil for welcoming us to the Alpine Haus!”

“Stayed at Glenmere for a wedding weekend and felt like I was at an Italian villa. Absolutely beautiful property, gorgeous rooms, and excellent service. True 5-star stay and accommodations.”

“Lots of history at this amazing location. Lake side outdoor dining, with beautiful views... great food. Have a relaxing lunch some weekend, and enjoy. Make sure to go inside and appreciate all the history.”

“Nice basic room----Fair price and good value----Quiet room----All amenities worked well. Plenty of room-----Well situated near breakfast, lunch, and dinner facilities. Mountain Creek nearby. Friendly, helpful manager. Served my needs very well. Highly recommended ------ will utilize this motel anytime I am in this area and need a comfortable place to stay.

Rooms: Nice basic room----Fair price and good value----Quiet room----All amenities worked well. Plenty of room-----Well situated near breakfast, lunch, and dinner facilities. Mountain Creek nearby. Friendly, helpful manager. Served my needs very well. Highly recommended ------ will utilize this motel anytime I am in this area and need a comfortable place to stay.

Nearby activities: Nice basic room----Fair price and good value----Quiet room----All amenities worked well. Plenty of room-----Well situated near breakfast, lunch, and dinner facilities. Mountain Creek nearby. Friendly, helpful manager. Served my needs very well. Highly recommended ------ will utilize this motel anytime I am in this area and need a comfortable place to stay.

Safety: Nice basic room----Fair price and good value----Quiet room----All amenities worked well. Plenty of room-----Well situated near breakfast, lunch, and dinner facilities. Mountain Creek nearby. Friendly, helpful manager. Served my needs very well. Highly recommended ------ will utilize this motel anytime I am in this area and need a comfortable place to stay.

Food and drinks: Nice basic room----Fair price and good value----Quiet room----All amenities worked well. Plenty of room-----Well situated near breakfast, lunch, and dinner facilities. Mountain Creek nearby. Friendly, helpful manager. Served my needs very well. Highly recommended ------ will utilize this motel anytime I am in this area and need a comfortable place to stay.

Noteworthy details: Nice basic room----Fair price and good value----Quiet room----All amenities worked well. Plenty of room-----Well situated near breakfast, lunch, and dinner facilities. Mountain Creek nearby. Friendly, helpful manager. Served my needs very well. Highly recommended ------ will utilize this motel anytime I am in this area and need a comfortable place to stay.”

“I have been staying here for years both booking direct and air bnb. Mostly airbnb. I only minus a star because we miss the arcade. This is the best bang for your buck in a 1 1/2 hr drive from Central ”

“Have stayed here several times as it is near to an event we go to twice a year. Rooms are clean. Beds are comfortable. Staff has always been friendly. Continental breakfast is minimal but at least it's something. Parking lot lights are bright, if your room is in the front of building. But that is also good for security. Variety of food options within a few minute drive.”