Gift Shops near Wantagh, NY

“Great shop. Always stop in for gifts, tea, brown bread. Ann and Ellen are two of the friendliest ladies. There are always new gift ideas for your friends and family ( sweaters, ornaments, Irish imports, jewelry, home decor)”

“Went here to pick up some quick Mother's Day gifts - you can't be surprised that the prices are a tiny bit higher than normal, it's a boutique and they have some really good quality stuff!I don't think I'd necessarily buy clothes from here as that's what has the heftiest price tag - but their house decor and little gifts are SO cute!!!They have an extensive jewelry section and the cutest little trinkets - even gifts for baby showers, bride-to-bes, etc.I'm so glad they moved closer to me (they used to be in Seaford) and I can't wait to come back! The owner is also really really sweet :)”

“I have made many platters for my friends getting engaged using this company. It is so easy to send the pictures and text that you want! The women who work for this company are very detail oriented and make the product exactly like asked. These items make a great gift and everyone loves it! Highly recommend for the next time you want a personalized gift!! Also so amazing that they can be washed and don't tarnish at all!!”

“Jerry is the absolute best my crystal had me in tears much better then I ever expected.Jerry was super patient and kind and I recommend everyone go check him out….”

“Amazing,I needed the arrangement within an hour and had to pay cash.I got here early and everything was perfect…So happy and Iam sure my gf recovering from surgery will be as well”

“A great store. What a wonderful owner. A pure gentleman. The store has plenty of lovely merchandise. The prices are fair. A great place for your holiday needs. In addition, pop in and browse
the jewelry”

“This place is so awesome! Friendliest people I've met in so long. Super attentive and warm, welcoming, and courteous. Very kind people with excellent service and attention to detail. So happy to have walked into this storefront and met the staff. Super clean super pro.”

“I have to be honest—after two incredibly frustrating calls with other Edible Arrangements locations, I was bracing myself for yet another letdown when I reached out to the Melville store. On Valentine’s Day morning at 11:37 AM, I placed an “hour delivery” order for a sweet surprise for my son’s pre-K teachers—something small but meaningful, especially as I’d be attending their class party later that afternoon. By the time I arrived at the school at 1:45 PM and the teachers hadn’t received anything, my heart sank. The clock was ticking, school ended at 2:30, and I had spent over $100 on what was now looking like a missed moment.

I called the original store I placed the order with—one I’d already given over $300 in business that same day—and not only were they unhelpful, they were borderline rude. No accountability, no urgency, no “let’s fix this.” Just excuses and attitude. I was told it wasn’t their responsibility, redirected to another store, and hung up more frustrated than when I started. The second location? Even worse. I was told, verbatim, “there’s no such thing as one-hour delivery on a holiday.” And when I pushed back, I was talked over, dismissed, and ultimately rushed off the phone with zero resolution. At that point, I was ready to call corporate and demand a refund across the board.

And then… I saw the email confirmation—it pointed to Edible Arrangements in Melville. Honestly? I was ready to fight.

But the moment I spoke to Erika, Brandy, Maria, and Mike, everything shifted. They were kind. They were calm. They were solutions-focused, even though this mess had nothing to do with them. Instead of deflecting blame, they said: “We’ll make it right.” And they meant it.

Not only did they track down the order, reroute it, and ensure it was delivered within 15 minutes, but they also added two extra items—on their own dime—as an apology for the delay. That kind of service is rare. And that kind of heart? Even rarer.

Let me be clear: the Melville team saved the face of two other stores that completely dropped the ball. I won’t call those stores out by name (because I’m not here to publicly drag businesses), but I will say this: I’ll never order from them again. Melville is the only Edible Arrangements I’ll ever use from this point forward.

Corporate should be thanking Erika, Brandy, Maria, and Mike—not just for protecting the brand, but for truly embodying what customer service is supposed to look like. Their professionalism, empathy, and hustle turned a disaster into a reminder that good people still exist—and they just happen to work in Melville.

To anyone placing an order: Don’t risk your money—or your special moments—on stores that can’t follow through. Go with Melville. Every time.

Thank you again to the entire team—you didn’t just deliver fruit, you delivered hope. And I’ll never forget it.”

“Lovely shop - truly something for everyone to treasure here. This is the kind of place where you'll find something that will delight you and others (everyone always asks me where did I get such and such and I always send them here!). Makes sense - the staff are warm and truly want to support your needs.

It is a very thoughtfully curated shop with high quality, trendy and timeless clothes (women's, teens, children's and men's!), home goods, jewelry and accessories. They also have a very sweet section of books, activities and toys for children.

Beautiful and well curated shop of unique finds, well priced and quality materials, and exceptionally kind and helpful staff. A must visit if you're in the area!”

“I had a wonderful shirodhara treatment with Laura. From the moment I walked in to Joyful Treasures I felt at ease… everyone I encountered had such amazing, warm energy. The shirodhara experience was incredibly relaxing and rejuvenating, Laura's expertise and calming presence made it even more special. I left feeling refreshed and at peace. So grateful to have this experience and will absolutely be back again!”

“If I could give this store 10 stars I would! Absolutely the best gift store around. So many items to choose from. Baby, home, bridal, college, etc.... They can personalize just about anything and the employees are so helpful. And... free gift wrapping that's so pretty!!”

“The edible arrangements were so good I wish I took pictures.. it was for my sister’s wedding and honestly every body ate through it so quickly!!

The strawberries and bananas were so fresh and sweet the best part of it was I took some home and 2 days later they still tasted fresh!! I think this might be my go to spot. Highly recommended”

“Thank you Melanie for making the beautiful candy bouquet when I walked into your story yesterday, you made a little girl with a broken arm very happy! I can’t wait to come back when I need another adorable gift or host a party!”

“Amazing card store..!! you will find any card in this place. Amazing selection of gifts for all occasions! Workers are always smiling and very helpful! Best 50%off card store on Lo g island!”

“Nelson at the Garden City location was extremely helpful and accommodating.

I would highly recommend this location because of his customer service alone.

Product was delivered in very good condition.”

“One of the better Botanicas I go to on Long Island. They just don't have the fresh herbs for the Spiritual Baths. However every other ingredient can be found here. They have mats, cascarilla, candles, small charms if you're into that, Esu Aye at the door. A kind Santera (Omo Oshun) runs the place. ?? ?⚡??”

“Simply Super stationery-papers, wrappings, cards, candies, cigarettes, very small items, very small gifts, notions, very small beverages; &, very small snacks selection, a few toys, many stuffed animals, lottery tickets; &, a small choice of useful household items kind of place.In general; &, especially, in the sense, of both of the Mom; &, Pop, co-owner's vibes; moods; approach; sensibilities; attitudes; feelings; &, policies; they're quite welcoming; accepting; tolerant; giving; accepting; &, embracing folks.At their quarters that they have, now; at this point; they are downsized to rather much smaller proportions; to state the barest minimum in descriptions; &, their, current customer demands are scarce; &, very narrow in sales scope; they, are therefore: few; &, far between; &, their stock of inventory is slight; restricted; &, gigantically limited; but, their hearts are: surely, filled w/: overflowing respect; &, assorted abundance. However, they have been local shopkeepers for quite a very long time.Their business codes of conduct in: commerce; transactions; &, personal demeanor; certainly guide; &, reflect all of that; as, both: George; who is: tolerant; patient; amiable; amenable; hapless; slow-going; accessible; available; present; understanding; &, accomodating; etc.; amongst his many other good characteristics; &, his, long-term: hugely devoted; undyingly loyal; highly caring; &, extremely loving; very concerned; &, greatly warm; elegant; classically tasteful; high-class; quietly, very shy; naivete-infused; and, rather conservative, spouse: Mini; who is an ->huge; frequent; &, regular help to him; in many ways; in the, constant; ongoing operation, of their business; &, their store; have both found ways, that they are enabled, w/: God's assistive support, to let those great qualities, that they mutually possess, shine through; &, be expressed; consistently, in their business practices; &, professional conduct; &, within the insides of their, private home; &, small family lives.They are without a, doubt: some of the, gentlest; most humble; nicest; kindest; low-toned; under-keyed; easiest-going; most laid-back; most polite; &, most soft-spoken; understated; sweetest; warmest; friendliest; most accomodating; and, most sophisticated combined vendors and proprietors; as well as: local community families; and, are amongst the: most, normal; simplest; plain-est; guile-less; most, routine; most, ordinary; yet: so caring; most, >decent; most, chill; &, most amiable; liberal; tolerant; open-minded; &, accomodating, of: small hamlet; tiny shop proprietors; and, to be found in this local small community; &, its' general, immediate, surrounding area.They also happen to be: very largely involved; engaged; committed; present; &, interested types of enthusiastic; emphatic "Family People"; incusive of: family of origin; &, their greater community, at large. Their best operating practices, include: being very good group members, as regards, any roles they inhabit; whether that involves, being: store owners; &, vendors, for very many multiple long years; parents/grandparents/family members; or: small-business operators/regional citizens/and, community anchors; as well as: just good people; as one is, both: clearly; &, probably, ever likely to be: able to; or, in actuality; come to: know; meet; or: find.If one encounters nearly any problem at all; here, it most likely will be addressed w/: some sufficiently adequate solution of resolve; or: reasonable accomodation; albeit, even this elevated vendor; and, shop, are not: perfect; like >all things in the human-made world.A. - [Up-Dated: Sun.-12/24/23.].”

“This place is amazing! During the worst of the pandemic.... they went ABOVE & BEYOND with amazing customer service! They really care about their customers. If you're wanting to support local business.... this is the place to go!!!”

“Harry and his beautiful family's please keep up the wonderful work you are doing in the community you guys always let everyone that come through the door feel welcome with a smile and most of all you know most of your customers by name keep on serving the community.”

“Thank you so much!! I put my order in online the night before a holiday and they were able to have it waiting for me when I arrived a few minutes early! They were so sweet and gave me a bag to keep it cooler knowing I was going down to the beach for a proposal! They came out perfect! (Pictured is out in the sun a little melted)”

“the customer service is amazing. Great prices and selection of items. Good quality items are sold here as well as dollar items. Now they have lotto too! One stop shop for everything I need.”

“Jo was SO kind! Best customer service I’ve ever received from an edible arrangements team member. I’ll be placing more orders here thanks to her amazing service. Thanks Jo!

-Monica”

“Ali was very helpful in getting my order out! Amazing product and superb customer service. Will use them again and again for all my gifting needs! Pictures speak for themselves”