“Simple Good always has something special, whether it's a gift for someone else, or a personal treat. The pieces I have from this store make me feel elegant and professional, unlike anything else I own. The staff is very friendly and approachable. It also feels good knowing that the store mitigates problematic consumerism by focusing on a mission of eco-friendly and sustainably sourced goods. Highly recommend.”
“This place is absolutely amazing! I come here every Christmas and also throughout the year. The staff always welcomes me and is always so helpful, especially for a young guy that doesn’t have a woman’s touch on fashion and what’s in and what will look nice! Highly recommended to everyone!”
“What a great little shop in the heart of the Main Street, Port Jefferson strip. Just a block or so from the water, this appropriately themed little gift shop had something perfect for everyone in our group! I found the wind chime I've been looking everywhere for, to go along with my preexisting birdbath. Yup.. that's a home run! Thank you!”
“I love this little town so much! As a college student, it makes me look forward to life post graduate! This shop is so wholesome and friendly. It’s the perfect place to shop for self care or a thoughtful gift for a loved one. Their custom scents are Everything!!! I’ve recently purchased the lavender perfume as a gift to myself for passing my road test. Cheers to future visits!”
9:30AM - 7:30PM
600 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma
Gift Shops
“The owner is a sweetheart. I looked all over for special little gifts for my daughter’s bridal shower but couldn’t find what I wanted anywhere. I came into her shop and just fell in love with so many little unique gifts. It’s great to know when I need something special this will be my go to place.”
“Mandalay Bayabas Bayou, Westbury berry. Old english alcohol, salem butterball turkey with rosecrans crips cranberry chinooks and crannys, new england chlamydia chowder. SoViet Cong KooGular warhead. Buttermilk Channel Chicken and waffles with Atlantic City blue crabs and chlamydia. Roscosmos chicken and waffles. salem oregon clackamas xmas. strain GMO OG vs organiQQas...disparity dish parity. York peppermint patty, reaps mint, spearmint, poker shark. NY ballers RIP. Mandalay Sand Dollar General.”
11:30AM - 5:30PM
813 Montauk Hwy B, Bayport
Gift Shops
“This little store has a rainbow of beautiful stained glass creations hand made by artists Sandy and her daughter Kathy. Pick a beautifully crafted sun catcher, a piece of unique jewely, or a nightlight, or go big with a stained glass bowl or wall hanging. Sandy and Kathy will even etch a message with a name if you'd like. I love my choice: a map of Long Island on glass made with tiny glass fragments and etched with an anchor and "Long Island "”
“I can’t say enough good things about them. I have used them multiple times their service is always fast and kind. This week as they transition to a new store owner and their systems were down. I came in for a last-minute purchase. They were quick to help me. They were not able to get the system back up In a timely manner that they offered to cover my purchase. To me that speaks Remarkable customer service!! I will definitely be returning and keep using them!!”
“5 star nice ppl nice store. THAT said I will not return. Large women with brittle blond hair is rude. . For no reason other than it's who she is . I spend 150 a week there an will go elsewhere. A person can be many things so why not be kind.”
11AM - 8PM
313 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove
Gift Shops
“ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!! I dealt with Alex from Lake Grove and he was incredible. So helpful and very sincerely involved with the customization and making sure you are happy with your choice. He helped me choose the right size crystal and made some adjustments to make sure it looked perfect. This was a birthday gift for my mom and he was determined to make sure it was great!! He made the 3D look amazing when I was nervous about the photo and was very passionate about what he was doing. Amazing service and so quick, only 3 days max!! Highly recommend and will definitely visit again!!”
“This very quaint store has many gift items like; candles, cards, cups, costume jewelry, stuffed toys, childrens books, Hallmark itmes and cards. It is well designed and it has a nice Mom and Pop vibe.”
“I recently ordered from Edible Arrangements for a friend's birthday, and I was genuinely impressed. The fruit was super fresh — like, you could actually taste the difference — and the arrangement looked exactly like the picture online (which never happens). Delivery was smooth too; it arrived right on time with everything still cold and crisp.
The only thing I'd say is that it’s definitely a bit pricey for the size, but honestly, you’re paying for the presentation and the quality, and in this case, it felt worth it. My friend absolutely loved it, and it made the gift feel a lot more special than just sending flowers or chocolates. Would definitely order again for a special occasion.”
“Great service! Had to put a plush animal toy on hold for a few days for a pick up. Item was confirmed and placed on hold. Picked it up last evening. My Mom is obsessed with her gift!”
“Sooner or later people are going to realize you can't just order everything online you need to touch feel smell and see what a great tragedy it will be if we lose all of our walls I love coming here when I can it's always clean they always have what you need and what you want I hope and pray you never leave thanks for always being there.”
“Great selection of cards and balloons.Nice gifts for all ages ranging from trading cards to cigars to Lennox figurines.Friendly owners. It's a real community store.”
“This place is perfect to run in and get cards and gift supplies. They have some really nice giftables here too... And I always grab some scratch offs for my cards too.”
11AM - 6PM
230 E Main St, Port Jefferson
Gift Shops
“I always find something I want here, and as a minimalist, take that for what it is. While I find the books overpriced, everything else is actually a good deal, and a very curated collection of oddities but not usually creepy ones (except those scorpions). Always a great selection of essential oils and beautiful little jewelry pieces. This time I walked away with one roll-on perfume, one essential oil blend, a beautiful pair of delicate sterling silver earrings, and a big lunar moth ring.”
“The new owner is so nice. I always choose the same place to play my lotto & scratch offs. This is my new place. Remodel looks fantastic. New fun stock. I always pop in here first before my bagel, pizza or Chinese stop. I recommend this location to everyone shopping or eating looking for a quick greeting card/lottery purchase and much more.”
“This was the last gift shop I stopped at on my tour of Port Jefferson on May 2. They had by far the most unique items out of the other gift shops in the area. I got a cool shark shaped mat for my room and a sculpture of an octopus for my shelf. The female owner was very kind in answering my questions about her cute little store. They’ve been open for many years and they have things you won’t find anywhere else.”
“Hands down the nicest staff! I always order from here for local pick up or deliveries they have the freshest fruit and cleanest store location I’ve experienced. Highly recommend this location!”
“I had a minor issue with my original order due to miscommunication. Upon contacting the store, they immediately and without hesitation sent a delivery that exceeded my expectations. It looked better than the picture on the EA website! I am very pleased and I highly recommend this specific store for all occasions! Thank you for making a special moment, extra memorable!”
“I’ve ordered from Edible Arrangements a few times now and it’s always been a great experience. The fruit is fresh, everything tastes amazing, and the presentation is beautiful. The staff is super helpful and so friendly every time. Easily the best Edible Arrangements spot in Long Island – highly recommend!”
“Very pleased. I placed an order as a gift that was either stolen or delivered to the wrong address, which is not the stores fault. I spoke with Ahmad (I hope I spelled this right) and he was extremely personable and accommodating. He was willing to make things right immediately by delivering the same arrangement again at no charge. This is a location you can trust. Thank you for the amazing customer service! Will def shop here again!”
“I have been to this location multiple times and would definitely recommended!! The customer service is always amazing. The staff are very friendly and go above and beyond when helping me through the process of picking an arrangement. The arrangements are always beautifully made and the fruits they use are fresh!”