Jewelry Stores near Wantagh, NY

30 locations found near Wantagh
View Map

“Great boutique unbelievable place has a fun atmosphere with a lot of nice clothing that you don’t see in other places Leslie the owner is very nice and helpful my wife loved the gifts I got her there . Definitely will be back to shop again for the next holiday”

4.3 Superb9 Reviews

“Excellent customer service! Went here to get ring resized and they did a beautiful job. Everyone was very kind, helpful, and knowledgeable! Made an appointment and it was done within an hour.”

4.2 Good43 Reviews

“The owner was very helpful and kind. He had great knowledge of the item I brought to him. I was grateful to come across this business and will definitely come back in the future if needed.”

5 Superb362 Reviews

“J & H jewelry store is the best store around ever. The owner and the staff are welcoming and helpful without being pushy or rushing you. The inventory is amazing. I cant say enough about this store! The repair person treats your jewelry as special as you feel it is and is an expert at what she does. I highly recommend this store”

5 Superb263 Reviews

“My boyfriend and I went in today to look at engagement rings for the time. The moment we walked in the vibe was very welcoming. Donna sat with us and showed me many options and let me try on everything that I wanted. Donna answered all of our questions and made the whole experience extremely comfortable. 100% recommend this store the service was impeccable.”

4.9 Superb178 Reviews

“I had the pleasure of dealing with Mary. She was very professional, knowledgeable, and helpful with assisting me in selling some pieces of my jewelry. Highly recommend Great American Jewelry! Thank you again for all your help!”

4.9 Superb150 Reviews

“I have been going to Forever Diamonds for a couple of years. Never a bad experience! From buying jewelry to replacing batteries to steam cleaning they are great. They are friendly and most important, they don't pressure you into anything. They want you to enjoy what you purchased. So nice to have small businesses you can go to and be happy”

4.9 Superb148 Reviews

“Simply amazing. Bennett and his team (Natalie, Danny, & Naheed to name a few) truly went above and beyond to deliver a white-glove experience that is second to none.My custom engagement ring and wedding bands came out exactly how I had envisioned them and the quality and attention to detail is impeccable. The team did a great job of educating me on my options and I left feeling awesome about my purchase. To further sweeten things, I also went home with my dream watch!I highly recommend stopping by Kravit for your jewelry and watch needs. You will not be disappointed and their brand new showroom is pure luxury. I hope to be a client for years to come.”

4.9 Superb137 Reviews

“Great customer service and communication. Very friendly and knowledgeable businessman. Was not greedy at all and Eddie was willing to work with me on prices. Very efficient at sourcing timepieces as well. Great inventory and even better customer service. Will be doing business at Lana’s again for sure!”

4.9 Superb123 Reviews

“I hardly recommended this jewelry, this guy did some heart design jewelry for my mother in lawI came to get fix few things great prices .Thanks Sir to keep good work”

4.9 Superb119 Reviews

“Chris and Nuha are the BEST! Incredibly easy to deal with, the jewelry is magnificent and prices are super. I have even had Chris customize a piece for me and it was outstanding. By not buying from a reputable jeweler you are making a big mistake. Nuha and Chris are honest, helpful and cannot do enough for you. They are my go to jeweler!”

4.9 Superb111 Reviews

“I had an outstanding experience with Maddy's Fine Jewelers in Woodbury, NY! They sized my watch and engraved a second watch beautifully. The customer service was top-notch, and the quality of their work is phenomenal. Their store also offers a fantastic selection of jewelry pieces for purchase. Highly recommended – 5 stars!”

5 Superb73 Reviews

“Lori was very helpful and friendly. Sometimes situations in life may bring you into places like pawnshops and what you hope for is a no judgment zone and a friendly environment and that’s what I gotThanks”

5 Superb68 Reviews

“My boyfriend just proposed with the most stunning ring from Gennaro Jewelers- we are so happy with the final setting and he was so thrilled to feel like family working with Angela and the rest of the team. The most special day of our lives- thank you for your knowledge, keen listening, and attention to detail, true experts and would HIGHLY recommend!”

4.8 Superb169 Reviews

“I was just in store to have watch band adjusted. He did a great job and took his time. He even explained how the adjustments were done. He was very nice and patient. The store is very clean and beautiful. The store has a great selection of jewelry and watches. I highly recommend to everyone!”

5 Superb61 Reviews

“Shamara at the Hicksville location offered exceptional customer service. I was more than satisfied with her professionalism and assistance with getting me the best price for my item. Definitely recommended and will be returning!”

4.9 Superb83 Reviews

“Had a great experience at HL Gross. Krysi is friendly , courteous and patient as she took the time to answer all of my questions and followed up with me when i reached out via email. She went above and beyond in helping me with my purchase as she delivered as promised.i highly recommend this store and will be doing more purchases.an update 10/19/23, Krysi came through once again for a special occasion . Thank you”

4.8 Superb142 Reviews

“I’ve lost count of how many years I’ve been going to Good Old Gold and I wouldn’t think about going anywhere else. They are a family operated, professional, friendly, helpful go out of their way for you kind of place. The atmosphere is comfortable and elegant. While everyone is attentive and quick to assist my absolute favorite is Amy! Working with her to make one of a kind pieces has been exciting, fun and I couldn’t be happier with the results.”

4.8 Superb134 Reviews

“Just purchased pre owned watch from Eddie and best buying experience ever. Paid via wire transfer and had the watch in hand in 24 hr. Watch was just as described and beautiful. Great service.”

4.8 Superb100 Reviews

“Working with Kamni on my engagement ring for my fiancée was a wonderful experience. She was collaborative, creative and worked with me through picking out stones as well as the overall design i had in my head. Her signature style she adds to every ring is a beautiful accent to the ring.I can’t wait to get our wedding bands and future jewelry from her.”

4.9 Superb62 Reviews

“Stacey and her team really know jewelry! They are friendly, sincere and welcoming. They carry a beautiful array of jewelry and Stacey is a talented designer who will help you redo an old piece or design something new and beautiful. Whether it's a simple repair or a fabulous new purchase it is always a pleasure to shop at Solomon Jewelers.”

4.9 Superb61 Reviews

“My family has been going to Candy's Jewelers for many years and have always been very happy with the quality of service and merchandise. Great family tradition.”

4.8 Superb90 Reviews

“Excellent family-owned jewelry store. Chris and Matt were a pleasure to work with. They take the time to work with you and find exactly what you are looking for. They beautifully customized an engagement ring for my girlfriend. I would highly recommend them.”

5 Superb44 Reviews

“Such a pleasant experience shopping at Charles Krypell! The staff is incredibly friendly. Sal was so helpful and patient and not at all pushy like you find with some salespeople. My new go-to guy for all things sparkly. Highly recommend stopping in here if you are in the market for jewelry!”

5 Superb43 Reviews

“My parents have been going to Martin at Anthony Jewelers for all jewelry needs for years because of his impeccable craftsmanship, and him being a wonderful human being! I finally had the pleasure of making my own purchase with Martin - my wedding ring! He showed me a truly unique wedding band that I hadn't seen anywhere else, and I knew it was perfect for me. He then custom made it for me to match the specs of my engagement ring and it came out beautifully! The best quality ring and nicest man. Thank you Martin!!!”

4.9 Superb57 Reviews

“My experience From Italy With Love has been truly exceptional. From the attention to detail of the design to the high quality service from Jeff and his staff, they have made this process as easy and as joyful as possible. I love my necklaces. Thank you so much !!”

4.8 Superb82 Reviews

“I have known David for about 4 years now and his customer service is unmatched! He is very honest and gives you nothing but Quality. I definitely appreciate doing business here!”

4.9 Superb52 Reviews

“My family and I have been going here for years for purchases and repairs. Highly knowledgable and trust worthy jewelers. My wife loves her jewelry from there. I would highly recommend, Goldie’s!”

4.8 Superb74 Reviews

“After an unfortunate experience with a previous jeweler, My husband and I came to JEM Logics to have two pairs of earrings evaluated. Matthew took his time to inspect both sets of earrings meticulously, down to the small diamonds that make up the halo.He was able to provide us with jewelry identification reports for our records. Matthew is experienced, well-educated on gems, and was kind and patient through the whole process - answering all of our questions. I would highly recommend Matthew at Jem Logics for anyone looking to buy, or who need appraisals or peace of mind!”

5 Superb38 Reviews

“I came in with my mom, it was our first time and instantly we were helped by Mintu. As he was showing us the jewelry there was another customer who complimented his service. Their words were “ you are very pleasant to be around. Great service!” I couldn’t agree more he was patient, delightful and the pieces I did end up buying were great priced and beautiful. Definitely coming here again”

4.8 Superb70 Reviews