Tire Dealers near Port Jefferson, NY

30 locations found near Port Jefferson

“Great staff, friendly, very HONEST. They for sure care about your car issue and are focus on ensuring the job is done right the first time. I’m glad to have found them, went once hesitating going to a mechanic, but I bring my cars there since. They showed me that they can be trusted.”

4.9 Superb67 Reviews

“Everyone here was fantastic, knowledgeable and extremely helpful! It can feel intimidating at times being a woman and walking into a repair shop but that was certainly not the case when coming here. Everyone was very polite and honest, I was very much at ease knowing my car was in safe hands. Highly recommend to anyone looking for such excellent service!”

4.9 Superb269 Reviews

“Brought my car in because another mechanic misdiagnosed a problem. This shop found the problem and fixed it. They had the car about a day and a half. They were nice to me every time I called to see the progress.”

4.9 Superb194 Reviews

“STS doesn’t upsell you on tires you don’t need yet. They’ll tell you straight: rotate, repair, or replace. Your wallet wins, your tires last longer, and you actually trust the recommendation because they have zero incentive to push expensive solutions. Fast turnaround, upfront pricing, and the kind of honest assessment that keeps you coming back. This is what a tire shop should be.”

4.9 Superb164 Reviews

“Convenient service spot. Has waiting area but not climate controlled. Depending on who is there service can vary but overall they get the job done and staff is attentive.”

4.9 Superb202 Reviews

“These guys are amazing, I’ve brought my 2023 Subaru brz to install new custom wheels and tires and they did a phenomenal job. I also came in today for a flat and they fixed it in 10 minutes! Highly recommend these guys they will never let you down”

4.9 Superb166 Reviews

“I had the pleasure of meeting two very nice gentlemen who helped me with my flat tire. Dan, the manager, got me in pretty quickly, and Ullysses, the tech, was incredibly helpful in putting my tire on and even replacing a missing lug nut. I truly appreciate them helping me out today!”

4.8 Superb257 Reviews

“Amazing Service and super friendly Crew Joe Christan and Matt were super knowledgeable and friendly I needed and OEM Filter for My WRX and they had it ordered for me and did a great oil change and inspection 10/10”

4.8 Superb145 Reviews

“I just wanted to give a big thank you to Anthony and James for getting my tire for my Tahoe sorted out, these guys are great here they were very helpful and professional! I would recommend this shop to anyone! Thanks again on a job well done!”

4.9 Superb68 Reviews

“This location was able to get me in right away for a car inspection. Keith and Anthony were extremely kind and it was super quick. I highly recommend this specific location!!!”

4.7 Superb304 Reviews

“I’ve been going to Mavis tire in Smithtown on West Main Street for years. Bruno and Larry are very nice, reliable and trustworthy. Not to mention they always get me in no matter how busy they are.
I highly recommend this location.”

4.7 Superb235 Reviews

“Came here last minute for a nail to get patched only place open near me late. The owner was respectful and helped tremendously! God bless and i will be back. A forever customer now!”

4.9 Superb57 Reviews

“Smithwest Service Center took me in without scheduling to repair my leaking tire. Work was completed fairly quick with minimal wait time in their comfortable waiting area. I left satisfied but not sure if my AAA discount was applied to the bill. Regardless the price was fair, perhaps more reasonable than other automotive shops in the area. I recommend Smithwest Service Center”

4.7 Superb167 Reviews

“Have had nothing but positive experiences wth Rob & Ashley. I have three vehicals that are serviced on a frequent basis. All work is verified prior to being done, and within the given time frame. A plesure to work with.”

5 Superb42 Reviews

“Good people you can trust. Nice Local place, we take ALL our family cars here. We even have then check out any used cars BEFORE we buy them! Get it fixed right the 1st time. Won't go anywhere else.”

4.8 Superb85 Reviews

“Brian and Dan treated me so well when I was there, Brian was able to effectively assist me with explaining what was wrong with my brake system on my car and resolving the problem, thank you guys and I will be back for future repairs”

4.7 Superb175 Reviews

“Taurus Auto Center has been my go-to for years, and they’re consistently excellent: honest, skilled, and fast. They explain what needs to be done (and what doesn’t), charge fair prices, and stand behind their work. I trust them completely, and so does my father. Highest recommendation. Five stars.”

5 Superb65 Reviews

“The gentleman at the front desk was exactly that. A gentleman. My car failed inspection down the block and I was being charged over $600 for two tires. I called this location, which was down the block from the initial shop I took my car to. He scheduled me with no problem and I was in and out in less than an hour. I was able to bring my car back to the original shop and pass inspection. He definitely does right by his customers and I really appreciated his level of communication throughout the entire process.”

4.6 Superb289 Reviews

“Carms,Jimmy is by far the best mechanic I know I've been working on my own cars since 16 years old had back surgery can't do a lot anymore thank God for Jimmy I don't let anyone work on my car but Jimmy I trust him 100% and his wife Jamie is absolutely awesome nice we love these people Jimmy can fix n work on anything I'm into muscle cars and Jimmy can do anything he just serviced my procharger did a great job car runs much better plus he tuned my car I couldn't be any happier with Jimmy's work”

4.9 Superb75 Reviews

“Every time I go here they always are so kind and helpful especially Mike and Dave. Memorial Day weekend was extremely busy but they rose above the chaos and got the job done no matter what. Thank you guys for a great experience”

4.6 Superb271 Reviews

“The Pep Boys Team goes above and beyond! They are super transparent about the diagnosis of the vehicle. Super professional and trustworthy! I keep coming back…”

4.6 Superb248 Reviews

“Sometimes you meet people and you can tell that they’re just genuine people trying to do some genuine good in the world. Mark is that guy, and the way he does business reflects that.

Mark, pleasure talking with you. Thanks to you and your team for fixing up my truck, thanks for also giving me a break when and where you could. I’ll be a customer as long as I’m on Long Island.

If you’re not sure, just go to Pinky’s, seriously. Car repairs are never fun, but they’re made a thousand times better when you’re working with an honest mechanic who’s got the customer’s best interest in mind.”

4.7 Superb121 Reviews

“i got an oil change and an inspection and the service was incredible! i was in and out in about an hour and while i was waiting i had the pleasure of seeing the puppy who is adorable. i will be coming back and recommend them to anyone who is having car troubles!:)”

4.7 Superb170 Reviews

“Smithtown/St James site is a great place to have service done i called and was able to get my car in for service within the next business day. Tom told me how long it would likely take and it was completed around that time”

4.6 Superb276 Reviews

“I needed a NYS safety check for my Tesla. Paul and his team made it happen w/o an appointment, in 10 mins, and for $10. This is unheard of (after previous experiences with official dealerships and small local shops) and I will certainly coming back. Great job, guys!”

4.7 Superb129 Reviews

“Recommend by a close friend for major repairs to the front end of my beloved Chevy Spark. My wife and I live in the City but we were able to make all the arrangements over the phone. They were awesome with communication leading up to and during the repair which took less than 24 hrs to get finished. I will be using this shop moving forward for all my future needs.”

4.6 Superb162 Reviews

“I had my brakes and brake pedal replaced for my Honda 2.0T at Durango Tires & Auto Repair, and they did an excellent job! The service was quick, professional, and the prices were very affordable compared to other shops. The team was friendly and made sure everything was done right. Highly recommend them for anyone looking for quality auto repair at a fair price!”

4.6 Superb131 Reviews

“As always Village Automotive was friendly, thorough and quick! I waited for my car and was on my way in a half hour.
Thank you to all the staff at Village Automotive! Anne byrnes”

4.7 Superb89 Reviews

“Great place to get bait for fishing trips. They have frozen spearing, and clams. They also have live eels. They also offer tackle and rigs. And eternal free fuel for the boat.”

4.7 Superb59 Reviews

“I found ER Automotive by chance when I needed a mechanic in the Medford area. From the first phone call, Ed was very helpful and knowledgeable. When I bought the car in, Ed and Mike were very thorough and explained items in detail. If I am in that area again and need mechanic work, I will definitely go back to them!”

4.8 Superb62 Reviews

Related Categories