Hardware Stores near Setauket- East Setauket, NY

27 locations found near Setauket- East Setauket

“Two years ago my 8 year old Ariens snowblower would not move it needed new belts they picked it up and also did complete tune up and we did not get much snow until 2026 well it worked like it was new.Thank You MVP.”

4.5 Superb46 Reviews

“Once again a great hardware store! Has everything you need! Went in to get 4 keys made up for my front door and every one of them was cut perfectly! No wait, courteous employees”

4.1 Good100 Reviews

“Brinkmann’s is a solid, reliable place to shop with a really positive experience overall.

The staff stood out right away—super friendly, helpful, and genuinely willing to assist without making you feel rushed or overwhelmed. That kind of service makes a big difference.

They also had what was needed when other places didn’t, and pricing felt fair and reasonable for what was offered. The store itself is clean, well-organized, and easy to navigate, which makes finding items quick and stress-free.

Overall, it’s a dependable spot with great service and a smooth shopping experience.”

4.9 Superb115 Reviews

“amazing customer service. i was in and out in less than 5 minutes because i was helped with my list of tools i need for my electrical class. they had everything i needed for an amazing price!”

4.9 Superb88 Reviews

“Very well stocked hardware store (about to become larger with a move down the road, construction in progress). Expert paint color matching to a sample from your wall, worked perfectly both times I used this service.”

4.6 Superb107 Reviews

“Asked around for some help repairing my window screens and I'm so glad I did. These guys were so helpful, turned around my screens swiftly and for a good price. I understand now they also sell snow blowers and lead blowers etc and do the maintenance, so I want to plug them for those services as well.”

4.7 Superb72 Reviews

“Employees are always friendly and pretty knowledgeable. Everything is fairly priced. I will usually come here first before I hit a big box store to get a tool or other gear. It does whay it needs to do and you can't complain about that.”

4.3 Superb181 Reviews

“This place is the best! I couldn’t run my business without the help and service they provide. Steve behind the counter is super knowledgeable about everything the sell and the applications their parts are used for. He goes out of his way to help his customers.”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“There couldn't be a nicer more professional more knowledgeable rental location in the world. If you go anywhere else you're doing yourself a disservice.”

4.8 Superb51 Reviews

“I am truly grateful for the help Nick gave me. I called in at 4:55 closing time is 5 o’clock. Nick was empathetic towards my situation, I had no heat.
He gathered the parts that I needed to correct my problem . He left them outside the store so I could pick them up and not go through the night without any heat. He also offered me his personal cell phone and encouraged me to call him , and he would walk me through the repair.
This was truly a unique experience that will stay with me for a long time. Nobody does business like these people , I will never go to another plumbing supply. I highly recommend Central Islip Plumbing Supply !!”

5 Superb23 Reviews

“Couldn’t be happier with the customer service from Mike the manager! He personally helped me choose a Weber grill for my new house and after delivery when I was confuse as to how the temp gauge works he took the time out on the phone on a Sunday afternoon to explain! Just moved into the area and will surely return there for all my home and hardware needs. Thanks for everything Mike!!!!”

4.2 Good117 Reviews

“Friendly neighborhood hardware store! I called ahead of time to verify store was open on New Year’s Day and was helped by a very friendly knowledgeable employee. I asked about a salt to drive my walkway and they offered me information and pricing on multiple options! When I got to the store another very kind employee directed me to the product options and offered to bring my purchase out to my vehicle. Great customer service and great store.”

4.5 Superb26 Reviews

“I called North East Equipment just three days before a major storm, and they had my snowblower repaired and back to me right away. Very professional, responsive, and easy to work with. Highly recommend.”

4.2 Good40 Reviews

“I have been going to Sider Lumber for my windows, doors, lumber, moldings, siding, roofing, hardware...you name it really - for over 30 years. The staff are all very knowledgeable and eager to assist clients. They go out of their way to find solutions and offer advice on the best products for my projects. And most importantly, they are trustworthy. They provide the great service and customer experience you would expect from a small town family business with all the benefits of large scale national company such as a quality showroom, large selection of in stock tools and supplies, extremely competitive pricing and a large selection of the nations top brands for just about all home building materials.”

4.3 Superb38 Reviews

“The ramen is absolutely delicious and nutritionally balanced. The good-for-you fiber from okra and bamboo shoots,Vitamin K. The nutrition from eating raw soft-boiled eggs. The pure flavor of bone broth,Awesome ramen”

3.9 Good213 Reviews

“The Location is extremely convenient for short days you dont want to travel to Home Depot or Lowes. Everytime I start a project, I always forget something, and this place is my go to!”

4 Good90 Reviews

““We would like to recognize the Tool Rental Department Manager on Pond path Homedepot “Francis Weik” for providing exceptional customer service and leadership. His was very knowledgeable, & professional, and went above and beyond to ensure we had the right equipment for our project. The rental process was smooth, efficient, and well-organized. His attention to detail, willingness to answer questions, and commitment to customer satisfaction truly stood out. It’s clear Francis Weik takes pride in his department and work hard to create a positive experience for every customer. Thank you for your outstanding service.” A+++ We highly recommend and will continue our service with him. Many Thanks!”

4.4 Superb37 Reviews

“Such great people and customer service! I recommend them to all my friends and family! They are my go to if I need any electrical supplies. Their customer service is amazing and I will definitely be ordering with them again!”

4.1 Good21 Reviews

“Thanks to Brian and the team at Taylor rental we had everything we needed for a party outside: tent, tables, chairs, linens. Brian is very organized and professional, follows up, and made helpful suggestions. The team arrived on time to install the tent, which was sparkling clean, and completed everything in short order. We highly recommend this company.”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“L.I.Hardware is the perfect place to get all sorts of things you need for your home/yard/project. The people working there are all so friendly and helpful, and as someone who does a lot of d.i.y.fixes, I'm happy they're just around the corner!”

3.7 Good99 Reviews

“Michael Deangelo extended me a great deal of service and guidance about the products I was looking for home kitchen. Good Luck

Also Ms Cathy was able to provide best cooperation.

Thanks to both and thanks to Home Depot”

3.7 Good206 Reviews

“Shout out to Theresa F. for her help with our small order to fix our church sign. Prompt, courteous, helpful service is so rare these days! A highly successful experience!”

3.4 Good8 Reviews

“Compliments to Chris working in the carpentry dept. Very helpful, thorough, knowledgeable, and kind. Thank you.

Adding on, compliments to Jeremy in Customer Service who went out of his way to help with a rental issue.”

3.6 Good200 Reviews

“My favorite Lowe’s on the island. I’m a local contractor I shopped here for the past 15 years and I’m here 2-3 times a week, friendly staff and clean store”

3.5 Good272 Reviews

“Empire Tractor Parts has been a fantastic resource for our equipment needs. They offer a wide range of high-quality parts, and their team is knowledgeable and always willing to help with any questions. Their fast shipping and reliable service have made them a go-to for our business. Highly recommend Empire Tractor Parts for anyone in need of quality parts and excellent service!”

3.1 Average23 Reviews

“Friendly, helpful staff. An item not at the Lowe's I was visiting was at another Lowe's 20 minutes away, the friendly staff told me. Went to the other Lowe's and completed my purchasing. Their prices were less than their competition for the items I needed today. However, they are a slightly longer drive from me. Lowe's wins today :)”

3.4 Good257 Reviews

Related topics