Hardware Stores near Selden, NY

26 locations found near Selden

“Saturday we had a late night kitchen drain emergency! Andrew was so kind to help me with 15 minutes to closing. He helped me find the right parts and let the front know too so I would be able to check out.

Thanks Andrew, we can now make breakfast on Mother's day!”

3.6 Good189 Reviews

“Great hardware store when you don't wanna deal with the bigger chain places. This is also my Goto for propane refilling because they actually fill your tank to its capacity not like others. Always a friendly crew working and never a wait.”

4.8 Superb92 Reviews

“Could not be happier with the customer service here. RJ always goes above and beyond for customers. From in person sales to over the phone he is always friendly, accommodating and helpful. I choose to go here over any other store when it comes to tool purchases. Make this your go to store!”

4.8 Superb90 Reviews

“The Sayville Brinkmann store is the absolute best! They are so helpful, the store is clean and beautiful. They carry everything you need! I brought in a lamp today that I was having an issue with. Gabe offered to take a look, and within 15 minutes I had my lamp fixed and even better than it was before. A few weeks back i needed glass replaced on a painting, and they replaced that for a reasonable price as well. Thank you Gabe and Sayville Brinkmann for being the best hardware store around!”

4.8 Superb107 Reviews

“I was shopping for a specific BBQ and found they had it for less than everyone else so I went there to buy it. I was skeptical of a catch but the girl behind the counter confirmed the price. She was excellent as well as the manager. They arranged for delivery and it arrived on time and assembled perfectly. This place is out of the way for me but I will be a regular customer from now on.”

4.8 Superb89 Reviews

“This is an unbelievable store to deal with number one. The staff all are completely educated with Plumbing along with some senior guys. They have to answer the hard questions. They have a great back office and they’re very competitive with their pricing. I wouldn’t go anywhere else in my Plumbing needs.”

4.8 Superb57 Reviews

“This may be the best Harbor Freight I have ever shopped at. I'm very glad it is now my local one after moving to the neighborhood. If you need any help with anything related to the store or its products, Christine is absolutely the finest Harbor Freight team member I have encountered. She took it as a personal mission to make sure my Insider Track membership was adjusted after multiple dead ends on my end of getting it to work. Its rare to see such dedication and pleasant folks just running a store so well. Thanks again for everything and see you soon.”

4.6 Superb61 Reviews

“The shopping experience here is great; far better than the big box stores. Not only are you greeted personally when you come in but for a small store they have an amazing inventory. Not only are they fully stocked with inventory but if you have problem to fix and have not been able to figure out a solution the owners often can make a suggestion that enables you to fix the issue. Great place to frequent and support. John B”

4.7 Superb68 Reviews

“If you need help with your painting needs, Destiny is the person to see, She is one of the most pleasant and helpful sales associate I've had the pleasure to deal with. Thanks Destiny.”

4.6 Superb88 Reviews

“Larry and John are amazing! They know what they are doing in and out. Outstanding service! Respectful and fun. It is a great pleasure to go to this place for advice or to buy equipment. They are hard working, responsive and reliable team. I got loan mower and weed trimmer there. Very happy with my purchase.”

4.7 Superb43 Reviews

“There couldn't be a nicer more professional more knowledgeable rental location in the world. If you go anywhere else you're doing yourself a disservice.”

4.8 Superb50 Reviews

“Employees are always friendly and pretty knowledgeable. Everything is fairly priced. I will usually come here first before I hit a big box store to get a tool or other gear. It does whay it needs to do and you can't complain about that.”

4.2 Good180 Reviews

“Ace is definitely the place to get everything you need for your home and business. They have the best selection of quality products at the lowest prices. Everytime I've been there all the employees have been extremely helpful and courteous. They are extremely knowledgeable regarding paint and recommending the right products to complete any job. East Setauket Ace has never let me down. It's the best hardware store I've every been to. I highly recommend Ave East Setauket.”

4.3 Superb95 Reviews

“Now my second experience here and both times I was in a jam with needing to get some hoses to get back up and running for my business. Without fail they were able to get it done and get me working again, all within a half hour. If you need any hose repairs for your business or personal use I would definitely come to them!!”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“had a great experience at Ace Hardware in Port Jefferson, thanks to Charlie. He was friendly, patient, and genuinely helpful took the time to make sure I found exactly what I needed and explained things clearly without rushing me. It’s always nice to walk into a store and feel like someone actually cares about helping. Charlie’s customer service really stood out and made the visit easy and pleasant. I’ll definitely be coming back!”

4.2 Good113 Reviews

“What a wonderful little shop! Feels like taking a step back into history—because it is—but more importantly Scott and Holly always either have what you need or, if they can order it, they do so in a heartbeat. Two of the friendliest, most helpful people you'll meet. Save yourself a trip to some corporate, faceless, big box store with self-checkouts and swing by Gray's Hardware and Paints instead!”

4.6 Superb42 Reviews

“There is something to be said for local shops. I bought the wrong paint and James and Vicky were so accommodating and friendly and helped me out in the return of a custom paint. While we were doing the return and processing the new paint, we shot the breeze and got to know each other. Ill go here first for any home needs I have for the next 20 years. People make a company. And all customers want these days is a sense of community and nice people to talk to. A nice chat and friendly smiles reminded me of why I love living here. Give these two a nice Christmas bonus - they earned a customer for life for your business. Honestly.”

4.3 Superb47 Reviews

“We order from Desunia for our small cabinetry shop and items always arrive in a timely manner and all contact with them has always been friendly and helpful. Thank you for being so easy to work with!”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“I have been going to Sider Lumber for my windows, doors, lumber, moldings, siding, roofing, hardware...you name it really - for over 30 years. The staff are all very knowledgeable and eager to assist clients. They go out of their way to find solutions and offer advice on the best products for my projects. And most importantly, they are trustworthy. They provide the great service and customer experience you would expect from a small town family business with all the benefits of large scale national company such as a quality showroom, large selection of in stock tools and supplies, extremely competitive pricing and a large selection of the nations top brands for just about all home building materials.”

4.3 Superb38 Reviews

“Had my partener order from here for a House I was building about a month ago. Was extremely pleased with my order, everything came out beautifully with no issues. Workers were friendly. Danny answered all questions sufficiently and was straight forward. I recommend this place to anyone looking to purchase good quality materials.”

4.8 Superb12 Reviews

“Made a delivery here. Everyone is very friendly. Delivery process smooth and fast. Can park on street in front of location. Quiet street. Easy in and out. Start unloading around 8am.”

4.5 Superb8 Reviews

“Very friendly and professional. I purchased a mower / trimmer / blower package (huge box) and the whole process of being notified when it was available, and help with the pick up was handled very well.”

3.9 Good221 Reviews

“I would like to complement Sunayana, a sales associate in the outdoor garden department in the So. Setauket. Her assistance on May 20, 2026 was exceptional. She offered me an option to open a Home Depot credit card and she was kind enough to escort me to my car to help unload my purchases. She is a valuable asset to the store.”

3.9 Good199 Reviews

“It is close to home and the people who work there actually know where things are unlike the big chain stores. They have basically everything you'd need for house projects.”

4 Good86 Reviews

“Such great people and customer service! I recommend them to all my friends and family! They are my go to if I need any electrical supplies. Their customer service is amazing and I will definitely be ordering with them again!”

4.1 Good21 Reviews

“So needed a new front door lock, went to depot first and received 0 help trying to track down the correct lock, when I figured it out I couldn’t get keys and I don’t like the self service machine, now headed to Lowe’s in lake grove, fretted as I walk in this employee asked what I needed then walked me straight to the locks, he made 4 extra keys and tested them onsite… that’s what service is about…”

3.9 Good92 Reviews

Related topics