Toy Stores in Sag Harbor, NY

4 locations found near Sag Harbor

“Every year without fail this is my first spot to stop! The chocolates are to die for, and the unique gifts are just fabulous! Everything you could possibly need from toys to accessories to gorgeous clothes, whether it's Christmas or 4th of July! The staff, and the owners are the nicest people I've ever met. They treat you like family!”

4.9 Superb21 Reviews

“This place is great. It’s been a while since I’ve been but have fond memories of. Growing up my family and I spent our summers in Noyac and visited the Wharf Shop quite often. Great customer service and beautiful products. In fact I still have a seagull bracelet that my Mom bought for me over 50 years ago! If you’re in Sag Harbor definitely make sure to stop in. You won’t be disappointed.”

4.4 Superb29 Reviews

“I always love shopping here when I'm visiting family in Springs. They have a LOT packed into a smallish store and its really fun to check out all the aisles for household needs and fun treasures.
My m.i.l. bought some fabric and the woman working in the fabric area was delightful and helpful.”

4.3 Superb43 Reviews

“A trip to sag harbor isn't complete without shopping at the kite store. Fun for kids and adults! Fidgets, toys,gags, trends, candy, and of course kites! Each time I visit they have something new. Never gets boring. But the real stars are the staff. Everyone is warm, welcoming, and helpful. A true gem.”

4 Good30 Reviews