Supermarkets near West Islip, NY

9 Udall Rd, West Islip NY 11795

4 Good 93 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 539-0706

“Lost my Mother's ring on Mother's Day. ..it was found and turned in by a good samaritan shopper in Best Farms...thank you so much to the shopper who found it and thank you to Best Farms for keeping it safe...”

400 Union Boulevard, West Islip NY 11795

3.6 Good 135 reviews

• Today 6AM – 11PM
• (631) 661-8230

“Stop and Shop pricing is very reasonable, has a great loyalty rewards program and is always clean. The staff are always friendly and this is why I only shop here for groceries.”

700 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood NY 11717

4.5 Superb 206 reviews

• Today 7AM – 11PM
• (631) 813-2131

“You will experience kindness generosity respectfully and without doubt the most amazing people you will ever encounter that work in a store. I would go back just for the opportunity to be able to experience what customer service should be. The food flavorful you could smell the spices throughout the store and the quality of the food is nothing like you will taste. I don’t eat meat but I had to pick up dinner for my daughter and she said that I have to go back and get her another plate.”

1500 Sunrise Hwy, Copiague NY 11726

4.4 Superb 150 reviews

• Today 7:30AM – 8:30PM
• (631) 842-9800

“Took me back to the island. They all kinds of authentic home know brands and a wide variety specialty items. Everyone I interacted with was extremely courteous and cool. Stop by and enjoy the experience!”

1035 NY-109, Farmingdale NY 11735

4.4 Superb 186 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 393-2742

“For the most part, really like this store. However they are a bit pricey The biggest criticism I have is the quality of their produce. Everytime I purchase their lettuce, cucumbers they inevitably go bad WITHIN A WEEK! I do not purchase produce from them anymore! Everything else is ok”

1070 Islip Ave, Brentwood NY 11717

4.4 Superb 67 reviews

• Today 6AM – 10PM
• (631) 245-6962

“Compare is a family oriented establishment. Fresh produce, bakery and homemade cuisine in food court is a blessing to have available. They have hold community activities and also offer a Tomra recycling machines that are well maintain and ready to accept your products and claim you deposits.”

721 Broadway, Amityville NY 11701

4.4 Superb 112 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 789-4052

“A lot of really good food. Prices are ok, lot of veggies and fruits. There is a fishmarket with fresh and good lookimg sea food. Everything looks clean and well arranged. Nice music in background.”

42 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore NY 11706

4.5 Superb 74 reviews

• Today 8AM – 9PM
• (631) 242-7068

“I had an excellent experience at Dairy City Supermarket! The customer service was top-notch—everyone was so friendly and helpful. I was in and out quickly, thanks to their fast checkout process. I also grabbed a sandwich while I was there, their buffalo chicken sandwich was absolutely delicious—definitely a 10/10. I'll definitely be coming back.”

1675 Old Country Rd, Old Bethpage NY 11804

4.2 Good 204 reviews

• Today 6AM – 10PM
• (516) 694-0640

“Great choice of cooked foods. I especially enjoy the diced grilled chicken to mix with salads, add to sandwiches or warm up with potatoes or rice and vegetables. I put a little salad dressing on the grilled chicken to add flavor. The Turkey meatloaf dinner,stuffed cabbage and butternut squash with spinach and cranberries is quite delicious, too!”

100 Broadway Rd, Saltaire NY 11706

4.7 Superb 46 reviews

• Today 8AM – 7PM
• (631) 583-5522

“Love this place. Great breakfast sandwiches and their baked goods are amazing. Sandwiches are good. Good selection is pretty great considering the store footprint.”

40 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack NY 11725

4.1 Good 151 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 499-8350

“Great store great seafood selection prices very fair no self service no check line in store butcher great meats fresh bread cold cuts salids best supermarket on the island”

421 Commack Road, Deer Park NY 11729

4.1 Good 135 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 274-0931

“Rayhen was assigned to self checkout today. I have seen him before and he is always upbeat and welcoming to customers. He always greats you with a smile and willing to help if you have a question . I truly feel he should be commended as an exemplary employee. Best customer service and started my day off on a bright note.”

174 Wheeler Road, Central Islip NY 11722

4.1 Good 110 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 851-0576

“If you're looking for Hispanic Culture ingredients, baked goods, or snacks among so much more this is an excellent choice for all sorts of items you won't see in a typical supermarket depending on your area. Of course they carry many standard supermarket items.”

101 Wicks Rd, Brentwood NY 11717

4 Good 186 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10:30PM
• (631) 236-4696

“LOVE the international food isle, has my favorite Asian and Caribbean snacks, seasonings and food. Workers are also really sweet, I just wish you guys had matouks garlic sauce! You have other sauces from the brand but not the garlic 😔”

1261 Deer Park Ave, North Babylon NY 11703

4 Good 126 reviews

• Today 8:30AM – 8PM
• (855) 955-2534

“I recently shopped there not to long ago an I gotta say that the best staff that was very nice, kind, friendly and helpful was Emmy and thanks to her I look forward to shopping there again someday.”

5601 Merrick Rd, Massapequa NY 11758

4 Good 134 reviews

• Today 8AM – 9PM
• (888) 654-3515

“Great sales, their brand items aren't bad and their meats are awesome. Not to many discount supermarkets around anynore. It us handicapped accessible. Dan and Spencer are tremendous assets for your company.”

134 Commack Rd, Commack NY 11725

4 Good 138 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 462-0612

“They have good produce and a good deli department, but their meat department is lacking and that their ground beef looks terrible every day they probably re-grind yesterday‘s meat with new meat to try to make it look better and it never works that way.”

865 Lowell Ave, Central Islip NY 11722

5 Superb 18 reviews

• Today 8AM – 7PM
• (631) 439-0460

“We loved the old fashioned more for for your buck treatment. Their meat pkg deals are generous, its enough to last the month. Huge saving compared to supermarkets.”

834 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore NY 11706

4 Good 86 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 206-0759

“Merri was so sweet/funny/helpful to me. I was doing an instacart today and she went and above and beyond to help me out. It’s so nice when people don’t make you feel like you’re a pest. I had to get her name and leave a review cause it means a lot. Thx Merri ✨”

1662 New York Ave, Huntington Station NY 11746

4 Good 81 reviews

• Today 7AM – 9PM
• (631) 673-5878

“Clean, multiple fruits to choose from, fresh bread every morning, and they got a deli section if you need some ham or cheese they also have good candy/treats to choose from but sometimes the items can be a bit pricey”

350 Walt Whitman Rd, Huntington Station NY 11746

3.9 Good 83 reviews

• Today 8AM – 9PM
• (516) 587-5321

“I love this Whole Foods a lot Staff is friendly But I think they need to lower down the prices on some stuff sometimes I go to ShopRite to get things. But I will give it 4 stars”

1626 Brentwood Rd, Brentwood NY 11717

3.9 Good 91 reviews

• Today 8AM – 7:45PM
• (631) 231-3552

“Nice place to shop, prices are better on many items than big chain supermarkets, while Brand selection is not. Parking lot can be hectic at times especially with the food truck and peddlers selling rugs, lawn statues, shaved ice and cut fruit along the perimeter. People inside are friendly and helpful and the lines if there are any move very quickly. Fresh produce really is a high point here especially for Hispanic or South American cuisine.”

36 Wheeler Rd, Central Islip NY 11722

4.2 Good 5 reviews

• Today 10AM – 7PM
• (631) 714-4490

1531 Straight Path, Wyandanch NY 11798

3.9 Good 67 reviews

• Today 6AM – 10PM
• (631) 491-7404

“Member of 'too good to go'.We tried their steam table meals . . .Liked what was offered . Will try different dishes next time . Great app , with great food deals daily ..”

870 Merrick Rd, Copiague NY 11726

3.8 Good 98 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 841-1268

“Always have fresh produce- juice bar and hot food bar is amazing - I grew up in copiague and have seen so much change - I was skeptical going into the store thinking I didn't know what to expect. I've now been shopping there for a few years . The staff there I find accommodating when asking questions about different produce I've never seen before. I also find the cashiers extremely friendly. Customer service is important . I do believe the manager is doing a great job . My only gripe is the parking lot . That they can not change . You just have to be careful when navagating .”

2650 Sunrise Highway, East Islip NY 11730

3.8 Good 171 reviews

• Today 6AM – 11PM
• (631) 859-5090

“It clean, well organized store that is my go-to place. They have a large bakery section, as well as takeaway, sushi and various other pre-prepared foods. They carry a lot of brands that can be difficult to find in other stores. Their produce section is well stocked and always fresh.”

533 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

3.8 Good 174 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 665-5625

“I brought some chicken breasts over to the meat department. The gentleman that work there are very nice & accommodating. I was able to get the breasts sliced thinly. I go to Stop & Shop in West Islip quite often. I always have a good experience. The people that work there are very devoted. I feel special when I shop there because they seem to make the shoppers priority! They definitely treat and assist shoppers, like myself. THANK YOU FOR A GREAT EXPERIENCE YESTERDAY!!!”

32 Wheeler Road, Central Islip NY 11722

3.7 Good 115 reviews

• Today 7AM – 10PM
• (631) 630-1850

“This supermarket has been here for so long my grandma and grandpa used to go here so my mom still goes and I have to say they have upgraded it looks very beautiful it's clean inside and the food is fresh”

1851 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore NY 11706

3.7 Good 185 reviews

• Today 8:30AM – 8:30PM
• (855) 955-2534

“My experience was ok. There were only 2 cashiers and the lines were very long. Finally another cashier came on to help get the lines and customers out. The prices have increased, like everywhere else, but Aldi is still the cheapest store to shop at.”